“I found a crack in the market and filled it”: Bum Butter cycling chamois cream enjoys “dream” spike in sales… after Amanda Holden gave brand a shout-out ahead of charity cycle; Shimano ‘crankgate’ rumbles on + more on the live blog
SUMMARY
Crank inspections back in the spotlight as cyclists despair at Shimano's approach... but not everyone has sympathy for bike shop "banned" from inspection programme
You might have seen, crank inspections and Shimano are back in the news. That’s because yesterday we shared this piece on a Lake District-based bike shop that claimed in an online video that it had been “banned” by the components giant due to failing 100% of them.
Very YouTube-friendly language of course, the “ban” relating to Mapdec Cycle Works no longer being paid the £35 Shimano is giving bike shops for each time they look at customers’ cranks as part of the “inspection and replacement” programme. Why? Well, Mapdec believes it is due to its ‘fail rate’, or at least its ‘not pass rate’ being 100 per cent (the bike shop refusing to pass any and sending them all back to Shimano for a second opinion).
Some added context to all this is that a few days before Shimano’s UK distributor Madison got in touch to reveal the news, Mapdec had uploaded another video, in which owner and founder Paul Vousden said: “We don’t bother inspecting them, we just ship them back, it seems to be the industry norm on all the bike and mechanic forums that we follow, they all just say just ship them back, get a new set.”
It’s this additional detail that left some reacting to our story with little sympathy for the bike shop, even if many accept the moral argument to Mapdec’s stance — and almost all believe Shimano should have simply ordered a full recall last September and replaced everyone’s cranks, not just asked customers to keep riding and get a mechanic to inspect them when they suspect something has gone wrong.
john_smith: “Doesn’t Shimano issue instructions on how the inspections are supposed to be done and what constitutes a pass or fail? If Shimano pays shops to do given checks in a given way and fail/pass the parts in accordance with given criteria, then a shopkeeper can hardly complain if he gets ‘banned’ for doing something different (which I presume is what is happening here).”
That sentiment was echoed by other comments too. Yes, Shimano does issue instructions, a summarised version of the scintillating 36-page dealer’s manual in the original story.
From Mapdec’s perspective, Vousden admitted they do inspect them properly, filling in the form, doing all the checks, cleaning the cranks, and taking the photos required. But, they won’t ‘pass’ any…
“It asks us, inspection passed or failed?” he continued. “There’s no in between. It’s a pass or a fail, so our policy has always been if it’s clearly failed, it’s obvious, it’s a fail. But we would never write the word ‘pass’, we would always write something like ‘customer reports creaking, customer not happy with the pass, unsure, please check’. So we thought that we’d send them off to Shimano and Shimano would then offer a second opinion.
“Our policy was always we don’t want to be the one that says this is a pass, we always thought that, even though Shimano gave a liability release, that liability release in our mind wasn’t strong enough. Also we had customers coming up to us and saying: ‘Well how do I know it’s safe?’ They’d come back the week later and say: ‘Can you inspect it again it’s still creaking? I’m not convinced this is not going to fail… I want a new one, I’m just going to keep coming back every week until you fail it’.
“I’ve always always put our customers first and I’ve never thought I’m going to be on the side of Shimano here.”
And while some comments under our piece have little sympathy for the “ban” considering the context of what was claimed previously, it’s fair to say the underlying feeling is that all this would have been avoided if Shimano had simply ordered a full recall last year…
NickSprink: “I watched the vid when Mapdec released it, and I completely agree with their approach. They are not materials engineers, they don’t have the ultrasound and X-ray equipment to establish this sort of issue (like the airline industry uses). A visual inspection and listening for ‘creaks’ cannot be sufficient. If I had one of the cranks listed, I would expect a full replacement. Anything else I would consider a fob off, and be very disillusioned.”
