Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

"Cyclists with cameras are grassing snitches... motorists with dash-cams are responsible citizens": BBC radio discussion looks at third-party reporting; "Long-overdue": Cyclists rejoice at plan for traffic-free Cheddar Gorge + more on the live blog

Welcome to the Friday live blog with Dan Alexander, your one-stop shop for all the news, reaction and more in the cycling world as we head towards the weekend
02 February 2024, 09:12
"Cyclists with cameras are grassing snitches... motorists with dash-cams are responsible citizens": BBC radio discussion looks at third-party reporting (and why do some cyclists get such a hard time for it?)

We got wind of BBC Radio 5 Live's Nicky Campbell hosting a segment during his Thursday show about reporting third-party helmet camera and dash-cam footage to the police so, naturally, thought we'd check it out and report back...

Techalogic DC-1 Dual Lens Helmet Camera

To our delight (and relief) there were some quite interesting and sensible points raised as listeners called and texted in, while Campbell spoke to Bryn Brooker, head of road safety at Nextbase (the dash-cam brand behind the Nextbase reporting portal).

Introduced with an 'Accidental Partridge'-worthy Campbell scrambling to get through to his guest... "Hi Bryn, are you there for me, Bryn? For everyone? Ready to go? Bryn? Bring on Bryn! Are you there Bryn? HELLO! YAY!"... the presenter went on to read out a text from a listener, Ally in Newcastle: "Cyclists with cameras are grassing snitches... motorists with dash-cams are responsible citizens doing their civic duty. Symptomatic of all our transport policies really"

That's enough material for this entire blog post, to be honest. An interesting point. As per Nextbase's own figures, more than 33,500 videos were submitted to police via the National Dash Cam Safety Portal in 2023 up until the end of November, a 30 per cent increase on the same period in 2022, most apparently coming from dash-cams.

Lady Bathurst close passed by overtaking motorist during charity ride (National Foundation for Retired Service Animals)

And yet, any length of time looking at the topic in the sewers of social media will find accusations of 'grassing' and 'snitching' labelled at cyclists who do so. Less so about the other road users who do the similar. In fact, camera cyclists' bad rap even reached the Britain's Got Talent stage in 2022 as comedian, and eventual winner, Axel Blake made it past the auditions with his cyclist bit, prompting judge Amanda Holden to weigh in on cyclists with cameras that are "asking for trouble". So, for starters, why? What is it about cyclists filming and reporting road offences which causes outrage when the majority of reports to the police come from cameras within vehicles?

Amanda Holden says camera cyclists are 'asking for trouble' on BGT (via Britain's Got Talent, YouTube)

Speaking on the wider third-party reporting point, Nextbase's head of safety said: "In five years over 100,000 offences have been reported and personally I've seen this making a real difference, enabling the police to take action on dangerous drivers. For me this people doing their civic duty. If you see a dangerous driver driving recklessly, almost causing a collision, then I think most people want to do something about that."

"The police are being inundated," came Campbell's reply...

"The police are actually finding this is saving time, the great thing about the portal is it was set up with the police and traditionally if you take a piece of footage to the police they would have to fill out a witness statement, take time to fill it out. With the system that's been set up that statement is taken automatically, so all they're asked to do is look at the footage. Is action required? Yes or no. If it is the witness statement is already there, ready to go.

> Here's what to do if you capture a near miss, close pass or collision on camera while cycling

"Actually, we calculated that over the last five years it saved an estimated 91 years of police time..."

Campbell reacted: "Oh, that's an extraordinary stat... an interesting interpretation of what some people are saying is just a mountain of extra stuff for police... but, it makes sense..."

Driver close passing cyclist, Coventry (Twitter: @jaj991)

"If you think about it," Nextbase's Brooker replied. "People have got phones and dash-cams. Evidence exists. Before this portal existed the police did have to go to people's houses to collect the data or people had to fill in a witness statement manually. That time is saved and it allows them to go and do other things."

The full episode is here, the discussion about cameras and third-party reporting coming just after the hour mark...

02 February 2024, 16:55
Pro cyclists who posted racist gesture during race in China asked to teach the "values of cycling" to junior riders
02 February 2024, 16:47
One of the UK's oldest bike shops closes after 134 years in business
Langsett Cycles (Terry Robinson/CC BY-SA 2.0 DEED/Geograph)

Langsett Cycles, the Sheffield bike shop that has been in business since 1890, has closed. In a post shared on Facebook this week, the 134-year-old bike shop's closure was announced.

