At road.cc every product is thoroughly tested for as long as it takes to get a proper insight into how well it works. Our reviewers are experienced cyclists that we trust to be objective. While we strive to ensure that opinions expressed are backed up by facts, reviews are by their nature an informed opinion, not a definitive verdict. We don't intentionally try to break anything (except locks) but we do try to look for weak points in any design. The overall score is not just an average of the other scores: it reflects both a product's function and value – with value determined by how a product compares with items of similar spec, quality, and price.What the road.cc scores mean
Good scores are more common than bad, because fortunately good products are more common than bad.
Mention the name Haynes and most people will immediately think of workshop manuals. Haynes Publishing has offered a cycling maintenance guide since 1994, and with this latest edition 'The Bike Book' has surely had more updates than any other printed manual for cyclists. The aim of any update is to keep what is still relevant from previous editions, but to ensure that every new edition is 'thoroughly revised to capture all new developments in the cycling world'. The result is generally clear and well-illustrated, albeit with some decisions or omissions that I found surprising.
The first edition of 'The Bike Book' was written by our very own grumpy Northerner John Stevenson, with the role of lead writer passing to Fred Milson for the next four editions. Mark Storey took over for the sixth, with James Witts joining Storey for this seventhth edition.
One of the first decisions that any new custodian has to make is what material to carry over from the previous edition. I only have a couple of previous editions to hand, so I can't do a full evaluation of what is no longer included, but let us take pedals as an example of how technology has changed since the first edition – and hence what has to be covered: in the beginning there was over a page about fitting toe-clips and toe-straps, with no mention of clipless pedals; today there are a couple of pages on fitting cleats for various clipless pedals, with clips and straps now receiving but a passing mention.
For most people that will be the right balance, but it is worth checking if the book covers any older technology that you want to know about – and perhaps keep hold of previous editions of the book in case you suddenly develop a taste for l'Eroica-compatible machines.
Ironically some of the original pictures of clips and straps are still being used to illustrate the section on removing and fitting pedals – and in fact many of the images have been carried over from previous editions. The photos are as clear and uncluttered as any you will find, and are supplemented by the occasional line drawing.
Obviously the various authors will have different views as to how much the existing material needs to be modified or removed: my view would be that if you are trying to live up to the claim of covering 'complete bicycle maintenance' then a certain amount of older equipment still needs to be included, but not at the expense of newer technology.
Over the years the page-and-a-half on puncture repair has shrunk to half a page, but somewhere along the way the instruction to roughen the tube with sandpaper before applying the glue has been lost, which is likely to result in an unsatisfactory repair.
An intermediate-level mechanic should know that anyway, and there may be instructions with the repair kit, but I found it a strange omission for the sake of saving the space of one picture. In my view if something is included it should be given proper coverage if it is to be of any use.
Here's another strange choice: right from the start Haynes advocated starting the taping of handlebars at the centre, by the stem. It will work, and may even make the job slightly easier - but you are likely to ruffle the edges of your new tape after just a few rides, which will shorten the life of your tape. Whilst it was the method suggested by the late (and influential) Richard Ballantine, current thinking is to start taping at the open end of the handlebar, which better suits the thicker tapes in use today.
While I am at it, there are a few instances of small errors appearing: nothing critical, but disappointing. For example, beside the description of a cable puller (commonly known as a 4th hand), there is a picture of a 'brake arm squeezer' (or a 3rd hand).
Another example: linear-pull brakes are described as being 'originally developed by Shimano'. Whilst they came up with the V-brake name, and certainly popularised the concept, several niche American brands offered such brakes before Shimano.
An important task for the author is to decide what new technologies to include: that is what keeps the book up-to-date, and is what the marketing team will be promoting. In this edition tubeless tyres, thru-axles, and internal cable-routing make their first appearance (among many other things), along with lots of new headset and bottom bracket 'standards'.
It is probably an impossible (and unnecessary) task to cover every variation available on some components; taking bottom brackets and chainsets as an example, 'The Bike Book' has broader coverage than most books, going from traditional 'cup and axle' bottom brackets for square-taper chainsets, through cartridge and external bottom brackets, to various press-fit designs, as well as the removal and fitting of the appropriate chainsets.