EK Spinner: “[Quoting the story] mechanics are required to undertake a process of inspecting and cleaning. The recall of last September is for 11-speed Hollowtech II road cranksets that were produced between 1 June 2012 and 30 June 2019, and covers the model numbers: Ultegra FC-6800 and FC-R8000, and Dura-Ace FC-9000, FC-R9100, and FC-R9100-P.”
“That should be the end of the process for the bike shop, the next line should be ‘Once a relevant crankset has been identified, bike shops are asked to return the chainset to Shimano’.”
> “It’s a bit of a mess”: A solicitor’s take on Shimano crankgate on our latest Podcast
Legin: “You may agree or disagree with the approach of Shimano to this issue. However this Bike Shop publicised that they were not following the process that they were taking the money for.”
Mr Anderson: “The clear and important issue is that, a crank may pass one inspection, but that does not guarantee that crank is defect free, it can still fail sometime in the future. As the video pointed out, the shareholder had this very experience. Mapdec is putting the customer first. All cranks should be shipped back to Shimano for them to inspect, and issue a warranty they are safe to use.”
If only there was a way this whole inspection programme could have been avoided…
BBC admits 15,000mph tailwind error...before we all go KOM-hunting
You might have got a shock opening your weather app this morning…
Unfortunately for anyone looking to bag a few wind-assisted KOMs, the BBC quickly addressed the data fault, and confirmed very earnestly that the 404°C temperatures forecast in Hottingham (sorry, that’s Nottingham) are not legit.
“Don’t be alarmed folks — Hurricane Milton hasn’t made it to us here in the UK! There’s been a data glitch between our suppliers and the app/online. Folk are working to solve the issue,” weather presenter Matt Taylor confirmed on social media, before the BBC Weather press office confirmed the fault in a slightly more serious statement…
Kasper Asgreen joins EF Education-EasyPost
EF Education Easy-Post have beefed up their classics line-up, adding Kasper Asgreen to the ranks for next season. The Dane hasn’t enjoyed a vintage 2024 but hopes to be revitalised by a move to “really cool” EF after seven seasons with Soudal Quick-Step, during which he won the Tour of Flanders, E3 Saxo Bank Classic, Kuurne-Brussel-Kuurne and a stage of the Tour de France.
“The main reason for me to come to this team is the way that the guys race,” Asgreen said of the move. “You can see that there’s always a plan to try to win. Even if the race is not perfectly suited to them, the guys won’t just sit in the bunch, waiting for the other teams to take charge. That really attracted me. On this team, we’re going to do everything that we can to make races develop the way we want them to develop. That is really, really cool. For me, it’s the main thing: I like the team’s approach to racing.”
A statement signing for EF who lost their former classics headliner Alberto Bettiol to Astana in August.
Cav and Wiggo to ride Gran Fondo Hincapie to raise money for US hurricane relief
Knights of the Realm Sir Mark Cavendish and Sir Bradley Wiggins are to ride the Gran Fondo Hincapie next weekend to raise money for the US hurricane relief efforts. Jan Ullrich is also expected to be on the startline, Rich Hincapie (president of Hincapie Events) explaining how they went from likely cancelling the sportive to using it for good…
” I realised that we could use the Gran Fondo to draw attention to the massive devastation in our area and turn the whole thing into a huge fundraising effort,” he said. “While we understand that many counties are in need, we want to focus on our neighbours in Polk County who have partnered with us and supported our Gran Fondo event for thirteen years. We want to rally the global cycling community and really make a difference in Polk County. Our goal is to raise one million dollars.”
RideLondon "hiatus" for 2025 due to opening of "car use-encouraging" tunnel, suggests FOI request, after London's walking and cycling commissioner objected to closure of new tunnel for cycling event as "absolute no"
Zoe Bäckstedt defends Simac Tour lead without any teammates
At 20 years of age, Zoe Bäckstedt is leading the Simac Tour, a Women’s WorldTour stage race in the Netherlands, heading a classy field including world champ Lotte Kopecky, Lorena Wiebes, Elisa Balsamo, Elisa Longo Borghini and a whole host of established experienced pros.