The owners also run a cycle hire business in Mallorca called Mallorca Bike Hire and have recently expanded the business to add a sports bar to their offering (bike hire and sport in a pub... that's all I need, to be fair), with the time now coming to "dedicate more of our time in the sunshine with our family".

"It's no secret that times are currently challenging in the cycle trade, but they won't be like this forever, spring is just around the corner," the post said.

"I believe that cycling will continue to increase considerably in the future and cycle shops do have a future, the business is solvent so if anyone is interested in taking on this historic business moving forward please get in touch via email asap... it's a gift!"

02 February 2024, 15:56
British Cycling hopes to deliver Tour of Britain and women's edition in 2024

Apologies, folks, nipped away to do something on this... 

2023 Tour of Britain stage three, Olav Kooij wins again (SWpix.com/Simon Wilkinson)

> British Cycling hopes to deliver Tour of Britain and women's edition in 2024

02 February 2024, 12:42
Turbans can reduce the risk of head injuries in cyclists but not “as effective as helmets”, study finds
02 February 2024, 12:13
"I presume that is the same as: 'A motorist at 20mph is carefully driving with care and consideration, whereas a cyclist at 20 mph is dangerously speeding and out of control'." — your thoughts on BBC camera discussion

 brooksby: "'Cyclists with cameras are grassing snitches... motorists with dash-cams are responsible citizens...'

"I presume that is the same as: a motorist at 20mph is carefully driving with care and consideration, whereas a cyclist at 20 mph is dangerously speeding and out of control."

Geoff Ingram: "Unless there is a MGIF driver behind the cyclist, at which point he is crawling along, holding everybody up."

Ah, Schrödinger, our old friend. Good to see you again...

ChasP: "I think a lot of the criticism of cyclist's reports are of phone use in slow or stationary traffic which many motorists wrongly see as ok."

Smoggysteve: "This whole culture of calling people snitches is ludicrous. Are we talking about Merseyside gang wars here or something? People will piss and moan about insurance costs rising but when efforts are put in place to try and reduce incidents on the roads ie using phones while driving or aggressive behaviour the same people will talk about grasses recording law breakers. Seriously! What do they want?"

02 February 2024, 11:59
Sometimes social media's a laugh: Comedian's startlingly accurate 15-minute city opponent vox-pops

Must have been inspired by that comic who does the parody MP skits... you know, the one where he rattles off a known conspiracy theory about 15-minute cities while speaking in Parliament... ah, wait a second...

> Tory MP attacks 15-minute city concept with known conspiracy theory

02 February 2024, 11:54
"The only motive was idiocy": Two men who pushed cyclists into ditches for “fun” handed a two-year suspended prison sentence
02 February 2024, 11:44
Rás Tailteann And Rás na mBan receive increased funding
Rás Tailteann 2022 (credit - Ryan Mallon) 7

In the week when the Tour of Britain  and Women's Tour disappeared off the UCI calendar the only positive news we've got for you comes from across the Irish Sea. Cycling Ireland has announced the Rás Tailteann and Rás na mBan races will enjoy increased funding for 2024. Wouldn't that be nice?

> How to save a bike race: Rás Tailteann organiser on keeping Ireland's biggest race alive, 'difficult second album syndrome', and why some races just mean more

The funding will be provided by the Department of Sport and with support from Sport Ireland and both races will receive an equal share of funding for the first time. Cycling Ireland thanked the relevant ministers and Department of Sport and Ireland for the support that, it says, "ensures the events take place in 2024".

Cycling Ireland Chief Executive Officer, James Quilligan, said: "Cycling Ireland is delighted to announce an increase in funding for the 2024 Rás Tailteann and Rás na mBan from the Department of Sport and Sport Ireland. Both races are led by an incredible group of volunteers, and we look forward to working with both as event partners in 2024.

> "It's like the world championship for Irish riders": Iconic Rás Tailteann stage race makes triumphant return

"The races are among the most important on the Irish calendar and showcase the very best of Irish cycling and have attracted many top international cyclists throughout their storied histories. We'd like to thank Minister Martin, Minister Byrne, the Department of Sport and Sport Ireland's support of the races."

Rás Tailteann Race Director, Ger Campbell, added: "All of us at Cairde Rás Tailteann are thrilled with the announcement of the increase in funding. With the costs involved in promoting the event it's a huge boost for the race. It will allow us to plan our budget earlier this year and put in place important structures to make the event even better. The Rás is hugely important to Ireland's sports calendar, and we look forward to the continued success for the event going forward. It's a huge boost for the event."

