Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Back to news
news

“The AA aren’t advising people not to drive”: Cyclists react to British Cycling’s state funeral advice; Drivers blast lorry-drafting cyclists; Riding primary: more harm than good?; NI minister “reneged” on active travel; Kangaroos + more on the live blog

It’s Wednesday, London is one long queue (what’s new there?), and Ryan Mallon is here with all the latest cycling news and views on your middle-of-the-week live blog
Wed, Sep 14, 2022 10:00
38
“The AA aren’t advising people not to drive”: Cyclists react to British Cycling’s state funeral advice; Drivers blast lorry-drafting cyclists; Riding primary: more harm than good?; NI minister “reneged” on active travel; Kangaroos + more on the live blogCyclist and Palace of Westminster (copyright Simon MacMichael)
14 September 2022, 15:49
MVDP vs. Girmay, the second leg

A not-very-aero but still brutally effective Mathieu van der Poel renewed his springtime rivalry with Biniam Girmay, beating the 22-year-old Eritrean on the uphill drag to the line at this afternoon’s Grand Prix de Wallonie.

While both MVDP and Girmay look in ominous form ahead of next week’s road worlds in Wollongong (those two and Van Aert for the rainbow stripes? Now that’s a mouth-watering prospect), Dylan Teuns’ strong late attack – sniffed out in the closing metres, after breakaway companion Gonzalo Serrano sat on the wheel – proves that the new Israel Premier Tech rider will be one to watch out for in the upcoming autumn classics.

Meanwhile, at the Tour of Slovakia, 22-year-old Brit Ethan Vernon added to yesterday’s prologue win with a sprint victory in the yellow jersey, ahead of Gleb Syritsa and Giovanni Lonardi.

Not too shabby for the Quick Step-Alpha Vinyl neo pro, who took his maiden professional win at the Volta a Catalunya in March.

14 September 2022, 15:24
Primary position: Does it do more harm than good?

Does riding in primary position – i.e. “in the centre of the leftmost moving traffic lane for the direction in which you wish to travel”, according to cycling skills manual Cyclecraft – do more harm than good?

> Monday moaning: Why don't cyclists stick to the left of the lane?

Well, transport planner Dermot Hanney thinks so, and argued on Twitter this morning that pushing cyclists in general to adopt primary position on the roads only helps create friction with motorists and could potentially discourage less confident cyclists.

Here’s what he had to say:

Hanney’s Twitter thread kicked off a rather interesting debate on the pros and cons of primary, featuring a wide variety of opinion on the subject:

What do you think?

14 September 2022, 14:56
road.cc makes Grieve Watch
14 September 2022, 14:41
14 September 2022, 13:53
Cavehill Road, Belfast (credit - Sustrans)
Sinn Féin minister “neglecting Northern Ireland’s future” and “locking us all into a fossil-fuelled dark age”, says Cycling UK

Cycling UK has criticised Sinn Féin MLA and Minister for Infrastructure, John O’Dowd, for appearing to renege on a pre-election pledge to introduce an Active Travel Act in Northern Ireland.

In the run-up to May’s Northern Ireland Assembly election, the cycling charity sought pledges from all candidates to support investment in cycling, walking and wheeling through the implementation of an Active Travel Act. This campaign secured the support of 53 percent of the elected MLAs, including Sinn Féin’s O’Dowd, who took over the Department for Infrastructure (DfI) role following the election, replacing the outgoing SDLP MLA Nichola Mallon in the devolved executive.

Cycling UK says that such an Act, mirroring similar ground-breaking legislation in Wales, would enshrine a commitment in government policy to enable more cycling and walking.

However, in a letter sent to Cycling UK by O’Dowd’s office last month, the minister pledged his commitment “to consider taking forward legislation to support active travel, not to an Active Travel Act per se.”

While the Assembly is currently in deadlock due to the DUP’s opposition to the controversial Northern Ireland Protocol, since taking office O’Dowd has approved two new road building projects and has guaranteed funding for a Greenway Project established by Mallon.