Today’s third stage, won by Wiebes, saw Bäckstedt maintain her race lead, a feat made even more impressive when you consider this is the extent of her Canyon//SRAM Racing team at the event…
🚴♀️En nog helemaal alleen over. Blessures en ziekte decimeerden de ploeg van leidster @Backstedt_Zoe @WMNcycling. Kan ze stand houden vandaag.#SLT2024 pic.twitter.com/BCKXh7H0Uq
— Simac Ladies Tour (@ladiestour) October 10, 2024
Yep, in a bizarre turn of events, all four of her teammates have abandoned, a grim mix of illness, injuries and crashes leaving Bäckstedt leading a one-woman charge against the WorldTour peloton.
Soraya Paladin and Maike van der Duin are out through illness, while fellow Brit Alex Morrice was unable to finish yesterday’s stage. Then there’s Chloé Dygert who broke her nose after walking into a door…
It all means Bäckstedt has three more days to defend the jersey alone, two flat stages followed by a punchy circuit in Arnhem on Sunday.
Works to treat "increasingly severe rainfall" flooding on Bath's Two Tunnels path to begin this week
Great to see the Two Tunnels route will reopen in the near future https://t.co/RJW9axEh3R
— Laura Laker (@laura_laker) October 10, 2024
The BBC has reported that Bath & North East Somerset Council is to install a pump at the entrance to the Devonshire Tunnel in Bath with the aim of diverting flood waters.
Flooded by “increasingly severe rainfall”, the eight weeks of work is being carried out on behalf of Sustrans, with the hope that the popular active travel route will be flood-proof afterwards.
“The original Victorian drainage in the Devonshire Tunnel has not been able to withstand the increasingly severe rainfall we have experienced in recent years,” Councillor Paul Roper said. “These essential works to install a pump will future-proof the route and ensure that it can remain open throughout future weather events. This is an important route for both commuting and pleasure and we apologise for the inconvenience while the works are carried out, however this is a long-term fix that needs to be done.”
Mark Cavendish set to race for final time as a professional in November at Tour de France Singapore Criterium, organisers ASO confirm
Excuse me?
This gem from St. Louis remains the king of scary bike lanes. pic.twitter.com/YGTJVksG5y
— Peter Flax (@Pflax1) October 9, 2024
George Hill doesn't hold back in his latest opinion piece... Boris Johnson, Tadej Pogačar and Taylor Swift are the same person, apparently... the problem with calling all cyclists 'Cyclists'
The Netherlands win European Bike Mechanics Championship
Jelmer Bijvang, Berend Bervoets and Kevin Smit have been crowned European Bike Mechanics Championship winners, representing the Netherlands. The Shimano-organised competition saw the participants “demonstrating their technical prowess, clear communication and teamwork, their ability to quickly identify and fix complex mechanic issues”. Italy were second and Germany third. According, to Shimano the tests included:
- ‘Drivetrain Setup’: (Installing a SHIMANO CUES front crank, choosing and installing a cassette that is compatible for the CUES drivetrain; fine-tuning the front and rear derailleurs using E-TUBE PROJECT Cyclist to customize SHIMANO ULTEGRA Di2 shift buttons)
- ‘Wheel maintenance’: (Servicing a freehub, replacing the freehub body and performing a brake bleed)
- ‘Hub Gear Maintenance’: (Disassembling, cleaning and reassembling SHIMANO NEXUS internal hub gear)
No word yet on if the tiebreaker round in case of a draw would have been full crank inspection…
"Unfair" Cycle to Work scheme "problems" need to be addressed, admits government minister
> “Unfair” Cycle to Work scheme “problems” need to be addressed, admits government minister
"I found a crack in the market and filled it": Bum Butter cycling chamois cream enjoys "dream" spike in sales... after Amanda Holden gave brand a shout-out ahead of charity cycle
“It all started when I woke up to a text telling me ‘Hey mate, you are all over Amanda Holden’s bum’… complete with some screen shots from The Sun online. Blimey!”
