A coroner presiding over an inquest into the death of a London motorcyclist who crashed into a bollard after skidding in the rain has ordered Transport for London (TfL) to undertake an “urgent” review of the blue paint used on the surface of the capital’s older Cycle Superhighways.
Milan Dokic, aged 49, was killed in the crash on 1 March last year at the junction of Battersea Park Road and Forfar Road when he lost control of his bike, a pre-inquest hearing was told last month, reports the London Evening Standard.
In a prevention of future deaths report sent to TfL, Dr Fiona Wilcox said that “there is a risk that future deaths will occur” and demanded “an urgent review of all areas treated with such road surface and replace it with the higher grip surface.”
The full inquest into Mr Dokic’s death is due to take place this summer at Westminster Coroner’s Court, and Dr Wilcox said: "These concerns are too urgent to wait until the full hearing of the evidence to be addressed.”
The motorcyclist had moved onto Cycle Superhighway 8, which was one of the first such routes when it opened in 2011, as he prepared to undertake a van.
“The CCTV clearly shows the motorcycle losing grip and sliding along the road,” the coroner wrote in her report to TfL.
“Sadly, Mr Dokic came off and hit a bollard, sustaining injuries that led to his death at the scene.”
Dr Wilcox revealed that a separate inquest will concern another death that took place in Battersea “in slightly different circumstances … where low grip on the [cycle superhighway] may have played a part.”
At the pre-inquest hearing, which took place on 14 February, a collision investigator said that the surface of Cycle Superhighway 8, painted blue to reflect the former sponsorship of the routes by Barclays, had a skid resistance of 56.3, while the conventional road surface had one of 77.
Dr Wilcox said some cyclists had talked about a lack of grip on parts of the superhighway, which runs between Westminster and Wandsworth.
“Our thoughts are with the family and friends of Milan Dokic,” said Leon Daniels, TfL’s managing director of surface transport. “We’re preparing our response to the coroner and carefully considering the issues raised.
"We are confident our cycle superhighway network is improving the safety of London’s roads,” he added.
A study published last month in the academic journal Accident Analysis & Prevention with the title Safety effects of the London Cycle Superhighways on cycle collisions claimed that the infrastructure, where not featuring physical segregation, had not caused a change in cycle collision rates.
Researchers from Imperial College said: “The increase in traffic was associated with a rise in annual total cycle collisions of around 2.6 per km (38% in percentage).
“However, when we re-estimate the effects based on cycle collision rates rather than levels, our results also show that the CS routes are not more dangerous or safer than the control roads.
They added “Among the four CS routes, CS3 performs the best in protecting cyclists with a large proportion of segregated lanes whilst the cyclists have to share the lanes with motorists on other routes. It is recommended that consistent safety designs should be applied on all CS routes for a safer cycling environment.”
At the inquest in 2013 into the death of cyclist Brian Dorling at Bow Roundabout in October 2011, police collision investigator PC Alex Hewitt was asked by Coroner Mary Hassell about the status of the Cycle Superhighway where the rider was crushed to death by a lorry as he rode to work at the Olympic Park and replied, “Legally nothing. It’s just a piece of blue paint.”
> Cycle Superhighway 2 “just a piece of blue paint” crash investigator tells inquest into death of Brian Dorling
Ms Hassell said: “It just seems to me that it’s an accident waiting to happen if cyclists are guided into the space where blue paint is on the left and they’re in the very place where the lorry is going to hit them. It seems like they’re being guided into the place where they’re most vulnerable.”
Add new comment
21 comments
The cynic in me does wonder if - had a cyclist been the one killed such immediate action would have been ordered by the coroner.
Maple street cycle lane in central london is green with moss/lichen as never sees real sunlight to dry and is lethal on damp days, especially with the camber
So one MC dies as a result of a somewhat ill-advised manoeuvre into a cycle lane and the coroner requests TfL to review blue paint, but many cyclists dying as a result of being left-hooked by tipper trucks has resulted in what exactly?
Perhaps TFL should put signs up saying "Cycle lanes unsuitable for motorcycles" or somesuch to discourage such manoeuvres. For sure that would work...about as well as the guidance in the highway code about motor vehicles not using cycle lanes.
I know this exact peice of cycle superhighway, and it is LETHAL.
I used to ride a scooter along there, and a couple of times I had to perform the same manouver, and nearly lost all traction. Had a couple of dodgy moments at that exact same spot, so as tragic as this is, I'm honesty not surprised this happened there.
I think the blue surfaces vary hugely though. Some are notably lacking in any sort of abrasive/grippy layer and are therefore like sheet ice in the wet. And some others are very grippy indeed, more so than the normal tarmac itself
Drain covers are the other thing to watch out for in the wet.
Saw a motorcyclist ride down a marked cycle lane near me a couple of weeks ago - it's an un-broken line, so definitely illegal.
He didn't save any time over me on my motorbike legally filtering down the outside of the traffic - we both ended up stopped at the traffic lights.
I've had a few near missed in that lane on my bike with motorists using it to undertake vehicles that are waiting to turn right.
He hit a bollard and died? Perhaps they need a law making it mandatory to wear a helmet when riding a motorbike.
The road outside my flat was relid a few years back and I wa watching them do it stage by stage. When it came to the final stage, the hot tarmac was spread on the road and the cycle lane was done with small chippings that had some colouring agent added to them before they were laid and the main lane of the road was done in the same way in a different colour. I would assume this is how the CSH's were done but from the reports and videos I've seen this isn't the case. Maybe the contractor could have some liability unless they were following specific instructions set out by the local council.
He shouldn't have been in the cycle lane.
DARE YOU ENTER THE CYCLE LANE OF DEATH!
A bit of a harsh comment. Hardly worth dying over temporarily moving into the cycle lane.
The blue paint is dangerous, no doubt. Especially in the wet. Surely its not beyond the wit of TfL to take a trip to Holland and see what they use? My other gripe is that its adjacent to a traffic jam for most of the day. Surely it would have been better to designate certain E- W / N - S roads to cyclists (and service access traffic alone) rather than mix the two?
It does vary depending on which section or route you are on in my opinion. But I don;t seem to recall the pain there if he was heafing east (although I do it often). Probably because there is always traffic there.
Oh - are motorbikes allowed to undertake? I thought that was (sadly) scooters?
Yes. Highway Code rule 151
In slow-moving traffic. You should... be aware of cyclists and motorcyclists who may be passing on either side
And rule 163
If the queue on your right is moving more slowly than you are, you may pass on the left
(I have always wondered whether 'queue' has a legal definition. Is 1 vehicle a queue?)
not sure whether the cycle highway there has a broken or unbroken line. If unbroken then yes, it was an illegal move. I've seen police bikes illegally use it on upper Thames st before pre upgrade. Also rear ended a moped there who jumped into the lane illegally without looking.
its a very sad event regardless, TfL should be made to pay for this sort of crap
Undertaking is simply idiotic in any circumstance regardless of your mode of transport.
Really?
So if someone is stationary, indicating to turn right but waiting for a gap in oncoming traffic, and there's loads of space to their left, you don't undertake?
FTFY HTH Kthxbai
Fixed that for you
Definitely one of those "depends on the circumstances" situations.
They put a cycle lane in along the side of a main road back home years ago using the glossy paint, then 6 months later they took it up and did it in some paint which actually had some grip.
Who actually signs off on using something which is so obviously not fit for purpose?
I've always said that blue stuff was lethal - I always avoid it in the wet. I'm sad that I've been proved right.
just a bit sad that it takes an undertaking motorcyclist using it illegally plus a coroner's report to actually make it into an issue