He has also decided to launch the third consultation in the space of a year concerning a trial cycle lane on the Limestone and Cavehill roads in Belfast, viewed by active travel advocates as key to delivering a proper cycling network in the city. However, those campaigners have been highly critical of the DfI’s approach to the project, which they say has been needlessly delayed through repeated consultations which fail to yield any new information.

In a statement released today, Andrew McClean, Cycling UK’s spokesperson in Northern Ireland, said: “Minister O’Dowd, who is responsible for our roads and the way we move, is dithering and locking us all into future car dependency. In rejecting his pre-election promise of support for an Active Travel Act he is neglecting Northern Ireland's future as he locks us all into a fossil-fuelled dark age.

“Across Northern Ireland, we’re facing the burden of a cost-of-living crisis with driving an expensive necessity for many. Making cycling and walking more accessible gives us all a choice, a choice to make cheaper, healthier and more environmentally friendly trips for those local essential journeys.

“It’s baffling the Minister and his department can’t see the short and long-term benefits of encouraging more cycling and walking.”

While Cycling UK says they recognise that the current impasse at Stormont has made it more difficult to ensure progress on cycling and walking issues, the charity claims that active travel is still being ignored to the detriment of the residents of Northern Ireland. 

“To date Cycling UK has received flimsy excuses as to why the Minister is doing nothing to help people travel cheaply,” said McClean.

“He’s signed off on new road schemes, so the very least he could do is begin scoping or beginning the consultation process on an Active Travel Act.”

14 September 2022, 13:25
Set your alarms…

Hands up, who’s going to attempt to watch every minute of every race?

No one? No one at all?

14 September 2022, 12:34
“Astana’s biggest win of this season”

Vino’s anonymous rap crew have only picked up two victories outside Kazakhstan in 2022, so will surely take any win they can get this year.

I’m not sure the Grammys ever got back to them, mind you…

14 September 2022, 11:40
“A classic case of ‘wear helmet, cannot think’”: Drivers criticise lorry-drafting cyclists

We’re heading across to Singapore this lunchtime, where a group of cyclists were filmed getting a sneaky draft from a lorry on the West Coast Highway, one of the Southeast Asian country’s major arterial roads:

Unsurprisingly, as the video was posted on Facebook, the drafting/foolhardy [delete as appropriate] cyclists have drawn the ire of some angry keyboard-wielding motorists.

One Facebook user blasted what he deemed “cyclists’ entitlement these days”, writing: “Lorry brakes, all bang on the lorry and get injured. Later they’ll ask for compensation from the lorry company.”

Another commenter described the situation as a “classic example of ‘wear helmet cannot think’”.

“Peanut brain, even my dog knows to never follow behind big trucks or containers,” typed one, while another said they would have “no sympathy for them when they get crushed”.

For those of you earnestly clutching your bingo cards, a Facebook user (not Grant Shapps) argued that it would be “fair for all drivers” if cyclists were forced to have number plates, so they can be summoned “next time they tailgate behind a vehicle or cycle dangerously”.

Someone was going to mention number plates at some point, even in Singapore where, incidentally, the country’s Senior Minister of State for Transport, Chee Hong Tat, ‘pulled a Shapps’ last year by suggesting that cyclists could require licences following a review of cycling safety laws…

14 September 2022, 11:18
AbsoluteBlack or AbsoluteCharred?

Ah, now we know why AbsoluteBlack’s new disc brake pads (featured on yesterday’s blog) cost so much, it’s all starting to make sense…

Proper engineering, that.