Bum Butter owner Charlie Hobbs has had quite the week, his chamois cream business being catapulted to fame by some comments Amanda Holden made ahead of her charity cycle this week.
Charlie explained: “Then my wife passed me her phone with a Good Morning Britain TV interview with Amanda and Bum Butter. Then the story was picked up by countless news outlets ‘Amanda Holden smothers herself in Bum Butter’… and just like that Bum Butter is now a household brand name.”
In an entertaining blog piece on Bum Butter’s website, Charlie asks how does the “mega turbo publicity benefit a small niche business”?
“This is dream marketing, this is off the scale, this is what every small business wishes for… or is it? It is. Website traffic is up, and sales are up. But it was very short lived. ‘Today’s news is tomorrows fish n chip paper’ is an old saying from when old newspapers where used to wrap your fish n chips… and it is very true. I rode the Holden wave and it is now fading away. The chart below clearly illustrates ‘Holden’s Spike’, and you can see what seems to be a sales tail, in grey.”
“This got me thinking…. How much would it costs for TV news, celebrity endorsement, and a double page story in The Sun? How much would this publicity cost if you were to buy it? I don’t know, but it could be £100-£300k. That is a guess. What was it worth to Bum Butter? A very welcome surge in sales… and hopefully a nice step up in brand awareness that will help in the longer term. Just so you know. This publicity was not requested, paid for, or even known about until it happened.”
And in an amusing twist, Charlie’s on Heart this morning talking to Holden about the product… “Whoop whoop…. The Bum Butter media rollercoaster ride is back on. This time next year Rodney…”
Presumably Cycliq or other camera brands won’t be getting the same treatment…
Help us to bring you the best cycling content
If you’ve enjoyed this article, then please consider subscribing to road.cc from as little as £1.99. Our mission is to bring you all the news that’s relevant to you as a cyclist, independent reviews, impartial buying advice and more. Your subscription will help us to do more.
36 Comments
Read more...
Read more...
Read more...
Latest Comments
Erm, Ruggins did manage to ride her bike very fast, perhaps in part because she'd headed up towards the Arctic Circle before the worst of the heat took hold. Are you perhaps thinking of Lael Wilcox?
@Rome73 The solar panels top up the battery. A battery is still needed especially when there isn't enough direct sunlight onto the panels to provide assistance. Brings a new meaning to fair-weather cyclist.
roadcc sinks to new low, next week wee reviewing electric cars !
@GravelIsNothingNew nearly, but not quite.
@chrisonabike I think its defining features are that it has nothing to do with sport, and very little utility.
@Sriracha I'm guilty of this because it's easier than going through the collision dynamics (which I'd no doubt get wrong). It's a proxy - I guess it's more fairly useful for explaining to the occupants of motor vehicles why less speed could be better (for them) eg. when crashing into an minimally yielding hard object? And for a gross "what damage does the vehicle do" in a collision - cyclists don't commonly bend or break street furniture, or buildings... As you say accelerations are more to the point. Of course as others note with larger heavier vehicles you could still suffer additional impacts (vehicle carries you on its front into an unyielding object, or you go under it / into a wheel arch). Plus potential crush if it ends on top of you.
I think you sort of miss the point. The idea of " pulling up whenever you fancy " just isn't possible with a roof tent as they overtly advertise your being there. You are limited to camp sites, themselves getting more and more expensive. A van remains the only viable choice for a true adventurer, as you can legitimately just pull up and go for a ride. Stealth... Stealth is the name of the game and a big orange triangle on your roof is only going to attract attention and end one way....
Again, two photos of the tyre still banded up fresh out of its packaging. No photo of the tyre fitted and inflated clearly showing the tread and profile.
