Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Judge sends "clear message" as Norfolk man jailed for 10 months for causing GBH to cyclist

Court hears aggressor harboured grudge against bike riders prior to random attack on Audax participant

A Norfolk man who harboured a grudge against cyclists has been jailed for 10 months for causing grievous bodily harm after shoulder-barging a rider taking part in an Audax event, the victim suffering a fractured hip. The judge in the case said that the sentence was “a clear message” that such behaviour will not be tolerated.

Cyclist Chris Brown, aged 61 and from Aylsham, spent two days in hospital after his hip was fractured when 52-year-old Duncan Smith attacked him on 7 December last year, reports the Eastern Daily Press.

During his sentencing hearing at Norwich Crown Court yesterday, it was revealed that Smith, who had earlier pleaded guilty to the charge, nursed a grudge against cyclists after spending £460 to repair his car’s wing mirror which had been damaged by a bike rider.

On the day he attacked Mr Brown, Smith said his wing mirror had once again been struck by a cyclist, which was playing on his mind as he returned to his home in Lamas and discovered riders in the Audax event passing by.

The court heard that he walked into the road and tried to stop riders to ask which club they were members of. It was told that although he didn’t intend to push Mr Brown from his bike on purpose, he was reckless as to the results of his actions.

The victim needed an operation on his hip, had to take time off work and spent three months getting around with the aid of crutches. He cannot now cycle as much as he used to, has problems sleeping, and it is thought that the fracture to his hip may never fully repair.

Sentencing Smith, Judge Stephen Holt told him: “A clear message must go out that behaviour of this type on a public highway that results in serious injury to an innocent person must lead to immediate custody.”

Representing Smith, Michael Clare said his client had written to Mr Brown to apologise, adding, “He is genuinely remorseful. He told me he was not an unreasonable person but had obviously got it wrong this time.”

Following the hearing, Mr Brown said he remained mystified at the “randomness of the attack.”

He added: “He had been dancing in the middle of the road, acting really strangely, with cyclists going either side of him. As I went to go by him he just shoulder-charged me.”

Simon joined as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Latest Comments

  • open_roads 5 min 19 sec ago

    1/3 of all ambulance call outs are for 0.6% of the patient population. In many cases these emergency call outs are subsequently classified as...

  • simonmb 6 min 51 sec ago

    Passing a cyclist in the opposite direction warrants at least a nod or a gentle lift of the hand from the bars. But what about overtaking a fellow...

  • HoarseMann 38 min 44 sec ago

    I'd hardly call Hirsute's comments victim blaming. They're not excusing the driver or saying the cyclist caused the incident....

  • Rich_cb 39 min 32 sec ago

    I've tried to hold off using an ad blocker on here as I also don't object to a reasonable amount of advertising....

  • brooksby 1 hour 2 min ago

    If a bicycle is the only vehicle stopped at a zebra crossing, you should just go around them.

  • ChrisB200SX 1 hour 2 min ago

    There is a car coming head-on, the car ahead has stopped, no room to complete a safe overtake and the driver is on the brakes before even being...

  • Global Nomad 1 hour 14 min ago

    as long as the wheel goes around when i pedal.....

  • Secret_squirrel 1 hour 32 min ago

    Im considering something like this to replace my current storage bottle on my downtube.  It does the job of keeping the tools safe and dry but at...

  • brooksby 11 hours 15 min ago

    The wheelbenders were on the verge again, so since there were no other bikes in sight i locked mine along the back of them....

  • chrisonatrike 11 hours 47 min ago

    Another humbug *!  Maybe also a "friendly fire" casualty - of the "war on the roads" on animals by motor traffic - possibly while "being the cat"?...