14 September 2022, 10:52
“Go do Worlds in Australia they said, it would be fun they said…”: Kangaroo takes out cyclist

First swooping magpies, now kangaroos targeting cyclists – No wonder Tom Pidcock didn’t fancy racing the road worlds in Australia this year…

While most cycling fans responded to the video by speculating (jokingly, I may add) about whether the potential of animal attacks was the real reason behind the absence of some top names from this month’s Wollongong worlds, one Spanish-speaking Twitter user noted the reckless nature of the kangaroo’s attempted overtake, where he pointed out that “the 1.5m distance was conspicuous by its absence”…

14 September 2022, 09:44
niki terpstra 2020 - via total direct energie website
Paris-Roubaix and Tour of Flanders winner Niki Terpstra announces retirement

Niki Terpstra, the winner of the 2014 edition of Paris-Roubaix and the 2018 Tour of Flanders, has announced that he will retire from professional cycling at the end of the season.

However, the 38-year-old TotalEnergies rider, who made the announcement on his Instagram page, has hinted that he will continue racing in 2023, perhaps in a different discipline.

“At the end of this season, I will retire from professional road cycling,” he said in the video.

“Ever since I was eight, I’ve been obsessed with cycling. I imagined cycling in the big races. I’ve managed to cycle them all and be victorious at my dream races.

“My career is filled with extreme highs and lows and, with everyone who has supported me, family, friends, fans, we can be proud of what we’ve achieved. I still love cycling and I will continue doing that but in a different way.”

After turning pro with Milram in 2007, the Dutch cobbled classics specialist spent the most successful years of his career in the colours of Belgian team Quick Step, where he enjoyed a spectacularly successful 2014 season, winning the Tour of Qatar, Dwars door Vlaanderen and the Queen of the Classics, Paris-Roubaix.

Despite another stunning year in 2018, which saw him take the E3 Harelbeke-Tour of Flanders double in the spring, Terpstra left Quick Step for TotalEnergies, where he failed to live up to his past successes despite the full backing of the French squad.

14 September 2022, 09:25
‘Why don’t cyclists use the cycle lanes?’, part 1,386
14 September 2022, 07:56
“The AA aren’t advising people not to drive”: Cyclists react to British Cycling’s state funeral guidance

As you all probably know by now, British Cycling moved swiftly yesterday evening to remove a somewhat controversial piece of advice, placed on its website shortly after Queen Elizabeth II’s death on Thursday, which “strongly recommended” that all cyclists in Great Britain should avoid riding their bikes during Monday’s state funeral.

The national governing body’s rapid U-turn on Bank Holiday leisure cycling – which only came after a furious online backlash, of course, and doesn’t apply to extremely disrespectful club rides – has nevertheless failed to appease cyclists across the country, many of whom believe that the “damage was done” following the initial ‘advice’.

> British Cycling removes advice telling members not to ride during funeral for Queen Elizabeth II

To kick things off this overcast Wednesday, I thought I’d round up some of the reaction to British Cycling’s mark of respect/PR disaster.

Under our story yesterday, road.cc reader Mark Skinner summed up the general feeling within the cycling community to the governing body’s advice, writing: “I’m looking forward to the RAC's ‘guidance’ telling motorists not to drive.”

eburtthebike concurred, describing British Cycling’s decisions as “utterly absurd, complete twaddle and well beyond their remit. 

“This is just pandering to the jingoistic populist patriotic DM reading elements in society and will gain absolutely no respect from anyone. 

“The Queen was the patron of Cycling UK and they have made no such comment, so I'm grateful I'm a member of them, not BC.

“Has the RAC or AA suggested that nobody drive at those times?”

Steve K, alluding to the viewpoint that the advice was based on the potential for backlash against cyclists seen riding outside on Monday, asked: “Surely anyone who might be hostile to cyclists riding at the time of the funeral will themselves be inside watching the funeral, so unaware of any cyclists out and about?”