I don't think the research stands up to the highest levels of scrutiny but the long notjusbikes video about this issue ("these stupid trucks are literally killing us") references some things like companies effectively "marketing towards arseholes" and a version of the common "roadkill experiment" by Mark Rober which had "SUV" drivers as the biggest (fake) animal killers. Now that these things are everywhere * perhaps this effect would be smaller. But perhaps it's not shocking that "less pro-social types" might be more likely to get a big mean car (and drive aggressively) than a 2CV... * What exactly is an "SUV"? Is it more "bigger car" plus the "look"?
@ROOTminus1 Plus 1 from me. I'd also add "LibreWolf" - Firefox fork that is focused on privacy and security. It adds some things like letterboxing to defeat fingerprinting by screen size, deletes most cookies on close by default, has other privacy protection mechanisms.
36 thoughts on ““I found a crack in the market and filled it”: Bum Butter cycling chamois cream enjoys “dream” spike in sales… after Amanda Holden gave brand a shout-out ahead of charity cycle; Shimano ‘crankgate’ rumbles on + more on the live blog”
I trust Shimano’s cranks as
I trust Shimano’s cranks as much as I trust BBC weather showing hurricane winds this morning in Bristol.
Tis a mere breeze..
Tis a mere breeze..
Given the actual hurricane in
Given the actual hurricane in Florida, it seems suspicious that the BBC app (which, incidentally, has never been very reliable after they dumped the Met Office and went with a different provider, IMO) is now warning of hurricanes here…
They’d never admit it, but who else thinks they got hacked?
brooksby wrote:
They’re just part of the Big Wind conspiracy
https://www.theguardian.com
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/oct/07/marjorie-taylor-greene-hurricane-helene
Presumably the members of the
Presumably the members of the US government all grew up playing D&D?
https://www.dndbeyond.com/spells/2050-control-weather
..and the reason they shut down Wilhelm Reich’s efforts in this regard was to maintain their monopoly? (Fortunately resulting in a good song at least).
chrisonabike wrote:
Wilhelm Reich had some interesting ideas which annoyed quite a few people. He’s the classic example of book burning in the U.S.A.
He met up with Einstein and even left Einstein with one of his orgone accumulator machines, but after some investigation, he must have decided that Reich was a bit of a crank and refused to take his calls afterwards.
Well… he was a crank, and
Well… he was a crank, and on inspection was (by the standards of the day even) cracked! (Although his personal magnetism was clearly remarkable – seems to be hard to bottle that though).
I think today people would be more concerned about his “coercive control” than the “quack doctor” aspects and promotion of orgasm (and anti-authoritarian stance) which seemed to have triggered the US authorities.
chrisonabike wrote:
I suspect that Taylor-Greene is more likely to be one of the people who were saying that D&D players were all Satanists or something…
brooksby wrote:
And yet her initials are the same as Magic The Gathering?
She’s probably busy trying to escape oversight by the Gazpacho Police (https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/gazpacho-police/). Presumably they watch over the stock market.
hawkinspeter wrote:
And don’t forget trying to keep out of range of the Jewish Space Lasers
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/marjorie-taylor-greene-qanon-wildfires-space-laser-rothschild-execute.html
Greene is going all out in a
Greene is going all out in a desperate attempt to make Trump look sane by comparison
?
?
chrisonabike wrote:
?
I’d rather rely on the Met
I’d rather rely on the Met Office, I’ve not been impressed with BBC weather info since parting company with them. Forecast for St George’s:
https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/forecast/gcnhwrck8
Naturally there is an app and I like their Youtube channel. Though it feels like they occasionally exaggerate the intensity or the area covered by extreme weather warnings; I am tempted to think that it’s a legacy of the 1987 Great Storm, famously downplayed by Michael Fish on BBC TV beforehand, though there’s a good Met Office article about that:
https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/learn-about/weather/case-studies/great-storm
Has BBC weather ever been
Has BBC weather ever been acurate? I can’t remember a time when it was. Gave up years ago. Met Office not great, but far better than the BBC.
