Overshoes

Deliver good all-round performance in changeable conditions

Good waterproofing, warmth and fit for not a huge amount of cash

Strong, light, windproof and very usefully water resistant – and the same price as the old version

Made-to-last overshoes with effective lighting at the heels, but a very tight fit

Exceptional warmth and excellent waterproofing – better than most winter boots

Impressive breathability, warmth and versatility, but a few areas need work

Fantastic close fit from a flexible fabric that isn't fully waterproof but keeps out drizzle and spray

Impressively robust and protective toe covers, if not the cheapest

Great attention to detail for a simple product and they're very warm

Excellent at keeping out wind and water, though lacking in insulation

Good main material let down by a bad fit and poorly taped seams

Great performers and they'll get you noticed, but sizing is way off