What's this landing with a thud on the doormat of road.cc towers? Only a set of the new 105 hydraulic/mechanical shifters and flat-mount brake callipers. Woo-hoo!
It was April when Shimano told us that their hydraulic disc tech was going to trickle down to 105 level, and we've been waiting half the year, but the levers are appearing on bikes now and the flat-mount callipers are in stock too. What we have is a full set of front and rear shifters and disc callipers, along with necessary pads, cables and hoses. It's a package that has an RRP of £399.
> Read our guide to Shimano groupsets
The lever shape looks quite different to the Ultegra-level hydraulic/mechanical shifters, but actually the section you'd normally be gripping when you're riding on the hoods is very similar. The top of the lever is flatter: the lever pivots from a different place and there's some re-arranging of the internals too.
> Review: Shimano 105 5800 groupset
With the original 785 Di2 hydraulic levers and the Ultegra-level 685 mechanical levers you had to peel back the rubber cover on the top of the hood to expose the bleed valve, and it was a bit of a faff getting it to sit back in place once you were done, especially on the Di2 ones. For the 505 levers the bleed port has moved to the base of the lever so you can just roll the rubber up a bit like you do when you're fitting them anyway. Shimano suggest accessing the recessed clamp bolt from the top of the hood but actually you can reach it from the bottom as well. Just. It's that little hole bottom left.
> First ride: Shimano ST-RS685 hydraulic discs
The callipers are more compact than the post mount ones and they come with Ice-Tech resin pads with heat-sink fins to help with cooling. The front brake has a reversible plate that allows you to run either a 160mm or 140mm rotor at the front. the rear flat mount calliper bolts directly through the frame if you're running a 140mm rotor; if you want a 160mm at the back you need an extra plate between the calliper and the chainstay.
The kit comes with all the cables, outer, hose, mineral oil and olives that you need to fully set up the brakes on your bike. You don't get derailleurs, of course. We've bunged all the bits on the road.cc scales of truth and they say the following:
- Levers (pair): 667g
- Callipers (pair): 223g
- Pads (x4): 60g
- Mineral oil (50ml bottle): 50g
- Cables, outer, hoses, olives (set): 120g
There's two bottles of oil included, so assuming you use both of them and all of the cable outer and hose, that's a full system weight of 1170g, excluding rotors. In reality you won't need all the oil and you'll be chopping bits of the cables and outers off, so it'll likely be an install weight of 100g or so less. When we tested the Shimano 105 5800 groupset we weighted the levers, cables and brakes at 1,000g. So the hydraulics will be around 200g heavier once the rotors are taken into account.
We'll be fitting these brakes to the new flat-mount-friendly Kinesis 4S Disc frame soon, so watch out for a full review in due course.
Add new comment
11 comments
Looks like these hoods will stay more put than on my ST-RS685, where they are constantly moving around when riding on the hoods. Very annoying.
I had same problem with the Shimano hoods on cannondale synapse. No problem in the SRAM i now have.
I'm going against the tide, I don't think they look ugly.
How compatible are different shifters with calipers? For those of us a bit new to hydraulic in the road world, are there multiple standards, or will things be fairly interchangeable?
Shimano's bits are interchangeable: we've already seen bikes with these new levers and older post-mount callipers. You can chop and change in that regard.
SRAM and Shimano systems are fundamentally different: SRAM use DOT5.1 brake fluid, Shimano use mineral oil. They're not compatible at all.
It'll be interesting to see how much these retail at when they hit the shelves considering the mechanical Ultegra level can be had for very little more than rrp of these 105 units. Certainly a bit of an aesthetic nightmare IMHO.
As they're Shimano, I'm sure they work brilliantly. But damn they look ugly. Shallow I know, but it has to be said.
Bang goes the 'discs are heavier' argument then. Not that that ever mattered a hill of beans, anyhoo. I for one welcome our new one-fingered spinny silent overlords.
no - they said 200g heavier.. also not to mention additional strengthening required to the frame
But I agree that these weights don't really matter, it's just the principle!
You only need to strengthen the frame/fork if it wasn't designed for discs in the first place. If it's a true disc-specific frame, you can remove material other places as demonstrated by the Giant Defy frame, CAAD12 Disc, etc.
Did you miss the 200grams heavier bit? 1/2lb is a fair chunk of extra weight. Not that it matters, discs are coming regardless of whether customers actually want them.
neat little pistons. Good to see 140mm at std.