NickSprink wrote:
They were, of course, one and the same thing until 2018.
NickSprink wrote:
It used to be more accurate up to 2018 because it got its forecasting information from the Met Office. When it gave the contract out to Meteogroup, now owned by a private American company concerned with global forecasts, it was patently obvious that the quality was going to be lower than a dedicated expert UK government agency. It’s interesting that the BBC still uses the Met Office forecasts for the shipping forecast, which would appear to be a tacit admission that Met Office forecasts are still the gold standard for when it really matters.
Rendel Harris wrote:
I believe the BBC were legally obliged to open the contract for tender, in order to provide the best “value”
mark1a wrote:
I don’t doubt that you are correct but what is the value of an incorrect forecast?
Backladder wrote:
I completely agree, hence my use of inverted commas in “value”
mark1a wrote:
The AliExpress economic model, yes it’s a pile of crap but you can’t deny that it’s amazing value…
Rendel Harris wrote:
I would much rather my licence
taxfee was spent on the weather, and other things that don’t necessarily represent economic value in the textbook sense, i.e. things that the private sector won’t, don’t or can’t do, than some of the other crap they somehow manage to fund.And yet Metcheck is far more
And yet Metcheck is far more accurate than the BBC and often more accurate than the MetOffice too, and always my go to site for planning bike rides.
Assessment of reporting
Assessment of reporting accuracy
stonojnr wrote:
+1 for Metcheck, especially their cycling specific weather forecast.
Rendel Harris wrote:
I think that the Aliexpress/Shein/Temu model is also “Find a picture of someone’s original design on the internet, copy it and sell it much much cheaper, then shrug if the original designer complains”
mark1a wrote:
I’m sure you’re correct about this. Public tendering follows strict rules. There are technical and commercial questions for bidders to answer. The answer scoring regime is published. Met Office may have ended up with a better quality score than Meteogroup but a higher price so the Met office overall score would not have been the winning one.
Trouble is, the Met Office is
Trouble is, the Met Office is nowadays run as a for-profit entity. I used to buy data from them, until they placed more and more restrictions on its use and I found I could get the exact same data elsewhere for less than half the price.
“Murderer who drove stolen
“Murderer who drove stolen car into cyclist jailed”
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvg3v882ppno
Another case where loss of libido and taste buds might be a good deterrent.
Was cycling on some side
Was cycling on some side streets yesterday, came round a bend to find some bloke standing in the middle of the road with his back to me, staring at his phone.
Me: Great place to stand mate
Him: I’m working
Me: Don’t you follow safe working practices then?
Me: Don’t you do a risk assessment which determines your working practices ?
His mate was standing on the pavement level with him – didn’t stand around the bend.
No Hi Viz either ! Practically invisible !!
I remember Amanda Holden
I remember Amanda Holden laughing uncontrollably with glee at a Britains got talent contentant’s “comedy” rant at cyclists – the usual bingo stuff.
Wonder how she’ll react if she gets a 10th of the hate normal cyclists do on her 250 mile ride? Hate that’s shes contributed to.
Was this ninja ambulance even
Was this ninja ambulance even wearing hi-viz or a helmet?
Sometimes they bring it on themselves.
FFS, headline calls it a near
FFS, headline calls it a near miss.
Water pump to solve tunnel
Water pump to solve tunnel flooding on cycle route
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cz7j8nvxvr4o
Apropos nothing, really, I
Apropos nothing, really, I just saw this on twitter and thought it worth sharing. Obviously from the US – we don’t have jay walking here – but it would be good to see this sort of attitude to drivers’ responsibilities from the judiciary more generally.
https://x.com/PeterNorton12/status/1844371092665950270