Each maintenance task is given a realistic rating for difficulty, from 'six spanners' for truing a wheel, falling to 'four' for bleeding hydraulic brakes or fitting a new gear cable (on a road bike), down to 'one' for measuring chain wear.
As is normal with such books there are brief chapters on recommended tools, accessories, and types of bike: they are full of good advice such as 'unless you're buying at the top of the range, avoid bikes with suspension components, as these are often crude and heavy.' It is aimed at purchasers of children's bikes, but would apply equally to adult bikes.
It is always hard to agree on which is the best printed workshop manual, because a lot depends on your own competence and specific equipment; of the books that we have reviewed recently I would still put Lennard Zinn at the top of the pile for advanced users, but for intermediate users 'The Bike Book' provides something slightly different to Dorling Kindersley's offering. I prefer the clarity of DK's CGI images, but appreciate the inclusion of some older technology by Haynes.
Some of Haynes' automotive manuals have been enhanced with videos and are appearing on-line at https://haynes.com/en-gb/ondemand , and no doubt there are discussions about doing the same with 'The Bike Book': at that point Haynes might be able to offer the best of both print and digital worlds.
Worthy successor to previous Haynes manuals, with good coverage of old and new technologies, albeit sometimes incomplete
If you're thinking of buying this product using a cashback deal why not use the road.cc Top Cashback page and get some top cashback while helping to support your favourite independent cycling website
road.cc test report
Make and model: Haynes Publishing The Bike Book Complete Bicycle Maintenence 7th Edition
Size tested: Hardback
Tell us what the product is for, and who it's aimed at. What do the manufacturers say about it? How does that compare to your own feelings about it?
Complete bicycle maintenance
Now in its 23rd year of publication, The Bike Book continues to be a bestseller. Compiled by a new author, this seventh edition is a major update to include all new developments in the cycling world along with a thorough check and revision of all existing material. New photography together with a refreshed page design offer the reader a user-friendly and contemporary manual – but still with the clear step-by-step approach for which Haynes is famous.
* Choosing a bike: different types of bike, correct sizing and setting up.
* Routine maintenance and repair: lubrication, adjustment, cleaning, repairing punctures, tyre care, chains, cables and brake pads.
* Braking systems: rim and disc brakes.
* Drive train: chains, cables, derailleurs, sprockets and cassettes, chainsets, bottom brackets, hub gears, gear shifters.
* Contact points: saddles, seat posts, bars and stems, pedals, toe clips, straps and clipless pedals.
* Wheels: adjustable-cone hubs, sealed-bearing hubs, spoke replacement and truing.
* Frames, forks, steering and suspension: frame materials and design, suspension fork strip and set-up, headset strip, adjustment and replacement, full-suspension bearing replacement.
* Safety, security and accessories: mudguards, racks, panniers, computers, bells, seatpost bags.
* Appendix: gear ratios, torque settings, chain types, tyre and rim combinations, Shimano, Sram and Campagnolo compatability, fault-finding.
Author: James Witts is a sports journalist who edited the UK's biggest and best-selling multisport magazine, 220 Triathlon, transforming it from a loss-making publication into one of Immediate Media's most profitable titles.
Tell us some more about the technical aspects of the product?
Title: The Bike Book – complete bicycle maintenance – 7th edition
Author: James Witts & Mark Storey
Date: April 2017
Normal SRP is slightly above the average for such a book, but currently 25% off in the Haynes Autumn Sale
Tell us what you particularly liked about the product
The continued inclusion of some older technologies
Tell us what you particularly disliked about the product
The occasional bit of questionable advice - and even the odd error
Did you enjoy using the product? Yes
Would you consider buying the product? No: I am not the target audience
Would you recommend the product to a friend? Yes: it is a recognised name for anyone new to cycle mechanics
Use this box to explain your score
It is good, and offers a different experience to comparable books - but is slightly let down by occasional incomplete (or out-of-date) advice, and even minor errors
About the tester
I usually ride: My best bike is:
I've been riding for: Over 20 years I ride: Every day I would class myself as: Expert
I regularly do the following types of riding: commuting, touring, club rides, sportives, general fitness riding,