Licences, registration and even number plates on bicycles have been the talk of the UK cycling community these past few weeks ever since the likely soon-to-be-replaced Transport Secretary's comments about toughening the law on bike riders were published on the front pages of national newspapers.
And while his interest in number plates on bikes was short-lived and has since been backtracked on, it got us thinking — is there anywhere in the world that requires, or has required in the past, cyclists to be licensed?
United Kingdom
Let's start closest to home...
Until a couple of months ago the idea of cyclists needing to be licensed to use the roads was little more than a social media 'debate' occasionally worthy of an airing on morning TV or radio talk shows.
As recently as December, the Department for Transport said there were "no plans" to implement a formal registration system for cyclists, saying the costs of introducing such a system would "outweigh the benefits".
Grant Shapps' comments relit the spotlight on the issue, but were followed by backtracking on number plates for cyclists. The then Transport Secretary, who was out of a job once Liz Truss became Prime Minister, suggested a toughening of the rules for cyclists would be considered as part of the current review that may see a causing death by dangerous cycling law introduced.
Thankfully, nothing came of it and the debate has gone away for a while.
United States and Canda
City planner and urban mobility expert Brent Toderian explained the licensing discussion "pops up every once in a while in North American cities, usually fuelled by conservative talk radio. It gets a little bit of fire and heat for a week or so and then goes away".
"As those who are actually informed on the issue point out all the reasons why it's far too expensive, won't work, and would be detrimental to actual stated public goals. Usually the conversation is initiated by the same people who would rather see fewer bikes and less safe bike infrastructure," he told us.
With legislation changing from state to state and even more locally, PeopleForBikes explained there are some parts of North America where licensing (of sorts) is required.
"Hawaii residents need to register their traditional and electric bicycles, but they are not required to have a licence," the group told us.
Permanent registration costs $15 and is applicable for anyone aged 18 or over. Bikes registered in another state do not need to be registered again in Hawaii.
"Several cities in Northern California have them, and many places in Florida require bike registrations. We thought Salt Lake City, and Utah in general, had one but perhaps that's changed — it's vague on the Salt Lake City website as to whether or not it's required.
(CC BY-NC-ND 2.0 license by BeyondDC:Flickr)
"Montgomery County, a huge county in Maryland outside of Washington D.C., only repealed its bike registration requirements in 2020. Lots of places have repealed them but every year somewhere new tries to introduce them under the pretence of raising funds (because they often cost money) or helping identify lost bikes when they're stolen. It's my personal opinion that they do far more harm than good though."
Australia
Perhaps surprisingly considering the library of strict laws and hefty penalty fines that cyclists Down Under can find themselves on the receiving end of, Australia does not require bike riders to be licensed.
As Brent pointed out is the case in the United States, Australia also has semi-regular calls for some form of licensing, most recently in 2014 when New South Wales Roads Minister Duncan Gay unsuccessfuly pushed for a cycling licence to be introduced.
Instead, he upped the fines for rule-breaking cyclists.
Netherlands
Oh come on, this is the home of the sensible approach to cycling as a form of sustainable and cheap transport, you weren’t really expecting the Dutch to make everyone register their bikes, were you? No, in the Netherlands, registration and licensing is not required.
And before we turn to another country, it is good to remind ourselves that Holland hasn’t always been brilliant for cycling. Amsterdam was once ruled by the car, but with some decent leadership, things have changed over the past 50 or so years to create a city that, by all accounts, is a very nice place to live.
Denmark
One place where bikes do have to be registered, is Denmark. This is, however, not a customer requirement, but something that the manufacturers must take care of.
The Danes have a 'VIN-system', introduced in 1942, which gives all bicycles a unique code embedded into the frame. It is illegal to sell frames in the country without a VIN and insurance companies refuse to pay out on stolen bicycles without one, but the system is more of an anti-theft measure than a registration.
Switzerland
Cyclists in Switzerland used to need a CHF-5-10 vignette sticker on their bikes for insurance purposes, however this began to be phased out in 2012. While being a registration scheme it was also to force riders into obtaining third-party liability insurance.