On Twitter, where one user memorably described the advice as “worthy of the Stasi”, the reaction was as equally bemused:

And, finally, on a lighter (if slightly obvious) note:

Ryan Mallon

After obtaining a PhD, lecturing, and hosting a history podcast at Queen’s University Belfast, Ryan joined road.cc in December 2021 and since then has kept the site’s readers and listeners informed and enthralled (well at least occasionally) on news, the live blog, and the road.cc Podcast. After boarding a wrong bus at the world championships and ruining a good pair of jeans at the cyclocross, he now serves as road.cc’s senior news writer. Before his foray into cycling journalism, he wallowed in the equally pitiless world of academia, where he wrote a book about Victorian politics and droned on about cycling and bikes to classes of bored students (while taking every chance he could get to talk about cycling in print or on the radio). He can be found riding his bike very slowly around the narrow, scenic country lanes of Co. Down.

Add new comment

36 comments

Avatar
NOtotheEU | 2 years ago
1 like

Who would have thought that Sinn Féin would prioritise something that burns well, creates smoke and sometimes kills people over cycling eh?

Avatar
Rome73 replied to NOtotheEU | 2 years ago
3 likes

Who would have thought the DUP would be anti democratic? Obviously everyone knows they are brexthick but anti democratic too? Who would have thought it. 

Avatar
NOtotheEU replied to Rome73 | 2 years ago
2 likes

BIRMINGHAMisaDUMP wrote:

Who would have thought the DUP would be anti democratic? Obviously everyone knows they are brexthick but anti democratic too? Who would have thought it. 

I thought I was on safe ground putting down what was the political wing of a terrorist group and is now seemingly not very pro cycling but you still found a way of making it about Brexit. Well done, kudos to you,

Avatar
Cycloid | 2 years ago
7 likes

I would be quite happy to keep to the LHS of the road IF overtaking vehicles would give me enough space when overtaking and make allowance for the fact that I may want to avoid potholes. Afterall I don't like having an impatient driver behind me anymore than they like being delayed by a cyclist.

However:-
If there is enough room for a Fiat Uno to overtake safely then a SUV will squeeze through.
If there is enough room for a SUV to overtake safely then a Transit will squeeze through.
If there is enough room for a Transit to overtake safely then a HGV will squeeze through.
etc.
Take Prime or Prime+ when you need to.
That bit of road to your left is your safety margin and escape route.

Avatar
OnYerBike | 2 years ago
9 likes

RE primary position.

This blog may be of interest: https://departmentfortransport.wordpress.com/2012/06/28/fuck-you-john-fr...

My two cents: I would certainly agree that "it's not a formula to lead to more cycling of all ages/abilities" and "we need to speed up infra and design to stop it being a needed thing at all."

BUT, in the meantime, advocating primary position in certain circumstances, or at the very least a more assertive secondary position at all times (1m+ from the kerb) can improve safety and reduce close passes. I absolutely understand that some people feel uncomfortable taking an assertive position on the road, but in my opinion that discomfort is less than the discomfort that results from closs passes. 

I would also say (again, solely on my annectodal experience) the fear that drivers will become irate if you take an assertive position is overblown, and if people tried it they would find they have, overall, a more positive experience. 

Avatar
Ramz | 2 years ago
8 likes

To the geniuses who say cyclists should stick to the left of the lane: shut up. There is a very simple reason Bikeability stage 2 (basically immediately you take a child and teach them to use the road) teaches them to use primary: it is essential for safety. Even if there are some cases where secondary position is recommended, primary position is required to perform basic manouvres safely (turning for example) and is recommended for others (approaching junctions, etc). Furthermore please check where secondary position is, because it's not where you think it is!

Avatar
Seagull2 | 2 years ago
4 likes

Re  ‘Why don’t cyclists use the cycle lanes?’, part 1,386  ,  this section is part of my commute in Dublin ,  it's a 6 lane dual carriageway , downhill section, easily 35-40 kph on bike . I occasionally come across cars pulled in there awaiting someone from a bus, or dropping off a family member. Most drivers in fairness stay out of the bike lane. Unfortunately there is no enforcement by the police , so the handful of offenders know there is v unlikely to be any consequence for them for parking up in the lane, and i am sure they think a "sure i'm only pulling in for a short while " and a smile will placate any discommoded cyclist. I have given up challenging them , unless i have my 11 year daughter with me,  when i absolutely will make the point on safety gorunds 

Avatar
Sanshelmut | 2 years ago
2 likes

Meh. I draft lorries all the time on my commute. I never get overlly close, but enough to benefit from the pull.

