Like this site? Help us to make it better.


Ghost bikes to be removed from New York City's streets?

Department of Sanitation plans to take away memorials to fallen cyclists

Ghost bikes, commemorating cyclists who have been killed while out riding, are set to disappear from the streets of New York City under proposals drawn up by the city’s Department of Sanitation to rid the streets of abandoned bicycles. The proposals have drawn fire from community groups that maintain that the bikes be kept as memorials to those who have died.

Under the proposals, which can be found here, the Department of Sanitation plans to remove “derelict” bicycles that are chained to public property and bear three or more characteristics from the following list:

  • It appears to be unusable.
  • It is missing parts, other than the seat and front wheel, including, but not limited to, handlebars, pedals, rear wheels and chains.
  • It has flat or missing tires.
  • The handlebars or pedals are damaged, or the rims are bent.
  • At least 75 percent of the bicycle is rusted.

In those cases, a notice will be placed on the bicycle stating that it must be removed by the owner within five days, otherwise it will be removed by the Department of Sanitation and disposed of.

However the proposals separately define a “ghost rider” as “a derelict bicycle that has been placed on public property and apparently intended as a memorial for someone who is deceased, and which may be painted white or have a sign posted on or near it, or flowers or other mementos in the basket.”

In the case of a ghost bike, none of the provisions relating to other derelict bicycles need to be satisfied, and the owner is given 30 days to remove it.

According to a report on the local news website, the proposals regarding ghost bikes have angered the city’s cyclists.

Leah Todd, spokeswoman for the NYC Street Memorial Project, said: “The rules themselves define ghost bikes as ‘derelict.’ Nobody is in favor of these rules. Nobody.”

The Department of Sanitation has made no comment on the issue beyond saying that the new rules were likely to come into effect in October, although the website said that at a meeting last week, a spokeswoman had defended the decision, saying: “We’ve noticed an increase in the number of bicycles affixed to property, including traffic signs and parking meters. These bicycles are an eyesore, a potential public safety hazard and a constant source of complaints.”

There have been clashed in the past over the removal of ghost bikes in the city. In 2007, one commemorating bike messenger Jonathan “Bronx Jon” Neese, who had been killed in Williamsburg the previous year, was removed, although it was later replaced and registered with the city. says that at that point there were 27 ghost bikes throughout the city but now there are 70. However, the website says that despite the increased number of the monuments, there does not appear to be opposition to them at local level.

The website said that in July, Brooklyn Heights’ Community Board 2 had issued an appeal for the memorials to be safeguarded, issuing a resolution that said: “We ask that language regarding ghost bikes be removed from this proposal altogether. Such rules should reflect that ghost bikes will not be summarily disposed of without special outreach procedures, to include families of victims.”

According to the website, which logs the appearance of the memorials throughout the world, the first ghost bike appeared in St Louis, Missouri in 2003 and they can now be found in more than 100 locations around the globe. As reported on earlier this year, a pair of film makers from New York City are putting together a documentary charting the international growth of the phenomenon.

According to a report in The Sun last year, more than 100 ghost bikes had been installed in the UK both at sites where cyclists had died and at other locations to remind drivers of the need to be watch out for cyclists. The newspaper added that many of those had since been removed by local councils.

One, placed at the junction of Broad Street and Parks Road in Oxford as a memorial to student cyclist Tsz Fok, who was killed in a collision with a lorry in April 2007, was removed, presumably by the council, in August of that year.

Simon joined as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment


David French | 13 years ago

Just keep the bikes in OK condition and they won't steal/remove them.

soldier1980 | 13 years ago

Get rid of the complainers and there will be no complaints.

Latest Comments