The online furore that greeted Jeremy Vine’s latest cycling video is evidence of an “unconscious bias” against cyclists, perpetuated by decades of negative media coverage, a liability expert has claimed.

According to content creator Big Jobber, Vine’s video, which saw the broadcaster squeezed by an overtaking bus driver while riding in a Kensington bike lane, only sparked such a ferocious online debate because it involved a cyclist, the YouTuber describing the driving captured in the clip as a “catalogue of errors”.

In April 2025, a week after his bike was stolen from outside his home, BBC and Channel 5 presenter Vine announced that he would no longer be posting videos of his bike-based commutes around London – which garnered at least 100 million views over the years – because “the trolling just got too bad” and “the anger they generate has genuinely upset me”.

Last week, however, Vine broke his self-imposed ban by sharing a clip from his morning ride through Kensington (initially on the One Chiswick X account), in a bid to highlight the need for bus stop bypasses, otherwise known as ‘floating bus stops’, and safe, protected cycle lanes.

> “Did I do something wrong here? I’m in the cycle lane!” Jeremy Vine’s bus driver near miss goes viral as broadcaster accused of “performative w***ery”

In the video, captured on Vine’s helmet camera, the presenter can be seen riding along a painted cycle lane when a bus driver passes him before immediately cutting across him to stop.

“Oh no, you can’t. I don’t know why you would think you could do that. Oh Lord,” Vine shouts at the bus driver as he rides past.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Jeremy Vine (@thejeremyvine)

A day later, on his Channel 5 current affairs programme, Vine replayed the incident, asking: “What’s going on? I don’t understand, I’m in the cycle lane! You can’t move past me and then move in, you can’t do that. And that’s why children don’t cycle in London. That’s why you need a proper cycle lane with a kerb.”

“Did I do something wrong here?” he continued. “This is a bad borough for cycling, Kensington, so they don’t believe in anything other than paint. I’m in the cycle lane here, the bus overtakes me, I don’t know why. Why would he do that?”

However, Vine’s astonishment at the bus driver’s actions wasn’t shared by everyone on social media, where commenters lined up to blame the presenter for the near miss.

One X user accused Vine of “yearning to be run over”, while another claimed that he was “frantically speeding up to indulge himself in yet another moment of performative w**kery on a bike”.

Comedian and 1990s panel show regular Lee Hurst even got involved, writing: “A normal person would have braked and not risked being hit by the bus even if the bus was in the wrong. But the actions of some cyclists would rather endanger themselves to prove their self-entitlement.”

> “Wouldn’t happen if he stayed on the pavement”: Driver at fault for ‘dooring’ cyclist, says liability expert – but confused motorists say “it’s time cyclists took responsibility for their own actions”

In the wake of this rather predictable backlash, one of the internet’s most popular dashcam video observers has now got involved, in an attempt to set the record straight with what he described as a “little tirade” against the anti-cycling rhetoric being spread on social media.

Shaun, known as Big Jobber, is a content creator who works in the motor insurance industry and has gained a following in recent years for his videos reviewing dashcam clips of road collisions and explaining liability on the internet.

He’s also gained plaudits within the cycling community for what many regard as his refreshingly balanced perspective on road safety incidents involving people on bikes.

In a lengthy X post, Big Jobber argued that the bus driver was entirely at fault for the near miss with Vine, going so far as to question the driver’s professional abilities.

“The liability would be squarely and solely on the bus driver, they’ve accelerated from behind the cyclist needlessly when they know they need to stop, got alongside, then threw on the anchors and an indicator,” he wrote.

Jeremy Vine alongside bus driver in Kensington cycle lane
Jeremy Vine alongside bus driver in Kensington cycle lane (Image Credit: Jeremy Vine)

Turning his attention to the criticism of Vine’s cycling in the clip, Big Jobber continued: “If this was a car versus bus situation there wouldn’t even be a debate, but because it’s a cyclist, all of a sudden the unconscious bias comes out (decades of angry worded news headlines about cyclists making the roads worse for car drivers, keeps millions of car drivers purchasing newspapers).

“Would I have liked to see the cyclist back out of the situation purely to preserve their safety? Yes. But this in no way makes them the liable party in this situation.

“No doubts in my mind that if Vine sent this to Operation Snap the bus driver wouldn’t be a bus driver for much longer. In all lines of work and career, we know there are silly things we could do that would get us sacked that we shouldn’t do.

“If I looked at my own insurance policy using work systems, or I went into a claim of someone I know, that would get me sacked. That bus driver did a ridiculous move; that will eventually be their downfall if they keep doing them.”

> “Many of our roads were built for cyclists, not cars”: Liability YouTuber slams “empty-headed” anti-cycling hypocrisy after driver with “observational skills of a garden gnome” doors cyclist… but motorists fixate on whether rider was on illegal e-bike

Responding to one motorist’s claim that Vine “wasn’t in the cycle lane when the bus started its manoeuvre”, Big Jobber said: “Cyclists aren’t bound to cycle lanes, roads are a shared space for all, the cycle lane is not relevant to the discussion.

“Roads were built and designed as a shared space long before motor vehicles were invented. Motor vehicle users were graciously allowed to also use the same shared space.”

He continued: “If a motor vehicle overtakes another motor vehicle, then cuts in and there’s a collision, it’s the overtaking vehicle’s fault every time.

“Re-familiarising myself with the Highway Code on this subject… Specifically relating to this clip: The bus driver has broken the first, fourth, ninth (tenth by association), and fourteenth bullet points of rule 163, and eighth and eleventh bullet of 167.”

The Highway Code rules referenced by Big Jobber advise motorists that they should “not get too close to the vehicle you intend to overtake”; “move quickly past the vehicle you are overtaking, once you have started to overtake. Allow plenty of room. Move back to the left as soon as you can but do not cut in”; and “give motorcyclists, cyclists and horse riders and horse drawn vehicles at least as much room as you would when overtaking a car”.

The rules Big Jobber say were also broken by the bus driver include the guidance to not overtake “when you would force another road user to swerve or slow down”, or “cut across cyclists going ahead”.

“That’s a catalogue of errors to have broken two rules, and specifically by seven individual points within those rules,” he said.

Jeremy Vine cyclist
Jeremy Vine 

According to Vine himself, his much-discussed close encounter with a London bus driver demonstrated the need for floating bus stops in the capital.

Bus stop bypasses, a frequent source of debate in active travel circles in recent years, aim to protect cyclists from being stuck behind a stationary bus, being pushed to the edge of the road (like Vine was), or having to pull out into moving traffic by positioning the cycle lane between the pavement and the stop.

However, they have been criticised, particularly by blind campaigners, for forcing pedestrians to cross the cycle lane to get to their stop.

> “I’m impartial on everything – except my own safety”: Jeremy Vine on his cycling “radicalisation”, Twitter trolls, the “gaslighting of cyclists”, and why bad streets and bad drivers cause road danger

But Vine argues that the lack of a bus stop bypass along his commute in Kensington was responsible for his near miss.

“This is what happens when you don’t have one of those,” he said. “Imagine arguing a child on a bike should have to deal with this.

“Buses can’t stop safely in cycle lanes, which is why floating bus stops are being built in every major city around the world.”

Vine’s stance was supported by the Open Chiswick account, who said the video is evidence of “why floating bus stops are necessary on cycle lanes to make cycling an inclusive mode of transport for everybody. Remember: London bus drivers kill somebody every three weeks.”