 

Avatar
andystow replied to Sanshelmut | 2 years ago
3 likes

Sanshelmut wrote:

Meh. I draft lorries all the time on my commute. I never get overlly[sic] close, but enough to benefit from the pull.

The perhaps not completely obvious danger is something in the road (tyre carcass, dead animal, brick, 6" deep pothole) that the lorry can drive right over with no trouble at all, will suddenly appear in front of you from under the lorry. I hope you're at least a few seconds back.

Avatar
Sanshelmut replied to andystow | 2 years ago
1 like

Aye, that's very true and i'm aware of those problems (i just didn't type them out). Some lorries (I live near a prominent cargo port) you can see fairly fair underneith them, I don;t go anywhere near the ones carrying loose materials (concrete lorries, waste metal recycling, hardcore, etc) and I know exactly where all the potholes are (even after they resurfaced it).

Avatar
iandusud replied to Sanshelmut | 2 years ago
7 likes

"Pushing primary position cycling as far as I'm concerned does more harm than good. I get the theory, it's just that in practice it doesn't work. Drivers get irate..."

Drivers who get irate behind the wheel of a car are not fit to drive and should hand in their licence. 

Avatar
Rendel Harris | 2 years ago
9 likes

Many top end cycling shoes – including Sidi, Bont, Lake, Vittoria and others - use kangaroo leather, perhaps Skippy has just been biding his time until the best in the world gather on his continent and now he will have his vengeance.

Avatar
ktache replied to Rendel Harris | 2 years ago
2 likes

Hirzl use it for the palms on their cycling gloves.

Sounds wonderful, providing grip even when wet.

But I don't know if it will take the regular machine washing I have to give my cycling gear.

Avatar
riggbeck | 2 years ago
15 likes

The people who think nobody should go out on the 19th for anything pleasure related will not be out to see those that do go out, sounds like a kind of nirvana where you only meet people enjoying themselves.

Avatar
ktache replied to riggbeck | 2 years ago
1 like

With almost everything being closed, it might be like lockdown, but with a more republican tinge...

Avatar
IanMK | 2 years ago
6 likes

Perhaps a better question would be; are the Ramblers Association telling people not to go on a hike?

Avatar
Awavey | 2 years ago
5 likes

Strangely I suspect the AA & RAC will probably advise people not to drive into London on the day of the funeral,or where there are local arrangements, alot of towns & cities are setting up public screenings of the funeral. And there is already travel advice for use of the railways and from TfL for guidance during the mourning period.

I dont feel I need to be appeased by BC, because I was neither furious or outraged by their guidance, I simply noted it.

But there you go I often feel the reaction to exaggerate everything thousandfold for social media clicks is far more disrespectful than the initial error of judgement.

BC corrected the guidance very quickly, my advice would be just keep calm and carry on.

Avatar
OnYerBike replied to Awavey | 2 years ago
12 likes

Awavey wrote:

Strangely I suspect the AA & RAC will probably advise people not to drive into London on the day of the funeral,or where there are local arrangements, alot of towns & cities are setting up public screenings of the funeral. And there is already travel advice for use of the railways and from TfL for guidance during the mourning period.

You are quite possibly correct; however, the distinction is that any advice not to drive (or other travel advice) will no doubt be couched entirely in terms of practicalities - i.e. roads may be closed, trains may be busy, schedules may be changed etc (much like the advice given around other major events).

I very much doubt there will be any suggestion that the mere act of driving is somehow disrespectful or inappropriate during a period of mourning.

