news

Giro d'Italia introduces Best Descender contest - but will it encourage riders to take too many risks?

Riders will reportedly be timed on 10 segments during this months race, with competition winner declared in Milan

This year’s 100th edition of the Giro d’Italia will feature a competition for the best descender -prompting social media users to ask whether it might put riders in danger by encouraging them to take risks.

Blogger Inner Ring posted brief details of the competition to Twitter, later clarifying the source as the rule book for the race, which starts on Sardinia this Friday.

The competition is a new one for 2017, and the financial prizes on offer said to be smaller than those for the main classifications.

However, several people on Twitter have suggested it is irresponsible to offer prizes at all for the fastest descent, given the death of Belgian rider Wouter Weylandt in a crash on the race in 2011 and, just last week, Chad Young dying from injuries sustained at the Tour of the Gila in the US.

> Chad Young dies in hospital five days after horror crash

Leopard-Trek rider Weylandt, aged 26 and winner of a Giro d’Italia stage in 2010, died instantly when he crashed into a wall on a descent during Stage 3 of the 2011 race from Reggio Emilia to Rappallo.

The following day saw one of the most emotional stages ever in the Giro’s history with racing neutralised and teams taking it in turn to lead the peloton until finally the Belgian’s Leopard Trek team mates, plus his close friend Tyler Farrar of Garmin-Cervelo, crossed the line in Livorno arm in arm as one.

> Peloton honours Wouter Weylandt, Leopard Trek pull out of Giro after poignant tribute

Despite his death, and those of other riders killed after crashing while descending, including Motorola’s Fabio Casartelli  in the Pyrenees during the 1995 Tour de France, there have long been calls for organisers of races to offer a descender’s jersey as well as one for the best climber.

The argument goes that it takes a lot more skill to descend rapidly than it does to climb; similarly, there is a school of thought that there should be some kind of combined mountains jersey that takes account of both the ascent and the downhill section – although that would favour climbers given there would be no descent after a summit finish.

Simon has been news editor at road.cc since 2009, reporting on 10 editions and counting of pro cycling’s biggest races such as the Tour de France, stories on issues including infrastructure and campaigning, and interviewing some of the biggest names in cycling. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, his background has proved invaluable in reporting on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, and the bike industry. He splits his time between London and Cambridge, and loves taking his miniature schnauzer Elodie on adventures in the basket of her Elephant Bike.

Latest Comments

  • kil0ran 1 sec ago

    Potentially from house insurance, yes. But I'd rather be certain and have cycling-specific cover due to recent cases. I chop and change house...

  • hawkinspeter 14 min 16 sec ago

    A pair of disk brake RP50s which are pre-black edition. 50mm depth in case that's not obvious.

  • The_Vermonter 53 min 30 sec ago

    I understand where you are coming from but I do not think their target demo is the traditional cyclist. Of the people I know with a Peloton, none...

  • Bobbinogs 1 hour 29 min ago

    Be realistic about how much turbo you think you will be doing. I just turbo when the weather is really rubbish or I am recovering from injury, so I...

  • mrbirch 1 hour 32 min ago

    Fantastic news, even when not on my bike and visiting on 'foot' I've been struck by dangerous it feels with the host of parking along that part of...

  • mdavidford 2 hours 5 min ago

    Only if the 'motorway' is actually a farm track where they're likely to get stuck behind a tractor or a farmer driving their livestock along it.

  • nniff 2 hours 11 min ago

    Assos have got £20 off if you fill in their questionnaire.  It only takes a few minutes but does contain some of the most surreal questions that I...

  • Jerm14 2 hours 13 min ago

    Can I be the first to say comments such as 'call this a list?' or 'what about.....?' and 'how could you not have included.......?'...

  • jollygoodvelo 2 hours 21 min ago

    Another vote that cable discs are a reasonable compromise at this price, though if there was a version with Apex 1 Hydro at maybe £700 that would...

  • kil0ran 2 hours 48 min ago

    Galibier get consistently good reviews - cost around £40. Waiting for Ardennes Shields to arrive and if I like those I'll probably get the other...