Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Tailgating lorry driver gets year in jail for breaking pensioner cyclist's leg

“Every road user is entitled to use the road way,” says judge

A lorry driver who tailgated a 74-year-old cyclist before getting out of his cab and pushing him off has been jailed for a year. Peterborough Crown Court heard that 66-year-old Richard Payne had accused the cyclist of making an offensive gesture as he overtook, but the judge said there was no suggestion of any improper action by the cyclist.

The Peterborough Telegraph reports that on June 27 at about 5pm, the victim was cycling along Station Road in March when Payne, driving a large HGV with trailer, approached from behind.

Transport minister says that cyclists are more dangerous to “commuters” than drivers

Charles Snelling, prosecuting, said: “The victim had mirrors on his bike, and could see how close the lorry was behind him, and that the lorry was trying to get past. The cyclist pulled over at a junction on Elm Road and waved the lorry past.”

At this point Payne pulled in front of the cyclist, causing him to stop. He got out of his cab, walked over to the victim and accused him of making an offensive gesture. He then pushed him over, using both hands, before walking away and driving off.

The incident was witnessed by another motorist, who had also been tailgated by Payne that day.

Snelling said that after being pushed over, the cyclist was still straddling the bike and could not get up because of the pain in his left leg. It was later discovered that he had suffered a broken femur which required surgery to fix. He now has a pin in the leg, which will remain in place permanently.

The victim also had an underlying heart condition and spent time in the critical care unit in hospital due to concerns over his heart rate.

Video: Car passenger pushed cyclist off bike… for a laugh

David Corbino, defending, said Payne had no previous convictions recorded against him, and had pleaded guilty to inflicting grievous bodily harm at an early opportunity.

Judge Sean Enright told Payne: “Every road user is entitled to use the road way – it is not confined to those with an engine. Horse and bike riders have equal entitlement.”

“It can be very intimidating for riders to be tailgated in this way and to be overtaken at speed,” he said. “A cyclist has no way out when a motorist pulls over and starts an altercation.”

In passing the sentence, he said: “This is a course of action I consider to be on the short side.”

As well as the jail term, Payne was also ordered to pay a £900 criminal courts charge and a £100 victim surcharge.

Alex has written for more cricket publications than the rest of the road.cc team combined. Despite the apparent evidence of this picture, he doesn't especially like cake.

Add new comment

7 comments

Avatar
DaveE128 | 9 years ago
3 likes

If he'd done it with the lorry I fear he would have had a far lighter punishment. IMHO using a vehicle should be even worse than using your hands.

Avatar
don simon fbpe | 9 years ago
0 likes

"Payne had accused the cyclist of making an offensive gesture as he overtook"

And

the

obvious

reaction

to

this

is

physical

violence.

Secondly,

he

tailgates,

I

guess,

because

he's

in

s

rush

to

get

past,

then

wastes

time

stopping,

getting

out,

pushing,

then moving off.

Not

much

of

a

rush

then...
 

Avatar
pdw | 9 years ago
4 likes

The mistake that this driver made was getting out of his vehicle to assault the cyclist, hence GBH rather than a driving-related charge.

Avatar
OldRidgeback | 9 years ago
2 likes

Given the offender's previous record, it does beg the question as to why he should be allowed to drive at all. Some people are clearly not fit to be licence holders and removing that entitlement permanently would be in the best interests of all.

Avatar
psling replied to OldRidgeback | 9 years ago
0 likes

OldRidgeback wrote:

Given the offender's previous record, it does beg the question as to why he should be allowed to drive at all. Some people are clearly not fit to be licence holders and removing that entitlement permanently would be in the best interests of all.

 

Quote:

 David Corbino, defending, said Payne had no previous convictions recorded against him... 

 

Not sure your comment tallies entirely with the report!! But the Judge's comments regarding sharing the road are spot on and should be an example to all judges.

Avatar
Das | 9 years ago
3 likes

A year? Good Lord, what ever next? Lifetime Ban for killing cyclists. Well you can only dream eh?

 

Avatar
Jacobi | 9 years ago
8 likes

“Every road user is entitled to use the road way – it is not confined to those with an engine. Horse and bike riders have equal entitlement.”

“It can be very intimidating for riders to be tailgated in this way and to be overtaken at speed,” he said. “A cyclist has no way out when a motorist pulls over and starts an altercation.”

Wise words that should be imparted to every non-cycling motor vehicle driver.

Latest Comments