02 February 2024, 11:29
UCI Cycling World Championships generated nearly £2 million for Dumfries and Galloway economy
UCI World Championships in Dumfries and Galloway (Ed Sykes/SWpix.com)

[Ed Sykes/SWpix.com]

How much bang for their buck did Dumfries and Galloway Council get out of bringing the paracycling events to the region during the UCI Cycling World Championships? Plenty, according to an independent analysis of the economic impact of the six-figure investment, reported by the Daily Record.

The events, held between August 9 and 12 created a direct economic impact of £1,888,277, a figure defined as "the total amount of additional expenditure within a defined geographical area, which can be directly attributed to staging an event".

"The council's investment of £130,000 was instrumental in achieving a direct economic impact of over £1.8m for businesses in Dumfries and
Galloway," the report stated.

In the breakdown of estimated spending, it is suggested the accomodation sector would have benefited from 4,532 booked bed nights, totalling around one million pounds in extra spending, while it is estimated more than £540,000 was spent by athletes, teams, spectators and staff on food, drink and other items.

02 February 2024, 10:13
"Long-overdue": Cyclists rejoice at plan for traffic-free Cheddar Gorge
Bikmo partners with Quotezone/cyclists Cheddar Gorge(via Bikmo)

> Cyclists and pedestrians could enjoy traffic-free Cheddar Gorge once a month under new plan

This has gone down well with you lot...

alchemilla: "This is long- overdue. Good luck to them, I hope it works out and eventually gets extended. Cheddar Gorge is a site of special scientific interest with rare Cheddar Pinks growing there, and of course the goats and sheep. It's incredible that this magnificent location has been allowed to be ruined for visitors by the noise and fumes of vehicles for too long."

Rendel Harris: "Amen. Average speed cameras at top and bottom would be a good addition, I went there once early on a spring morning and it was paradise, once on a summer afternoon and it was crammed with idiots with supercars and hot hatches treating it like a rally track. Superbikes (the motorised kind) were pretty bad too."

don simon fbpe: "I'd like to see something like this in Eryri, particularly roads around Yr Wyddfa. Sounds like a great idea."

Robert Hardy: "Restricted to once a month I hope it doesn't become dominated by sport cyclists, families ambling along on their bikes, child seats and trailers amongst pedestrians at little more than walking pace presents a pleasant picture."

Dan is the road.cc news editor and joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan has been at road.cc for four years and mainly writes news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He has hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.

Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, when he's not working you'll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he'll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he's a bit strange like that.

Add new comment

31 comments

Avatar
JN35000 | 10 months ago
1 like

Just a comment on the French court case involving two motorists attacking cyclists. The report that you quoted from The Connexion reported wasn't quite exact. Other French media reports the pair were sentenced to two years imprisonment of which only one year was suspended. The remaining one year of prison will almost certainly be served at home with an electronic bracelet, as is possible in France for short prison sentences. Note as well, both had their driving licences cancelled but can repass the test in six months time, which probably means they will be back on the roads before the summer is out.

Avatar
Slartibartfast | 10 months ago
0 likes

Nothing quite makes my Friday like seeing Alistair green on road.cc. I'd highly recommend his back catalogue to anyone who likes a bit of cringe

Avatar
mitsky | 10 months ago
13 likes

My suggested response to anyone complaining about cyclists using cameras:

"Grass?
That is the language of criminals.
Your reaction/comment appears to indicate that you condone this sort of behaviour/dangerous driving.
So you are ok with people being hurt and killed by dangerous drivers?
And are you also ok with the costs of crashes being shared by EVERONE ELSE through higher insurance premiums due to the actions of dangerous drivers?
No…? So You are going to retract your comments?
I won't hold my breath.

Also, what about doorbell cameras?
If you had footage of a criminal doing something illegal but not on your property would you "grass"/"snitch" or stay silent and allow crime in your area to increase?"

Avatar
lesterama replied to mitsky | 10 months ago
2 likes
Avatar
brooksby | 10 months ago
14 likes

London could introduce SUV parking charge, Sadiq Khan indicates

Mayor says he will monitor Paris’s plan to triple levies for large vehicles and could copy policy if it cuts emissions and pollution

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/feb/02/london-could-introdu...

Avatar
Hirsute | 10 months ago
6 likes

That nicky campbell clip was still going after 30 mins.

Not very illuminating other than providing a platform for the taxi spokesman to say cyclists are unaccountable and using your phone in stationary traffic is ok.

He had no answer to Dave Sherry who said "it's all in your own hands".

The worst part was a caller talking about vigilantes and Nicky Campbell describing submiters as vigilantes - neither was challenged.

Nothing on the level of distraction that phone use causes nor the effects that last 20 -30 seconds after the phone is put down.