Support for the system waned at the turn of the 2010s as it was acknowledged that the cost of the scheme was outweighing the benefits.
Having baulked at the price of a beer there, we’ve learned that if the Swiss think something is too expensive then it most definitely is.
Japan
[CC licensed image by neekoh.fi:Flickr]
Japan remains the most prominent current example of a major nation requiring citizens to register their bikes and, after purchasing a bicycle, riders are legally obliged to register their machine.
Registration costs around £3 and is often done as the bike is purchased, with a form including personal details submitted. Upon completion a small sticker can be added to the bike. It's worth noting again, as with Denmark's VIN, the registration is primarily an anti-theft measure.
North Korea
And finally the one you've all been waiting for...
Up until 1992, bicycles were banned in the capital, Pyongyang, although even with the ban lifted the cost is far out of reach for many. Cyclists in the country reportedly must get a license to use their bikes, pass a road safety test and register their bicycle.
Then again, given the lack of information that gets out of North Korea, we’re really not sure whether the licencing requirement is still in place.
So yes, in short, were the UK to go down the path of requiring all cyclists to register their bikes or obtain a licence, North Korea might just be the closest comparison...
Add new comment
63 comments
Many other European countries inforce the registration and licensing of bicycle and cyclists.
As it is mandatory if anyone wants to ride on public roads.
In the UK, unfortunately there are many disrespectful cyclists that have no clue about road/traffic regulations/laws.
Many causing accidents and running away.
Others, specially in London that simply do not respect the traffic lights nor signals and someone whom thinks its above the law saying its stupid to inforce a licence?
This person must be an idiot period.
It's cool to ride a bike, it's cheaper, many use it as they have no other alternative to travel to work.
Provably more than 50% that ride a bike don't have a clue about road traffic regulations and we see this everyday.
Don't just show in the news when a cyclists is being bullied, show the all true of the day by day struggle from drivers against the disrespectful behaviour of cyclists and the dangerous way they ride in the city's roads👌.
If your defending cyclists you MUST also criticised them when they are wrong 👌.
Car/van/motorcycle drivers pay taxes, insurance to cover themselves, specially against negligence of cyclists that even demand compensation for their own mistakes....
You should all think about this in a near future, before it escalates to more deaths and always blaming drivers and never the cyclists.
Can I be the first to give you a warm welcome to road.cc, a place where we welcome all kinds of spelling, grammar, logic and "facts". Someone will be with you shortly...
Fighting satire* with satire... Good stuff.
*At least I think it must have been - it was the "disrespectful" that gave it away.
Yes, we seem to be afflicted by more than an acceptable number of malevolent dimwits presently
The thing is, as a driver, when was the last time you thought you were going to breath your last due to a cyclist?
I can tell you my last experience of believing I was going to die due to a motorist: 10:18am on Tuesday.
How many motorists have you known personally who have died due to cyclists? Can you beat 5 cyclists killed in our club over the last decade?
So don't play the false equivalence.
My daughter, who is a police officer, knocked on the window of a car who drew next to her about a foot away. "Is that 1.5 metres" "Don't you f***king touch my car again." Tap! "@*£&@" Driver Meltdown!
citation needed
Hi Drago.
Thanks for your inciteful post. It started quite well but turned into absolute dog crap after this bit.
"Drago | 1 post | 12 hours ago"
I like that word.
Is Drago a Slavic form of Nigel?
You know. It's really not worth the effort or time countering any of your points here. I struggle to understand why somebody signs up to a forum, has an uneducated rant and doesn't bother to engage with any of the people who respond.
IIRC japan has no penality for not registering your bike. However if the police come in to posession of it (lost, stolen, damaged while locked up etc) then they will immediately dispose of it if it isn't registered...
I believe the US cities that have it have a long history of racism (i.e. basically the only people charged for not being registered in several decades are black...)
Why not try setting a different agenda - make fitting front and rear cameras compulsory for motor vehicles, with 6 points on the licence of the registered keeper if footage is not available. All footage required to be retained for 7 days and must be permanently retained if a NIP is received.
