Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Dramatic footage shows Tesco delivery driver knocking cyclist off bike on London cycleway (+ video)

Incident happened on Millbank, but driver denied he had been at wheel of vehicle

A man has been fined after a cyclist riding on a busy cycleway in London was knocked off his bike by a Tesco delivery driver who turned left across his path but later denied he had been driving the vehicle.

The dramatic incident was filmed in May and has now been uploaded to YouTube by road.cc reader Chris.

It happened on Cycleway 8 – one of the original ‘lick of blue paint’ Cycle Superhighways that afford nothing in the way of physical protection – on Millbank, just after the junction with Vauxhall Bridge Road.

The driver could not have been unaware that there were cyclists to his left, with the start of the video showing around a dozen of them positioned in the advanced stop line area ahead of him as they waited for the traffic lights to change to cross Vauxhall Bridge Road.

Nevertheless, after the lights change, the driver passed Chris then turned left into a small cul-de-sac, knocking the front rider from his bike and, as this still image shows, the cyclist was very close to having his leg crushed by the vehicle’s nearside front wheel.

Tesco van on CS8 YouTube still.PNG

Chris told us that the cyclist was able to ride away from the scene, and that the case has only just gone to court – although incredibly, the driver refused to admit that he was driving the vehicle at the time.

“This meant the police could not charge him for driving-related charges as he could not officially be identified - despite the video evidence,” Chris said.

“Instead he was prosecuted for ‘failing to nominate driver. He was given a £300 fine, plus £332 in costs and six points.

“Despite the employee refusing to take responsibility for the crash, Tesco admitted liability in the insurance claim.”

Chris added that in a later part of the footage he captured, not shown in this edit (which has been uploaded and shared with the cyclist’s permission, “the employee states the cyclist had been in his ‘blind spot’.”

In October 2015, cyclist Julie Dinsdale lost her right leg when she was crushed by a left-turning Tesco lorry as she rode along London’s Old Street with her partner, mountain bike pioneer Keith Bontrager.

The following August, the driver, Florian Oprea, was fined £625 and had his driving licence endorsed with five penalty points after pleading guilty to driving without due care and attention.

Dinsdale said afterwards that she was “hugely disappointed by the decision of the Court which finds that despite the evidence that I was visible to the driver, he should not be handed a more substantial sentence given the impact his actions have had on my life.”

> Cyclist who lost leg ‘hugely disappointed’ by driver’s £625 fine

Simon joined road.cc as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment

60 comments

Avatar
Xena | 4 years ago
0 likes

Ok , driver fucked up , but if I was riding , I would have slowed down as soon as that van came alongside . Ride defensively, ride smart . Maybe it's my experience when I used to be a cycle courier, but  that was written in the stars . You have to be aware . You cannot assume anything . Just make sure there is a space in front of you to stop and you should be fine . Not had a crash ever on my road bikes ( sub 4 kilos yeah baby )  .  Rode all over Europe etc .Been close on more than one occasion but my spider sense seems to help me .  You start to understand the flow of traffic ,the sound of traffic etc with awareness , Just because you have the right of way  or your in the right doesn't mean your going to get it. Rely on yourself not others. 

Avatar
mdavidford replied to Xena | 4 years ago
10 likes

Xena wrote:

Not had a crash ever on my road bikes

Probably because you were never moving, since you couldn't go anywhere while there was a vehicle in your vicinity.

Avatar
srchar replied to Xena | 4 years ago
10 likes

Just stopped by to compliment you on how great you are - that's the point you wanted to get across, right?

Avatar
pullfaces replied to Xena | 4 years ago
5 likes

But Xena, you weren't riding or using your imaginary spider sense on your Yeah baby road bike. I'm not surprised you're on a baby bike, you can't go faster than walking pace otherwise how do you get to cycle quicker than that anywhere when riding in London (as crash was)? There are vehicles along side continuously on busy roads.

Avatar
kt26 replied to Xena | 4 years ago
6 likes

Blaming victims for drivers as you put it fucking up won't protect you from drivers fucking up - not matter how much you think you can control a situation you can be on the recieving end of someone elses mistake.

I dare say you already have, so try to remember what that is like before you, gratify yourself again by reassuring yourself this couldn't possibly happen to you and bragging about your (non existent?) set of wheels.