I did learn that sitting in a car for 10-15 minutes queuing is boring and so using a phone is ok as is the need to use a phone to tell someone you are running late. When did people become a slave to a phone?

Avatar
squired replied to Hirsute | 10 months ago
6 likes

Of course people don't really need to text someone to tell them they are running late.  The wonders of modern technology mean you can have your location shared.  In my case I have mine shared with my brother via Google maps and also livetrack on my Garmin.  If my brother is at home he can see exactly how I'm progressing on my commute and thus when I'm likely to arrive home.  No need to send any messages.  Very handy for timing dinner so that it is on the plate as I walk through the door!

Avatar
Surreyrider replied to Hirsute | 10 months ago
0 likes

I can't stand Nicky Campbell. 

Avatar
Jigzy99 replied to Surreyrider | 10 months ago
2 likes

Thank you for sharing that.

Avatar
The Larger Cyclist replied to Hirsute | 10 months ago
6 likes

"Hello Google"

"Send text message to wife"

"I'm running late"

"Send"

No need to touch the phone.....

Avatar
brooksby | 10 months ago
14 likes

"Cyclists with cameras are grassing snitches... motorists with dash-cams are responsible citizens"

I presume that is the same as

"A motorist at 20mph is carefully driving with care and consideration, whereas a cyclist at 20 mph is dangerously speeding and out of control."

Avatar
Geoff Ingram replied to brooksby | 10 months ago
6 likes

Unless there is a mgif car behind the cyclist, at which point he is crawling along, holding everybody up.

Avatar
ChasP | 10 months ago
10 likes

I think a lot of the criticism of cyclist's reports are of phone use in slow or stationary traffic which many motorists wrongly see as ok.

Avatar
Matthew Acton-Varian replied to ChasP | 10 months ago
6 likes

Some drivers need to learn the letter of the law in regards to motoring offences. And shouldn't be allowed to drive until they do.

Avatar
Daveyraveygravey replied to Matthew Acton-Varian | 10 months ago
8 likes

Matthew Acton-Varian wrote:

Some drivers need to learn the letter of the law in regards to motoring offences. And shouldn't be allowed to drive until they do.

Some drivers????  Your comment applies to almost every driver, they are particularly adept at picking and choosing which bits of the law apply to them, and when.

Avatar
Hirsute replied to ChasP | 10 months ago
6 likes

It just underplays the level of distraction - I reply that distracted driving leads to KSIs and increased insurance premiums for all.

I got this punishment pass when I challenged a driver blocking the junction whilst engrossed in his mobile phone. NFA as the numberplate did not exist on the new vehicle database for a number of weeks

 

Avatar
Smoggysteve | 10 months ago
16 likes

This whole culture of calling people snitches is ludicrous. Are we talking about Merseyside gang wars here or something? 
 

People will piss and moan about insurance costs rising but when efforts are put in place to try and reduce incidents on the roads ie using phones while driving or aggressive behaviour the same people will talk about grasses recording law breakers. Seriously ! WTF do they want? 
 

If cameras help save one death or serious injury or discourage these knobhead who put other road users in danger they are worth every penny. To those who call cyclist or drivers with cameras on grasses - go f**k yourselves. I hope you get a lengthy ban and big fine if you get caught. 

Avatar
mitsky | 10 months ago
13 likes

Bicycles are vehicles.

"What is it about cyclists filming and reporting road offences which causes outrage when the majority of reports to the police come from cameras within vehicles?"
should be
"What is it about cyclists filming and reporting road offences which causes outrage when the majority of reports to the police come from drivers?"

Avatar
Steve K replied to mitsky | 10 months ago
2 likes

mitsky wrote:

Bicycles are vehicles.

"What is it about cyclists filming and reporting road offences which causes outrage when the majority of reports to the police come from cameras within vehicles?"
should be
"What is it about cyclists filming and reporting road offences which causes outrage when the majority of reports to the police come from drivers themselves?"

I absolutely agree with your point - and your redraft is better even without the accurate 'vehicle' pedantry.

But as I can't resist a bit of pedantry myself, the first version was still accurate as cyclists' cameras are either on their vehicle or their person, not 'within' their vehicle.

 

Avatar
Matthew Acton-Varian replied to mitsky | 10 months ago
7 likes

It's simple. Drivists are inside a metal box so they are protected You don't know for certain which cars have cameras and which ones don't. There is still a level of anonymity there. Cyclists are exposed and an easy target. Cameras are mounted externally, either on the bars or more commonly on top of the helmet, in clear view.

