Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

“A valuable part of the city will be lost” if cycle lane plans remove car parking spaces, artists claim

Proposals to replace 33 parking spaces with a protected bike lane have been criticised by artists who display and sell their work in the area on Sundays – though the council has noted that there are 650 spaces located within 500 metres of the exhibit

Plans to remove 33 car parking spaces to make way for a segregated cycle lane beside a Dublin park have been criticised by local artists who display and sell their work in the area every Sunday. According to opponents of the proposed cycle lane on the city’s Merrion Square, the protected infrastructure’s installation will “eliminate the artists” who park nearby, and lead to the “death of a very special tradition”.

The planned cycle lane on Merrion Square North, one side of a leafy Georgian garden square just southeast of Dublin city centre and located near the seat of the Irish parliament, forms part of an interim protected cycle route and active travel network linking Trinity College and Ballsbridge, which Dublin City Council says will provide a “safer environment for cycling” that will provide links to the city’s “important cultural and governmental institutions”.

However, the plans have been opposed in recent months by artists behind the Merrion Square Arts Exhibition, a weekly outdoor exhibit established in 1985 in which artists hang their paintings from the park’s railings, selling them to locals and tourists at a reduced rate every Sunday.

The artists behind the exhibit say the car parking spaces on Merrion Square North are essential for the transportation of their work, and that replacing them with a cycle lane will mean that a “valuable part of Dublin will be lost”.

“The artists of Merrion Square are deeply concerned with new traffic management proposals,” an email sent by one artist to councillors earlier this year read.

“Merrion Square artists have been exhibiting every Sunday for nearly forty years under an annual licence from Dublin City Council. They are a living cultural and tourist attraction unique to Dublin City.

“Removal of their ability to shelter, in wet and cold winters and summer showers, in a car adjacent to their designated exhibition space would signal the death of this very special Dublin tradition.”

> Bicycle racks in pub loading bays causing "unnecessary stress", businesses claim

Speaking to the Irish Independent this week, artist Elizabeth Prendergast said the new cycle lane would be “completely devastating for Merrion Square to be honest”.

She continued: ““When the bicycle lane goes in, it’ll remove all the parking from the north side of the square and eliminate the artists.

“It is so valuable to artists and tourists. Are there any other art exhibitions like Merrion Square in any other major capital in the world? Merrion Square is a year-round, particularly precious, resource. You can ask them to do something especially for you. You build up a relationship, it’s very personal.

“We’ve paid a license fee, we’ve paid our insurance, and we commit to being there every single Sunday of the year. It’s a huge commitment. It’s a shame they’re trying to get rid of it rather than promote it, it boggles my mind.”

Prendergast, who has been selling her art in Merrion Square for over 20 years, also claimed that concerns over the implementation of the cycle lanes have already started to affect her colleagues.

“A lot of artists have already given up because they’re just so tired of the whole worry and anxiety of whether they’re able to come in,” she said.

Merrion Square North, Dublin

Merrion Square North, Dublin

Earlier this year, Merrion Square Artists Association called on the council to use “soft” protective barriers on the lane, instead of concrete kerbs, which would enable the artists to park on Sundays, a proposed solution that was dismissed by the council, who claimed it would only “frustrate” both motorists and cyclists.

The council also noted at the time that there are close to 650 parking spaces located within a 500 metre walk of the art exhibit, including 100 on the adjacent Merrion Square South, as well as “a number of multistorey car parks”.

However, the Association has continued to urge the local authority to keep parking available on Merrion Square North on Sundays between 9am and 5pm, diverting cyclists onto an existing route in Archbishop Ryan Park in the process.

“For the artist community to survive and grow, it is essential that parking which is currently available free on a Sunday continues to exist,” a spokesperson for the Association said.

“This is essential for the artists to load and unload their work, awnings, and take shelter in their cars during adverse weather conditions and the cold. This is essential, in particular for the senior artists.

“We are not against cycle lanes, on the contrary. But there has to be an accommodation made for the artists.

“We feel they are worth consideration. We are proposing these options having observed over the years that the cycle traffic along Merrion Square North on a Sunday is very slight.”

> "There's a fear of being bullied": Cyclists don't feel "recognised" by other road users, says transport expert

While artists continue to raise concerns about the proposed cycle lane, others within Dublin City Council have also noted the potential impact it may have on parents attending the nearby maternity hospital on Holles Street.

“There’s about five and half thousand babies delivered every year across the road at the National Maternity Hospital. I am a keen cycling advocate but even I wouldn’t put a newborn baby in a bicycle basket,” Fine Gael Cllr James Geoghegan said.

“You are going to cause major disruption to both artists and potentially parents collecting their babies”.