Avatar
Patrick9-32 replied to OnYerBike | 2 years ago
5 likes

"the mere act of driving is (...) disrespectful or inappropriate"

Words to live by 3 

Avatar
Awavey replied to OnYerBike | 2 years ago
3 likes

Well as we are choosing to debate the since REMOVED advice to the nth degree, and seem to have totally lost the capability to interpret for ourselves and require everything to be spelled out.

I would argue the specific distinction you are making was not added as a qualifier to either the statement "Has the RAC or AA suggested that nobody drive at those times?" or "The AA arent advising people not to drive"

So how are we supposed to know that in this context those statements accept the AA & RAC will offer practical travel advice about not travelling ?

And since BC never explained the reasons for their initial,but since REMOVED, guidance, how can we assume it had anything to do with BC concerns about cycling being disrespectful or inappropriate during the specific times of the funeral, maybe they assumed there were practical reasons, ie roads may closed, schedules may be changed, much like the advice given around other major events...

And we are of course in the period of mourning now, and BCs guidance for that remains unchanged as far as I can tell, it was specific to the funeral.

Avatar
Simon E replied to Awavey | 2 years ago
2 likes

Awavey wrote:

Well as we are choosing to debate the since REMOVED advice to the nth degree, and seem to have totally lost the capability to interpret for ourselves and require everything to be spelled out.

It was ridiculously ill-advised advice that should never have been conceived, never mind published.

But that it was published by an organisation that supposedly works on behalf of people who ride is very concerning.

Overreaction on social media (and road.cc comments section) is a sign of these fractious times but it is really, really unhelpful that BC may have provided fuel to people who have an irrational dislike of other people because they are riding bicycles.

Avatar
hawkinspeter replied to OnYerBike | 2 years ago
19 likes

OnYerBike wrote:

I very much doubt there will be any suggestion that the mere act of driving is somehow disrespectful or inappropriate during a period of mourning.

It's just a matter of time until they cancel the funeral out of respect for the queen

Avatar
brooksby replied to hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
6 likes

hawkinspeter wrote:

OnYerBike wrote:

I very much doubt there will be any suggestion that the mere act of driving is somehow disrespectful or inappropriate during a period of mourning.

It's just a matter of time until they cancel the funeral out of respect for the queen

I did see an article on a tabloid news site this morning, outraged about how one of the morning TV programmes was out talking to people queuing for the coffin and offering them doughnuts, and - and they were talking normally and even laughing, as if it was a normal queue rather than a sacred and holy event... 

Avatar
IanMSpencer replied to brooksby | 2 years ago
1 like

Well, we had to be respectfully behaved in 1987 to view the body of Mao Tse Tung through several inches of glass, and he'd been dead for 11 years. Didn't even get to take a photo of the ghoulish green apparition before us.

Avatar
chrisonabike replied to hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
2 likes

Fair enough - Kim Il Sung is still president in North Korea so why should we be outdone?

Avatar
SimoninSpalding replied to hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
3 likes

Meanwhile, good news! The BBC are going to run a livestream of the Queen's coffin!

Avatar
hawkinspeter replied to SimoninSpalding | 2 years ago
11 likes

SimoninSpalding wrote:

Meanwhile, good news! The BBC are going to run a livestream of the Queen's coffin!

Deadstream, surely?

Avatar
vthejk replied to hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
8 likes

hawkinspeter wrote:

SimoninSpalding wrote:

Meanwhile, good news! The BBC are going to run a livestream of the Queen's coffin!

Deadstream, surely?

I was going to say "Too Soon!" but it's never too soon for quality black humour.

Avatar
SimoninSpalding replied to vthejk | 2 years ago
3 likes

For some reason I am envisaging an update every evening on BBC2 with Chris Packham and Michaela Strachan talking about the "highlights".

Avatar
brooksby replied to SimoninSpalding | 2 years ago
4 likes

What sort of updates are the BBC expecting to see?  It's a box, in a big room, guarded by soldiers.  It's not like the box is going to open or something ("Surpriiiise!", cries a laughing monarch to her disappointed son).

Too soon? 

Pages

Latest Comments