Avatar
nniff replied to Xena | 4 years ago
5 likes

Xena wrote:

Ok , driver fucked up , but if I was riding , I would have slowed down as soon as that van came alongside . Ride defensively, ride smart . Maybe it's my experience when I used to be a cycle courier, but  that was written in the stars . You have to be aware . You cannot assume anything . Just make sure there is a space in front of you to stop and you should be fine . Not had a crash ever on my road bikes ( sub 4 kilos yeah baby )  .  Rode all over Europe etc .Been close on more than one occasion but my spider sense seems to help me .  You start to understand the flow of traffic ,the sound of traffic etc with awareness , Just because you have the right of way  or your in the right doesn't mean your going to get it. Rely on yourself not others. 

Bully for you.  Nominate yourself for the fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square.  

Avatar
nniff replied to Xena | 4 years ago
0 likes

I thought the name rang a bell - the following is Xena from a few days ago - the brake-check video.  What was that old saying - "I have strong principles, but if you don't agree with them, I do have others" - 

"Police don't give a shit , they are just another bunch of revenue seekers for the government. Don't forget they turn up after the crime has been committed, but woe if you have a rear brake light out or drive 1 mph over the speed limit , then your treated like you have murdered someone . I mean most people who join the police do it for the power trip. I respect people not a uniform . Most encounters I've had with the "fuzz " they have been arseholes on a power trip and I told them so. 
That driver could have killed that cyclist. But no money in prosecuting him . That's the truth.  I'd love to know what  would have happened to that driver if the cyclist was a copper ....... just had a thought ,i wonder if the driver has a couple of mates in the right places, wouldn't surprise me .   If that was another car instead of a  bike ? "

Avatar
Guyz2010 replied to Xena | 4 years ago
6 likes

Wow youre a star (Sarcasm!!). Look closely and the vans indicator flashes just twice before it started turning, no chance of the rider reacting to a one second split. He knew he was along side cyclists. If you had the react to every vehcile by slowing when they are along side you you'd never get anywhere!!

Then he denies it despite video evidence. I'd like to think Tesco stopped him driving in future he's a complete danger to anyone else on the road. What a shister!

Avatar
LastBoyScout replied to Capt Sisko | 4 years ago
3 likes

I've also nearly been wiped out by a left-hooking Tesco delivery van.

Tried sending the video to Tesco and the police. Police not interested, as no contact. Tesco came up with an increasing list of excuses as to why they couldn't view the video and then just stopped responding at all.

I still have the video.

Avatar
ktache replied to LastBoyScout | 4 years ago
1 like

This particular van has on board video recording, the notice is just below the insulting and nonsense blind spot thing.

I saw a Tesco's van take to the pavement to gain a few seconds in queing traffic (Brookwood, I never understood how drivers did it every day), if he had not been so apologetic I would have reported him.

 

Avatar
Mybike | 4 years ago
4 likes

How can the driver say it was not him driving when the videio clearly shows his face,  Im sure Tesco knew who was driving that truck that day and time. It also the drivers resopnability to be aware of what in his blind spots

Avatar
Hirsute replied to Mybike | 4 years ago
0 likes

You mean the passenger"s face.

Avatar
headingley replied to Mybike | 4 years ago
0 likes

The driver is in reality not denying being the driver here, the offence is under S.172 RTA 1988. The registered keeper of the vehicle (assume Tesco) would be formally requested to ""give information as to drivers identity" Failure to do so within 28 days is an offence - the penalty is a fine and minimum 6 points. No endorsement for limited companies. On the civil liability side clearly Tesco did the right thing and accepted their driver was at fault - hard to argue with !

Avatar
Hirsute replied to headingley | 4 years ago
0 likes

Who got the fine and points then ?

Avatar
WiznaeMe replied to headingley | 4 years ago
3 likes

Anyone can be required to identify a driver if it is "in their power to do so". Section. 172(2)(b).  
That includes the 'passenger' in this crash if it was two people who got out.

Avatar
Rik Mayals unde... | 4 years ago
5 likes

The 'blind spot' claim is bollocks. Iveco Daily vans have large twin mirrors, the bottom mirror is a wide view anti blind spot mirror. Even if they are not set perfectly for the driver, it is impossible not to be able to see.

What a disgusting example to set by Tesco. 

Avatar
MonkeyPuzzle | 4 years ago
4 likes

The cyclist had been in his blind spot? The blind spot of the man definitely not driving?

Avatar
Organon replied to MonkeyPuzzle | 4 years ago
2 likes

The only blind spot is in his memory of the cyclist he over took 5 seconds before. Flick and go, that is all that is required, right?