Responding to the latest concerns, Ireland’s Active Travel Office and Dublin City Council both noted that the proposed cycle lane on Merrion Square North will not be installed until 2025 at the earliest, as part of phase two of the Greater Dublin Area Cycle Network Plan, with phase one expected to commence in the next few weeks.

“When the time comes, public consultation with interested stakeholders and residents will occur and you will all be notified of this well in advance,” a spokesperson said.

“People will be allowed to make submissions and comments on the proposed scheme before it goes to a detailed design phase. In the meantime, there is no cycle track planned for Merrion Square North.”

Ryan joined road.cc in December 2021 and since then has kept the site’s readers and listeners informed and enthralled (well at least occasionally) on news, the live blog, and the road.cc Podcast. After boarding a wrong bus at the world championships and ruining a good pair of jeans at the cyclocross, he now serves as road.cc’s senior news writer. Before his foray into cycling journalism, he wallowed in the equally pitiless world of academia, where he wrote a book about Victorian politics and droned on about cycling and bikes to classes of bored students (while taking every chance he could get to talk about cycling in print or on the radio). He can be found riding his bike very slowly around the narrow, scenic country lanes of Co. Down.

Add new comment

15 comments

Avatar
Car Delenda Est | 10 months ago
1 like

Sounds like a shelter with some seats are what they really need, but then that would open up the display to all the artists who can't afford a car..

Avatar
eburtthebike | 10 months ago
3 likes

“We are not against cycle lanes, on the contrary. But there has to be an accommodation made for the artists."

There is: the pavement.  And you are against cycle lanes.

“You are going to cause major disruption to both artists and potentially parents collecting their babies”.

OMG!  Did I read that right?  What about when a parent wants to pick up their baby and the space is occupied by an artist?

Honestly, of all the nimbys I've ever heard of, the Dublin ones beat them all.

 

Avatar
Car Delenda Est replied to eburtthebike | 10 months ago
1 like

Babies born on Sundays don't count.

Avatar
pockstone | 10 months ago
2 likes

These artists should familiarise themselves with the work of Rene Magritte and Auguste Renoir. Hats, overcoats and umbrellas ARE available.

Avatar
belugabob | 10 months ago
0 likes

Is that another parking area, on the other side of the road?
How do the artists cope, if the existing parking bays are already full?

Avatar
David9694 | 10 months ago
0 likes

not sure I'm following the "sit in our cars" bit 

Avatar
Runtilyoudrop | 10 months ago
3 likes

How about they turn up. Unload their cars. Go and park somewhere then come back at the end of the day? I'm sure if they are quick to unload this could be accommodated.

Avatar
Left_is_for_Losers replied to Runtilyoudrop | 10 months ago
0 likes

No because you can guarantee there would be a frothing cyclist who sees the vehicle parked there and make a scene about the lane being blocked. Like they have done with the regular amazon/dhl/other courier delivery drivers blocking cycle lanes we've seen. 

Avatar
chrisonabike replied to Left_is_for_Losers | 10 months ago
4 likes

"The Frothing Cyclist" would be a good name for a coffee stall.  I saw one this afternoon actually, doing business out of their cargo trike.

I wonder what would make a good name for a whelk stall?

Avatar
belugabob replied to chrisonabike | 10 months ago
4 likes
chrisonatrike wrote:

"The Frothing Cyclist" would be a good name for a coffee stall.  I saw one this afternoon actually, doing business out of their cargo trike.

I wonder what would make a good name for a whelk stall?

Whelk meat again?

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to chrisonabike | 10 months ago
4 likes

chrisonatrike wrote:

I wonder what would make a good name for a whelk stall?

If it were blocking a cycle lane, The Shellfish Parker?

Avatar
brooksby | 10 months ago
1 like

Cargo bikes, anyone? 

Avatar
sheridan | 10 months ago
1 like

"Are there any other art exhibitions like Merrion Square in any other major capital in the world?"

I've not been to the one in Dublin, so are there?  From the description and photo it looks like a few I've seen - the one on the Bayswater Road, for example: https://www.bayswater-road-artists.co.uk/

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to sheridan | 10 months ago
1 like

The most famous one in London is on Picadilly every Saturday and Sunday, with paintings hanging on the railings at Green Park all the way from the Ritz down to Hyde Park Corner. Way back in the day it was a place where you could sometimes find a lost Old Master or pick up something by the next hot new artist for a few shillings, nowadays it's more amateur tat.

Avatar
hawkinspeter | 10 months ago
7 likes

I've got nothing against street sellers and artists, but they can get annoying in tourist areas where they take up a big slab of the pavement and the more insistent hassle everyone that walks by. I reckon they should relocate to the park and maybe have semi-permanent display boards put up for them to use. If they can't park their cars, then maybe they could get a friendly cargo bike user to transport their art around.

Latest Comments