Cardiff Council has been criticised after the bike hangars introduced to the city were unveiled at twice the price of the same storage in London.

The 17 hangars, provided by Cyclehoops, are part of a pilot scheme that began last month to improve cycle storage in neighbourhoods with terraced housing. But whilst most London boroughs charge a resident an annual storage space subscription between £50 and £60, Cardiff Council are charging residents £120, as first reported by the BBC.

In contrast, Cyclehoops offers a standard fee to councils of £72 a year, with prices variable according to subsidies made by local authorities. The cheapest annual subscription in the UK is £11 a year in Dundee, Scotland.

Chris Roberts, chair of the Cardiff Cycle City organisation and a former General Secretary of Welsh Labour, said the pricing was an “injustice”, considering that the price was more than treble that of a residential car parking permit in many of the same locations.

“It was great news, until we found out they were going to the be the most expensive bike hangars in the UK. In Splott, [one of the most deprived neighbourhoods in Wales] you are paying more to park your bike than in Islington. For someone on a low income, £120 a year is a lot.

Bike hangars, Islington
Bike hangars, Islington (Image Credit: Islington Council)

“Most of these bike hangars are going to less affluent parts of the city where people don’t have the income for a drive and a garage,” Roberts added.

> Over 3,000 cyclists waiting for bike hangar space, as council aims to deliver parking infrastructure “suitable for larger bikes and cargo bikes”

Cardiff Council said that it would provide further detail on the pricing policy “when it is available”. The BBC added it understood that part of the reasoning for the higher subscription costs was an agreement that Cyclehoops would provide quicker maintenance and repairs to any damaged hangars. But Roberts says that the prices are creating “an income cut-off point” and “anti-cycling” by making it prohibitively expensive for people to cycle, despite the council’s stated aims.

In 2022, Cardiff Council unveiled its Stronger Fairer Greener policy document. Included among the proposals to be achieved by 2027 was an ambition to “reduc[e] the dependency on private cars whilst making it easier, safer and cheaper for people to walk, cycle or use public transport” with “secure cycle parking across key local centres” included as part of that.

Alongside the bike hangars, Cyclehoop also specialise in retrofitting bike storage around lampposts and using vehicle-shaped bike racks to highlight the spatial savings that can be made by travelling on two wheels.

Cyclehoop Car Bike Port 03.jpg
Cyclehoop Car Bike Port 03.jpg (Image Credit: Cyclehoop)

The hangars have become controversial for some motorists angry at being deprived an additional parking space to accommodate 12 bicycles. But, in an interview with road.cc last year, Cyclehoop inventor Anthony Lau said “Cycling is growing and will continue to grow, and it needs more space. There is always going to be someone who doesn’t like change, and they’ll see that space as belonging to the driver.

“And I think that’s a mentality we have to change – the streets aren’t designed for cars, they’re designed for people. And cycling is something we have to prioritise, and that means making unpopular decisions.”

> “Driving a car is just too easy”: Bikehangar inventor on theft, the need for safe cycle storage, and why “there are too many cars on our streets”