Like this site? Help us to make it better.


Tram-related cyclist falls in Edinburgh went up last year

30 incidents recorded even though city council insists it is making safety improvements

New figures show that there was an increase last year in the number of cyclists involved in falls caused by the tracks of Edinburgh’s tram system.

The data, obtained by Edinburgh News under a Freedom of Information request, reveal that 30 cyclists came off their bikes in incidents involving tram tracks during 2019.

That compares with an average of 27 times a year from 2009-16 reported by a study led by cycling campaigner and retired orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Chris Oliver.

He said that Edinburgh City Council had ignored warnings about the design of the tracks before the system came into operation in 2009.

> Cyclists win first two cases following Edinburgh tram track falls

“Before the trams were built we went to the council and said we can tell you how to design this well and they didn’t want to know or consider it,” he told the newspaper.

“They never built a proper segregated tramline. It should be better segregated and it is still pretty dangerous.

 “The council just didn’t investigate or listen to advice about good infrastructure.”

Published in 2018, the study led by Professor Oliver saw researchers study emergency admissions to hospitals in Edinburgh and West Lothian of patients with tram-related injuries between May 2009 and April 2016.

They identified 191 cyclists who had been injured, 119 male and 72 female, and discovered that one in three patients – 63 in all – suffered fractures or dislocations, 55 of those to upper limbs, eight to lower limbs, and two to the face.

 “They were often forced to change direction either because of a vehicle close to the tramline or changing direction to make a safe move across the tramlines,” he explained.

“The current infrastructure forces cyclists to take action to avoid a crash and it is often a taxi.

“The council are trying very hard for the city centre but it is the area around the trams elsewhere in the city that is bad.

“The people who are involved in these accidents have their confidence knocked and about a third of people never go back to cycling again. It just puts them off and puts them off the activity forever.”

Edinburgh City Council’s transport and environment convener, Councillor Lesley Macinnes, insisted that the council was gradually introducing safety improvements on the route.

“Cycle safety is of utmost importance to us and over the last few years we have been working to deliver a phased programme of cycle safety improvements along the tram route,” she said.

“As part of this we’ve already significantly enhanced road markings, signage and signalling beside the line and are progressing with the third phase of the scheme, which will include changes to junctions, increasing safety and prioritising people on bikes.

“Like other European and UK cities with trams, it takes time for the tram to become part of the environment,” she added.

“We’ve worked extremely hard to ensure cycling provision is integral to the Trams to Newhaven project, which will incorporate segregated cycle lanes on Leith Walk and an onward cycle route to Ocean Terminal, and have involved local cycling groups throughout.

“Once complete, this route will feed into broader plans to transform walking and cycling provision across the city, including the City Centre West to East Cycle Link.”

In June 2017, medical student Zhi Min Soh was killed when her bike’s wheel became stuck in a tram track and she was thrown into the path of a minibus.

Simon joined as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment


Sriracha | 4 years ago

Sounds like typical misuse of statistics to me. 30 seems entirely consistent with an average of 27 over the previous 7 years, not indicative of an increase.

Philh68 | 4 years ago

So more attention should be put on Saferails,

The problem has always existed, don’t just accept that’s the way it has to be - change it.

NPlus1Bikelights | 4 years ago

I find Princes St. stressful it in the wet.

“Like other European and UK cities with trams, it takes time for the tram to become part of the environment,” she added. 

AKA victim blaming and SMIDGF. 

As they are extending it, expect incidents to increase again when that is finished in 2029. 


Latest Comments