These entry-level Shimano RC1W SPD-SL Women's Shoes, built with a female-specific last, offer a reasonably stiff ride considering the outsole isn't carbon, but bear in mind the fit favours a flatter foot rather than a higher instep, and the sizing is on the small side.
The RC1Ws are constructed from synthetic leather, perforated to allow for ventilation, and the tongue is fixed down one side, to avoid unnecessary overlap and uncomfortable compression at the top of the foot.
> Find your nearest dealer here
The fixed tongue does make for a secure fit, keeping slippage to a minimum even when you're pulling up hard, but the shape of your foot could be crucial. My fairly average foot has a pretty standard arch, and yet these were slightly too low volume for me, and fastened without much in the way of overlap of the tongue.
The shoes also come up small. My usual size in cycling shoes is 39 (38.5 in 'normal' shoes) but I'd be inclined to go up a full size in these (half sizes are not available anyway). The width is standard to narrow. The overlapping tongue does make for good comfort at the top of the foot, though, thanks to a reduction in possible chafing points, with less chance of it shifting.
The synthetic leather upper keeps out a fair amount of road grime and extraneous water, but the perforations and the vented forefoot of the sole mean that in really wet weather these are not the best choice. On milder, drier days, they offer good levels of comfort in terms of warmth and protection.
The outsole is reinforced with glass fibre for added stiffness, and allows for fairly decent power transfer, particularly for a shoe at this entry-level price. The three Velcro straps do give some flex at the top, though, resulting in some movement of the foot when riding vigorously.
Being road-specific, they take a three-bolt cleat, with fitting guidelines there to help with placement.
A heel pad helps with walking comfort and stability, but I still found them quite slippery to walk in, with virtually no traction. Still, that's not hugely unusual for a shoe of this type.
Available in both the black as tested and also a navy and turquoise option, these are conservatively styled shoes, but not unattractive.
The RC1Ws have gone up by a tenner recently (although they seem to be almost exclusively available for £69.99 or less), but even at £79.99 they're pretty good value compared with what else is out there.
You can get cheaper entry-level road shoes from the likes of Decathlon with its Van Rysel RCR500s at £49.99, which take two-bolt cleats as well as three-bolt, and the FLR-F35.IIIs at £64.99, but others are another £10-£15 or more.
> Buyer’s Guide: 12 of the best cheap cycling shoes
dhb's lace-up Dorica road shoes are now £85 (but currently on sale at £68), while the Giant Phase 2 Road Shoes are £89.99, though they do include a ratchet strap, and the road-specific Specialized Torch 1.0s are now £95, but they come with a Boa dial.
Overall, I'd say the Shimano RC1Ws offer a fair whack of performance for the budget-conscious or novice road rider, provided that the fit suits. If so, it's a comfortable road-specific shoe that delivers a decent performance.
Budget-friendly shoes offering comfort and decent non-aggressive ride performance, but check the size and fit
If you're thinking of buying this product using a cashback deal why not use the road.cc Top Cashback page and get some top cashback while helping to support your favourite independent cycling website
Make and model: Shimano RC1W SPD-SL Women's Shoes
Tell us what the product is for
It's described by the manufacturer as a women's road cycling shoe with race-inspired style and features.
Tell us some more about the technical aspects of the product?
Freewheel (Shimano's UK distributor) lists:
Surround wrapping upper structure reduces overlap and provides a glove-like fit.
Synthetic leather with mesh texture creates a comfortable fit and an exciting racing profile.
Three durable hook & loop straps evenly spread tightening force across the top of the foot.
Lightweight glass fiber reinforced nylon sole for power transfer.
Durable, wide heel pads provide walking stability.
Women's specific last for a natural, comfortable fit.
Offset strap relieves tension at highest point of the foot.
Available in sizes EU36-44 (full sizes only)
Rate the product for quality of construction:
Very sturdily built and nicely finished.
Rate the product for performance:
As an entry-level road shoe it performs very well. A bit too much flex in the Velcro straps and the fibreglass reinforced outsole for really aggressive riding.
Rate the product for durability:
Should last pretty well, as the upper won't soak up water and dirt, but the Velcro straps do stretch with prolonged use, particularly if you're cinching them in tight.
Rate the product for fit:
The fit is best suited to those with low arches or a low volume foot, and on the narrow side of average.
Rate the product for sizing:
Significantly smaller than expected from the stated size. I'd go up a size. Half sizes not available.
Rate the product for weight:
Pretty light considering they are quite sturdy and not carbon soled.
Rate the product for comfort:
As long as the fit suits, these are comfortable shoes.
Rate the product for value:
Pretty good value for money for a road-specific shoe with decent performance.
How easy is the product to care for? How did it respond to being washed?
Very easy to look after. Outer wipes clean nicely. Removable insoles can be handwashed or replaced.
Tell us how the product performed overall when used for its designed purpose
Performed very well for the price/entry level.
Tell us what you particularly liked about the product
Price, ease of adjustment, durability.
Tell us what you particularly disliked about the product
Fit is best suited to low volume, narrower feet; sizing is smaller than expected.
How does the price compare to that of similar products in the market, including ones recently tested on road.cc?
At £79.99 it's pretty good for an entry-level shoe. Van Rysel's RCR500s are cheaper at £49.99, and the FLR-F35.III Road Shoe are £64.99, but others are more expensive, such as dhb's lace-up Dorica road shoes, now £85, the Giant Phase 2 Road Shoes at £89.99, and the road-specific Specialized Torch 1.0 at £95, although both the Giant and Specialized have superior closure systems.
Did you enjoy using the product? Yes
Would you consider buying the product? Probably not, the fit wasn't ideal for me.
Would you recommend the product to a friend? Yes, if the fit suits them.
Use this box to explain your overall score
I'd say these are above average, delivering a decent performance at a decent price. They're not brilliant in really wet weather, and the sole is too flexible for more aggressive riders, but if the low-volume fit suits, they're worth considering.
Age: 48 Height: 1.65m Weight: 77kg
I usually ride: Liv Invite My best bike is: Specialized Ruby Elite
I've been riding for: Over 20 years I ride: Most days I would class myself as: Experienced
I regularly do the following types of riding: commuting, touring, sportives, general fitness riding, mtb,
What extraordinary statements! If BC were doing such sterling work, they'd be shouting it to the heavens, not hiding it under a bushel. As for...
I'm not sure what i've missed here. Can you give me a link or more details?
Well that's a ridiculous basis for a research paper isn't it?...
I think membership of the ABD is one.
Huge difference between being impolite and punching someone repeatedly in the face and tasing them....
I'm not blaming the cyclist. Far from it. The reason the crime is being committed is due to the value of the bike in a pub car park. It's worth...
An utterly stupid dodge since vehicle registration is not PII...
I strongly agree with the saddle comment - for me the shorts and saddle work as a system. If I wear my ideal shorts on a different saddle it is...