Given the absolutely cack driving we see on UK Dashcams when such a small percentage of cars run them, knowing you are recording your own incompetence would be like being in a permanent average speed camera zone. While we are at it, legislate for GPS to be admissible for sustained speeding.
While we are at it, add in cycle detection technology and provide a system for close passes to be automatically reported.
Awesome ideas!
Imagine how safe (or empty!) the roads would become.
Are we still going on about this? I think this horse is well and truly dead; it's time to stop flogging it.
At one time Western Australia required bicycle registration - I think the requirement stopped in the early 1960s. When I was going to school there slightly after that time, I used to see bikes being ridden around that still had their registration plates, even though they were no longer required. See https://historicalcycleclub.com.au/news/2017/5/12/wa-bicycle-number-plates.
If you've read The Trial by Franz Kafka you may remember that at the start of the book when he's being arrested, he needs ID and finds his bicycle licence, but decides it's too trivial an item for those arresting him.
Kafka had the right idea with regard to bicycle licencing.
I've been to N Korea a few times. Don't ever remember seeing evidence that bikes were registered. Riders may have been I suppose. The thing that struck me most though was that all the bikes had locks. I can't think of a place less likely to have a bike theft problem!
Probably to stop capitalist spies and infiltrators - who're everywhere, especially in more repressive and dictatorial places! - using them to bring down the state.
Is working well as a strat tbf - same family in power since 1948.
Wait, so you're saying that if we all stop locking our bikes our govt gets overthrown? Can't hurt to try I suppose... 😁
That was casually put...? Well - you're clearly not Hans Blix anyway (sweary link).
Until the Govt and police force can guarantee that all motorists are legally able to drive, are insured and have road tax I will not even consider the idea of bike number plates etc. However, as the Govt. and police force cannot ensure all of the current motorists are "road legal" this is just a farce and maybe we cyclists are just being seen as an easy monetory target?
as the Govt. and police force cannot ensure all of the current motorists are "road legal" this is just a farce
The police demonstrate a complete lack of interest in whether vehicles are road-legal or not. I found yet another large Mercedes today with no MOT for over 11 months, but I know that Lancashire Constabulary will be proud of completely ignoring the report and will joyfully refuse to act
Is the cycling test in North Korea tougher than the driving test in China?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vT2QVHgf1o
That explains a lot. When I visited there, my employer wouldn't let us rent a car. We were chauffeured, took taxis, or walked everywhere.
My mid-sized Midwest US home still has bicycle registration on the books. I think it's $5 one-time for a sticker. I've met one cyclist who has one.
I'd be willing to bet that if I tried to register mine at the police station, they would have no clue what I was on about.
I can recall my bike as a youngling in the UK having a unique identifying number stamped on the frame - this would be 1980 or so. It may have been examined as part of the Cycling Proficiency process.
When did these fade out, if they did?
Frame numbers, crucial part of combatting bike theft but with no official scheme, just something the manufacturer provided. Often teamed with having your postcode hammered into the bottom bracket, which the police would often do for free at fetes etc. I can remember them at least on steel bikes up to about 2000. Not sure why they died out, are they harder to put into/more likely to compromise aluminium frames? Presumably they couldn't be carved into carbon frames. None of my newer bikes, carbon, aluminium or steel seem to have them, instead having more or less permanent computer barcodes instead. Is it assumed that if you want a marker you would put Smartwater or similar on it? They were very useful as a secondhand buyer, if you looked the bike over and found the frame number had been filed off you knew not to buy as it was nicked.
My Synapse Neo has a serial number stamped on the frame, and that's a 2021 build.
Interesting - it does seem a very commonsense way of making life more difficult for the light-fingered fraternity.
Lovely bike that by the way, had a chat with an owner recently (wasn't you was it? Lights on Grosvenor Place near Vauxhall Bridge!) and they were eulogising it.
Sorry Rendel, only just seen your reply.
Its a gorgeous bike, well worth the money, and without the Bosch motor I wouldn't be riding at all.
And sorry ... wasn't me
Pages