It’s everyone’s favourite brand of news – academic rebuttal news. But don’t worry, it’s about cycle helmets so one way or another there’s a good chance you’ll find something to get worked up about.
Back in 2006, Dr Ian Walker of the University of Bath conducted an experiment you may be aware of within the context of the eternal helmet debate.
Cycling with and without a helmet and with and without a wig, he discovered that cyclists are afforded more space by passing drivers if they are (or at least appear to be) female or if they’re not wearing a helmet.
(In a separate study, conducted in 2013, Walker found that some drivers will pass too closely no matter that you wear.)
Bicycling.com reports that the helmet and wig study (not its official name) was questioned by researchers from the University of New South Wales in 2013.
They analysed the same data – 2,355 observations over 200 miles of riding – and concluded that “bicycle helmet wearing is not associated with close motor vehicle passing.”
They argued that that the average passing distances were greater than one metre – a distance that in some places would not be considered a “close pass.”
Walker and Dorothy Robinson have now responded to the response via a recently published paper in Accident Analysis & Prevention.
Referring to the University of New South Wales analysis, they write: “Their conclusion was based on omitting information about variability in driver behaviour and instead dividing overtakes into two binary categories of ‘close’ and ‘not close’; we demonstrate that they did not justify or address the implications of this choice, did not have sufficient statistical power for their approach, and moreover show that slightly adjusting their definition of ‘close’ would reverse their conclusions.”
They also present a new analysis of the original dataset, measuring directly the extent to which drivers changed their behaviour in response to helmet wearing. “This analysis confirms that drivers did, overall, get closer when the rider wore a helmet.”
"Nigel"?
Which just delays the inevitable unfortunately imo, plus if the government have that kind of money I think there are better ways to promote cycling...
Reminds me of this case, where a driver pulled out on a speeding motorist:...
Nice response from CERATIZIT WNT
There's some fascinating psychology here but the ubiquitous becomes invisible. (The interesting bits are the excellent heuristic shortcuts...
"Friend"? 😄
I rode on the University side towards Peppard Lane, its quite bumpy. The opposite side for sure delivery drivers will park on it., Perhaps that was...
The police will do nothing, and without personal consequences for the driver these unspeakable offences will continue - punctuated by the...
User replaceable batteries. I'm about to replace an otherwise perfectly functional Edge 130 because the battery is knackered. Yes it adds a few...
Happens on unmoderated forum. Forums I have run stamp on anti-social behaviour, and would rather stray into over-moderation than under moderation....