Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Anti Pollution Masks

I commute daily 22 miles there and back Stockport to Salford Quays and have done for 10+ years.

Recently I was admitted to hospital with Pneumonia and Viral Flu. The nurses were saying alot of cyclists had been admitted with serious infections and chest issues. I am fit and healthy but I am starting to worry about this traffic laden commute.

Yesterday I was behind a bus for 6 minutes doing around 32mph. Stopped at the traffic lights became dizzy disorentated and immediately felt sick.

Upon getting home I was sick twice and went to bed and had an awfully restless sleep. Has anyone used a pollution mask? Any recomendations?

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

18 comments

Avatar
fenix | 3 years ago
1 like

"Yesterday I was behind a bus for 6 minutes doing around 32mph."

Maybe don't do this in future then ? Where you right by the exhaust or just stuck in its wake ? Yuk. 

Interesting looking back now at a rise in chest infections at the tail end of 2019 isn't it ?  Hope you're fully recovered now. 

Avatar
fenix | 3 years ago
0 likes

"Yesterday I was behind a bus for 6 minutes doing around 32mph."

Maybe don't do this in future then ? Where you right by the exhaust or just stuck in its wake ? Yuk. 

Interesting looking back now at a rise in chest infections at the tail end of 2019 isn't it ?  Hope you're fully recovered now. 

Avatar
Spangly Shiny | 4 years ago
0 likes

3M make several forced air breathing systems for industrial applications, one of which is a face mask fed from a waist mounted filter and pump. I haven' t tried it myself but could this be you answer? Filtered air but without the need to draw it through the filter using lung power alone.

Wish I had something like that back in my Army days, running in an S6 respirator was no joke; hot, sweaty and exhausting.

Avatar
crazy-legs replied to Spangly Shiny | 4 years ago
0 likes

Spangly Shiny wrote:

3M make several forced air breathing systems for industrial applications, one of which is a face mask fed from a waist mounted filter and pump. I haven' t tried it myself but could this be you answer? Filtered air but without the need to draw it through the filter using lung power alone.

Wish I had something like that back in my Army days, running in an S6 respirator was no joke; hot, sweaty and exhausting.

I used to work in an industrial chemistry unit, we wore stuff like that for certain applications. It's a full hood system with hosing in and out and all connected up to a battery powered filter unit which you wear on your belt clip at the bac (to keep it out of the way). There is no way on earth I would try cycling with it.

Also, I have no idea of the cost of it but I suspect it was very high. The battery unit needed regular charging, it'd do for about 20 mins continuous use and then need charging (by which point you'd want to take the whole thing off anyway, it was heavy and annoying!)

We also had a safety officer who's job was to take all the PPE apart, clean it, replace valves and parts etc on a regular basis. Again, I doubt you'd want to be doing that every couple of weeks in your living room.

Avatar
john beltx replied to Spangly Shiny | 3 years ago
0 likes

Hi me i'm using this one the design and quality are very good https://bikemaskpollution.com/

Avatar
Organon | 4 years ago
0 likes

Well in the summer you could at least take the mersey path from the Pyramid to Parrswood. It has less climbing, no traffic and pollution.

Avatar
mancsi | 4 years ago
0 likes

I usually wear a buff, to keep the head and neck warm. In this weather generally above my nose. Easy to drink and clear the nose. Is there any buff thst has some kind of protection? Obviously not to 2.5 microns but anything really. 
we're all suffering 

Avatar
Sniffer replied to mancsi | 4 years ago
2 likes
mancsi wrote:

I usually wear a buff, to keep the head and neck warm. In this weather generally above my nose. Easy to drink and clear the nose. Is there any buff thst has some kind of protection? Obviously not to 2.5 microns but anything really. 
we're all suffering 

No

Avatar
CXR94Di2 | 4 years ago
0 likes

Im not familiar with the area but from describing the route. looking at Google maps, there are many residential areas which would take you away from the main roads.

Health or speed?

Avatar
mancsi | 4 years ago
1 like

Thanks for all the comments. I did read reviews in the Guardian about the Respro but on reading the wiggle reviews it seemed, as everyone confirms useless! I'd also not even considered drinking, spitting, clearing ones nose! 
fallowfield loop is ok just adds a lot of time on and I'm not all that comfy on the road bike. The Btwin mountain bike I have is so heavy I struggle to get it from the cellar! ha

My route is to Stockport centre, then past pets @ home, Heaton Mersey, Parrs Wood, Didsbury, Chorlton..?