Avatar
brooksby replied to Matthew Acton-Varian | 10 months ago
3 likes

I wonder if drivists sometimes forget that there are other drivists inside those big metal boxes, so cyclists are exposed (though still not properly human, obviously) and an easy target.

Avatar
Matthew Acton-Varian replied to brooksby | 10 months ago
2 likes

They certainly remember if there's a collision or a close call.

I had someone attempt to open my door because I didn't let them squeeze their banger in to a queue of slow moving traffic. It wasn't safe and I wasn't able. He accellerated hard out of the side road to try and aggressively force through. And bacause he failed and we were all coming to a stop he parked alongside and got out trying to threaten me. But my car has automatic external locking so the moment I drive off nobody can open the doors from outside. My young child was also present. He eventually just sped off and tried to force his way in further up the queue. Just a shame there were no coppers to see.

Avatar
Daveyraveygravey replied to Matthew Acton-Varian | 10 months ago
2 likes

Matthew Acton-Varian wrote:

It's simple. Drivists are inside a metal box so they are protected You don't know for certain which cars have cameras and which ones don't. There is still a level of anonymity there. Cyclists are exposed and an easy target. Cameras are mounted externally, either on the bars or more commonly on top of the helmet, in clear view.

I don't think you're right.  Cameras on bikes are often lights or other pieces of kit, so not necessarily any easier to see.

Avatar
Surreyrider replied to Daveyraveygravey | 10 months ago
0 likes

Agree. I see a lot of motobike riders with cameras on their helmets though.

Avatar
lonpfrb replied to Surreyrider | 10 months ago
0 likes

Helmet on camera is a significant risk and not allowed on circuits because helmets are designed and tested for use without any attachments. They cannot perform as tested with attachments and seriously increase the risk of neck injury.

Camera mounts on the tank are also a banned hazard due to the history of serious injuries caused to riders.

Fixed to the chassis or bodywork with a backup tether is the minimum.

The only successful body worn camera is chest mounted for action cameras. That tends to be protected by the instinctive reaction to curl up, assuming that a back protector is also worn.

Given the ever shrinking electronics you might expect smaller cameras but pencil cameras seem to be expensive and not very robust. So not robust enough for real life...

Avatar
stonojnr replied to Daveyraveygravey | 10 months ago
2 likes

Agreed, I ride with a 10x10cm squared PassPixi camera sign, and people still drive around me completely cluelessly not noticing it.

I think it's simply most of these people don't see not leaving enough space to a cyclist, or using a phone in a car, as a crime, which are the bulk of cyclist dashcam submissions.

Whilst car dash cams are always of that dangerous driving or crashing into things variety, which most of these people view as higher level and worthy of reporting.

Avatar
Hirsute replied to stonojnr | 10 months ago
3 likes

Essex Stats Jan

341 Extra Eyes reports
94 from cyclists
Outcomes for cyclist reports:
- Notice of intended prosecution 60 (64%)
- No further action 32 (34%)
- Advice letter 0 (0%)
- Other 2 (2%)
 
87 reports by cyclists were for close passes

 

Avatar
stonojnr replied to Hirsute | 10 months ago
1 like

Yep so close passes form the bulk of cyclist submissions, and we can guarantee the majority of non cyclists see close passes as trivial.

Hence the difference in attitudes to cycle cammers v drivers with dash cams

Avatar
lonpfrb replied to stonojnr | 10 months ago
0 likes

I humbly suggest that avoidance is better than education or enforcement both of which are hard and uncertain.
Spending £100s on camera and the effort to report is much more expensive and risky than getting a one pound white plastic tube fitted to the seatpost perpendicular to the top tube on the offside. 1.5M long provides the spacially challenged with clarity on the minimum separation to a vulnerable road user.
It's supposed to look strange and result in wide passes, usually in the adjacent lane.
Results are good and occasional challenges enable a frank discussion about the road danger caused by irresponsible road users.

Avatar
Smoggysteve replied to mitsky | 10 months ago
6 likes

I have 2 cameras on my bike. A Garmin Virb front and GoPro hero on the rear. I also have a Garmin Varia on the saddle. Both my cars have Nextbase dashcams on. I have not once had to use my bike cams to report poor road users but I've sent off car footage to the police twice. One of a taxi going through a red light that nearly caused a collision. I also had the footage of a driver reversing into my car in a car park. It was only cosmetic but they paid for the respray on the bumper. I see more and more cam footage from cars than bikes yet cyclists seem to be the target. Maybe those complaining should realise that their behaviour is the problem not the cameras. 

Pages

Latest Comments