Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Murderer who threatened to run over cyclist spared jail

Incident near Faslane naval base was caught on film by victim - an off-duty MOD Police officer

A convicted murderer who was out of prison on licence has been spared being sent back to jail after threatening to run over a cyclist who happened to be an off-duty police officer.

The incident happened on 14 August last year close to the Faslane naval base in Argyll & Bute, home to the UK’s Triident submarines, reports the Daily Record.

Andrew Rodger – jailed for life in 1987 after he used a crowbar to kill a swimming pool attendant who caught him trying to steal from a vending machine, and released in 2006 – pleaded guilty at Dumbarton Sheriff Court to shouting, swearing and threatening the victim, and to assault.

The victim in the incident, which happened on the A814 close to Faslane, was an off-duty Ministry of Defence Police Officer who recorded what happened on a camera mounted on his bike.

Fiscal depute Gemma McKechnie told the court that the victim was riding along the road when he became aware of a white van behind him, which was being driven by Rodger.

She said that Rodger overtook another vehicle with the cyclist, who was afraid for his safety, making a hand gesture at the driver.

Further along the road, the rider stopped and Rodger pulled in next to him, with Ms McKechnie telling the court that the driver shouted: “Who the f*ck do you think you are? I am allowed to overtake you. This is a road.”

Rodger continued shouting, telling the rider: “I heard a cyclist get knocked down by a car and I can see why. You are a c*nt. If there was no-one about I would f*ck*ng run you over and I would laugh.

“The only reason I don’t is I don't want the f*ck*ng jail. You are a c*nt.”

The prosecutor told the court: “The witness informed the accused he was recording the incident on his cycle-mounted camera and the accused returned to his van.

“He returned holding a black torch and thereafter lunged in an attempt to strike the witness, causing him to move backward.”

Rodger drove off but the victim and another witness reported the incident to the police, who arrested him a few hours later.

Speaking in mitigation, Rodger’s lawyer said that his client, who lives in Garelochead, had made friends in the community who had been assessed as helping prevent him from re-offending, and that he undertook bricklaying and painting and decorating for local people.

“Assessments were carried out in 2016 and 2018, which assessed him as low risk,” he said.

“Mr Rodger has shown genuine contrition. He is horrified by his behaviour and accepts he never should have behaved in such a manner.

He continued: “The reason Mr Rodger stopped was because he perceived the hand gesture to be obscene. Whether his perception is right or wrong, it’s his behaviour thereafter which is the issue.

“Regrettably, when it escalated, the discussion became more heated, Mr Rodger returned to his vehicle and removed a torch which he then pursued the complainer with.”

Sheriff Simon Pender sentenced Rodger to a community payback order with two years of supervision and 250 hours of unpaid work.

He told Rodger: “You should be in no doubt that this is an extremely serious offence, especially given your record which includes a previous conviction for murder. Your actions were wholly unacceptable.

“I take account of your conduct since you were released on licence, I have concluded, not without hesitation, that I can just deal with you by a direct alternative to custody.”

The sheriff also imposed a five-month curfew on Rodger from 7pm to 7am.

Rodger hit national headlines in 1995 when he and two other inmates broke out of the maximum security Parkhurst prison on the Isle of Wight after making a ladder and a gun, as well as a master key capable of unlocking every door in the jail.

The trio spent six nights on the run before being captured following a massive manhunt.

Simon joined road.cc as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment

14 comments

Avatar
Christopher TR1 | 5 years ago
3 likes

How can anyone think that it's ok for this person to be out in public? He was obviously a nutter when he originally went to jail and he has proven, on camera, that he is still a nutter. May the consequences of his next violent offence be on the sheriff's conscious.

Avatar
Legs_Eleven_Wor... replied to Christopher TR1 | 5 years ago
1 like

Christopher TR1 wrote:

How can anyone think that it's ok for this person to be out in public? 

He's not.  

But prisons are expensive and .. well, you know the rest.  