 

thanks again for all the replies 
 

Avatar
srh73 replied to mancsi | 3 years ago
0 likes

Parrswood and chorlton are horrible for fumes. I always avoid chorlton by going down nell Lane next to withington hospital then St werburgh's road.Same with parrswood especially the bus stop opposite the entrance to tesco with buses queuing up. tend to by pass it by taking road next to tram terminal then down school lane.

Avatar
Organon | 4 years ago
1 like

I have a Respro but I took the filter out, it did nothing but get me out of breath. It is still good to keep the chill of your chin though. 

 

Have you tried the Fallowfield Loop? It is off road and wonderfully paved. Maybe not great in the dark without strong lights, but if you can get to the Levenshulme end it will drop you off in Chorlton and you can go up the quieter Seymour Grove to the Quays. Much better than going into town via Kingsway or the A6. Tell me your route and I might be able to improve it.

Avatar
DrG82 | 4 years ago
2 likes

Repeating the above, any mask you can comfortably breathe through will be useless for removing the worst bits in traffic pollution.
A study of pedestrian exposure to pollution demonstrated that the most effective way of reducing exposure was to stay away from the edge of the road. Just walking on the inside of the pavement and standing back when waiting at lights was enough to have a significant positive effect. Since reading this I always try to stay back from vehicles infront when waiting at lights or in traffic.

Avatar
ktache | 4 years ago
0 likes

I got a reflective Respro after the Bunscombe fire, riding home on the Sunday evening was hard, breathing in thick, pollution laden fog.  I just couldn't breathe, proper scary, chipped off the ride to work on the Monday and got me the mask on the way to work on the Tuesday morning.

Wore it for a bit, not pleasent, hot and sweaty, the nose rubs, not too easy to breathe.  I couldn't drink or spit while riding, which I found to be very annoying.

I got some Techno filters and valves, just in case.  One morning when weather woman Carol warned of very high pollution I wore it, still an awful experience.

Try and modify the route so it's slightly greener, quieter and less polluted, if possible, might be a better proposition.

Oh, and my liking for facial hair probably makes the benifits of the mask redundent.  With any sort of beard/moustache (even light stubble) the H+S people will not do a face fit test with a standard mask, and to do my job they purchased a powered respirator for me.  A much more pleasent experience,  until you forget about it, and break wind, the position of the power unit means that the smell reaches you very quickly.

Avatar
Rick_Rude | 4 years ago
0 likes

I'd be done if I did 32mph for 6 minutes. I can only hold 30 for about a minute.

Avatar
Xenophon2 | 4 years ago
0 likes

I don't see any type of mask that's effective at stopping small particles work on a bike if you like to go fast, breathing resistance will quickly become inacceptably high.  Don't know if you've ever been in the military but if yes:  remember running whilst wearing a gas mask?  Further, the particulate filters will do nothing to stop noxious gases (nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide....).

Maybe you just overdid it yesterday, 32 mph is a good clip, even behind a bus (which will have exposed you to plenty of exhaust gases, among which carbon monoxide that might explain some of your symptoms (I'm not a medical doctor, I hasten to say).

I commute every day and my solution is to simply accept a longish detour (8 km extra one way) that largely allows me to escape traffic.  Obviously that's not an approach that's feasible for everyone.

Avatar
Pilot Pete replied to Xenophon2 | 3 years ago
0 likes

"Don't know if you've ever been in the military but if yes:  remember running whilst wearing a gas mask?"

God, how many of us have run in S6s and S10s!!!indecision

PP

Avatar
CXR94Di2 | 4 years ago
0 likes

By taking a less busy route or quiet roads will significantly reduce vehicle pollution exposure.

I personally dont commute or go outside in winter. I train in-doors.

Another option would be an ebike so reduce the deep breathing effort and lessen pollution drawn deep into lungs.

Mask will do naff all. You're talking about particulates of 2.5 microns in size. Only a full breathing mask to filter out 2.5 or smaller will work. Darth Vader cycling

Latest Comments