Avatar
gsk82 | 4 years ago
2 likes

Am i the only one who thinks that as the one who's the most vulnerable, the cyclist should be more aware of what's going on here?

Since this is the internet and everything on the internet is black or white, i now have to point out that I'm not saying that it's his fault.

Avatar
srchar replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
14 likes

I do hope so.

I'm not sure what you think the rider should have done. He did not have the same point of view as we do in the video. He'd have seen the truck pull alongside him, still travelling apparently too quickly to make a 90 degree turn. From the moment the driver braked and switched on his indicator to the moment of impact was a whole two seconds.

There's not much point writing "I'm not saying that it's his fault" when you have just written that the rider should have been more aware.

Avatar
Tired of the tr... replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
0 likes

gsk82 wrote:

Am i the only one who thinks that as the one who's the most vulnerable, the cyclist should be more aware of what's going on here? Since this is the internet and everything on the internet is black or white, i now have to point out that I'm not saying that it's his fault.

I don't know if they "should"... It's hard to judge from a video, but it seems that the driver turned off so suddenly and without warning that it would be hard to react even if you observe the van carefully.

However I see your poin; from own experience if a van half passes me but then slows down and doesn't quite overtake, I would certainly expect that trhe driver is rubbish and might suddenly turn or pull into the bike lane, so I'd slow down and try not to cycle next to them.

But then all cycling videos from London look like extremely aggressive, competitive cycling that we don't really have up here.

 

Avatar
Captain Badger replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
11 likes

Do you think that the less vulnerable should be less aware??

Avatar
hawkinspeter replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
7 likes

gsk82 wrote:

Am i the only one who thinks that as the one who's the most vulnerable, the cyclist should be more aware of what's going on here? Since this is the internet and everything on the internet is black or white, i now have to point out that I'm not saying that it's his fault.

That's like saying "attractive ladies/gentlemen should be more aware of rapists".

Avatar
dughs replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
6 likes

Really? This isn't like a 'Third Person' view on a video game. You are looking at the situation from a camera a couple of meters back giving you an unrealistic view of what the cyclist who was hit would see. So no, he could not have been more aware of the impending hit at all.

Avatar
missionsystem replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
9 likes

I assume you are trolling because your point is absolutely ludicrous.

The cyclist becomes accutely aware pretty much as soon as humanly possible but there was absolutely nothing he could have done to avoid the collision.

Perhaps you could enlighten us as to what you would have done differently?

Avatar
TriTaxMan replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
9 likes

I have rewatched the video several times, and at best the driver brakes and indicates at the point where the back of his van has only just passed the front wheel of the cyclist.  And about 2 seconds later is the point of impact.

And given the cyclists speed - around 20mph by my guess, even with the best reactions in the world, had he applied full braking force he would have still have hit the side of the van.

And should a cyclist slow down and expect every vehicle that starts to pass them is blindly going to cut across their path, perhaps doff their cycling cap to the superior drivers as they acknowledge their presence? 

Your point is akin to someone driving in the inside lane on a motorway on the approach to an exit sliproad expecting that some bell end is going to attempt the suicide entry to the slip road from lane 3.

Avatar
formerLondon replied to gsk82 | 4 years ago
4 likes

gsk82 wrote:

Am i the only one who thinks that as the one who's the most vulnerable, the cyclist should be more aware of what's going on here? ...

yes.

(as in: yes, you are the only one)

Avatar
Shades | 4 years ago
2 likes

Not being a London cyclist how are these blue painted superhighways supposed to work?  Traffic will need to turn left so who has right of way?  If I was a driver and had to use a wing mirror to spot a gap in amongst a stream of cyclists (ie cyclists have right of way), it would be a nightmare.  In Bristol any cycle highway (generally) is segregated and you give way when crossing a side road.  I would never undertake a moving vehicle and only in a hatched line cycle lane if there wasn't a side road where the vehicle may turn left.  Crap cycle infrastructure?

Avatar
cyclegaz replied to Shades | 4 years ago
8 likes

Shades wrote:

Traffic will need to turn left so who has right of way?

Right of way is the wrong term here. Right of way is a legal term regarding who can use a path, route, road etc... So in theory they both had equal right of way. Right of way doesn't dictate who is more important or who has to give way.

What you mean is priorty. In this case the turning vehicle should give way to the cyclsits in the cycle lane. If you indicate and wait, people will either move around you or stop to let you go.

Pages

Latest Comments