Avatar
EK Spinner | 5 years ago
1 like

So he is out on licence from a murder charge, he also has shown no respect to the criminal justice system by breaking out from prison. He has chased and threatened (with a weapon?) a member of the public.

1. I thought he would have been back in jail prior to any court appearance, because he was on licence.

2. How bad does you behaviour need to be before the licence or parole is withdrawn

3. He can show all the contrition he likes in the court, he should be judged by his actions not his lawyers words

Avatar
EK Spinner | 5 years ago
6 likes

So he is out on licence from a murder charge, he also has shown no respect to the criminal justice system by breaking out from prison. He has chased and threatened (with a weapon?) a member of the public.

1. I thought he would have been back in jail prior to any court appearance, because he was on licence.

2. How bad does you behaviour need to be before the licence or parole is withdrawn

3. He can show all the contrition he likes in the court, he should be judged by his actions not his lawyers words

Avatar
Mungecrundle | 5 years ago
4 likes

I do not see how this addresses his patently ongoing anger management issues and more worryingly provides no safeguard to anyone who happens to be in harms way should that rage overcome his self control at some point in the future.

Not convinced that sending him back to prison or a secure hospital is the answer, but surely referal to a specialist for proper assessment is required before making that decision. This man killed someone who tried to prevent him stealing from a vending machine. Any "benefit of the doubt" when he makes threats to kill should be well and truly put to one side.

Avatar
PRSboy | 5 years ago
4 likes

Sounds like an ideal opportunity to get a thug off the streets before he kills someone again.

Avatar
ktache | 5 years ago
7 likes

He went to prison for killing a swimming pool attendant with a crowbar, I'm guessing thet the aggression was there a bit before he went inside.

And his mates in the community don't seem to have prevented him from reoffending in this case.

Avatar
hawkinspeter replied to ktache | 5 years ago
4 likes

ktache wrote:

He went to prison for killing a swimming pool attendant with a crowbar, I'm guessing thet the aggression was there a bit before he went inside.

And his mates in the community don't seem to have prevented him from reoffending in this case.

To be fair, I got shouted at by a swimming pool attendant once for peeing in the pool. Apparently doing it from the diving board isn't allowed.

Avatar
hawkinspeter | 5 years ago
4 likes

I'm wondering how much of his aggression is from prison culture (not appearing "weak" to avoid being bullied) and how much is general road rage.

Maybe take his driving license away for a while until he learns a bit of composure.

Avatar
Kendalred replied to hawkinspeter | 5 years ago
7 likes

hawkinspeter wrote:

I'm wondering how much of his aggression is from prison culture (not appearing "weak" to avoid being bullied) and how much is general road rage.

Maybe take his driving license away for a while until he learns a bit of composure.

Well given he was inside for beating someone to death with a crowbar for trying to stop him robbing a vending machine, I'd argue he was already fairly aggressive beforehand?

Avatar
john1967 replied to hawkinspeter | 5 years ago
4 likes
hawkinspeter wrote:

I'm wondering how much of his aggression is from prison culture (not appearing "weak" to avoid being bullied) and how much is general road rage.

Maybe take his driving license away for a while until he learns a bit of composure.

Did you read the article?? He beat a man to death with a crow bar.I would say he had major aggression problems long before he went to prison.

Avatar
RDG | 5 years ago
3 likes

Wow...sounds like a nice fella. No doubt a strong community man and all round good guy. I'll watch out, as I ride from Rhu when I'm visiting the folks. I haven't seen the fottage, but I'd question whether conditions of his release where fully met. Now...off to tell my parents to very carefully vet any painters, decorators or brickies should they need one..

Avatar
EddyBerckx | 5 years ago
2 likes

Wow....

Avatar
HoarseMann | 5 years ago
3 likes

Well, what I take out of that is “prison works”. He basically said he would have killed the cyclist, but for the fear of going to prison.

Sadly, with such leniency being shown this time, he might not be that concerned about being sent down in the future.

Meanwhile the politicians are fretting over why some people are feeling the need to “tool up” before going out. If you are going to tool up with something, make it a camera!

Latest Comments