On Tuesday morning, Good Morning Britain set up its outside broadcast on Belgrave Middleway in Birmingham to tell the nation that police forces aren’t fining cyclists. If it felt familiar, that’s because it was largely a rerun of a recent Times piece and many national media pieces before it that regularly misplace the real cause of danger on our roads.
I know Belgrave Middleway well. As West Midlands Cycling & Walking Commissioner, I stood next to it with police, watching countless red light running drivers finally get enforced against, for a few days a year when there were the resources to do so. Any road user in Birmingham will attest that dangerous driving is rife and the police face an uphill battle to tackle it.
In May 2023, husband-to-be Hussien Nur Teklise, 45, was killed while cycling on Belgrave Middleway by a hit-and-run driver. He was one of a string of people killed or seriously injured walking and cycling on Birmingham’s roads in a matter of weeks that summer.
I wrote to the Chief Constable, the Police and Crime Commissioner and the council at the time, and said publicly that this was an emergency. It kick-started better collaboration and a clampdown on the causes of harm on West Midlands roads. None of the focus, rightly, was on cyclists. Statistically, pedestrians and cyclists are most likely to be killed by motorists.
On today’s edition of Good Morning Britain, however, Gillian Keegan, the former Secretary of State for Education, suggested cameras would be a good replacement for police enforcement, and that cyclists in the Netherlands have number plates. They don’t. As Chris Boardman later pointed out on the segment, the only place to insist on registration plates for cyclists is North Korea. Not a model most of us aspire to.
Ironically for Gillian Keegan’s suggestion, Belgrave Middleway already has a red light camera. It just doesn’t work. There was no revenue funding to keep it up to date and calibrated. There was no back-office support to process all the fines that would come from it. So it was switched off.
How we got here
The lack of revenue funding for red light and speed cameras is not an accident. It is the product of years of a successful lobbying campaign and a narrative about a war on motorists.
Until 2007, camera partnerships could recycle fine income into running and maintaining cameras. Accused of treating drivers as a cash cow by a powerful media narrative, the government of the time ended that and sent the money directly to the Treasury instead, bypassing local authorities.
The grants that replaced it were then cut from 2010 by a government promising to end the war on the motorist. In layman’s terms, none of the money raised from fines stays in the local area. That starved local authorities and police of the funding to make their roads safer, and many cameras, including the one on Belgrave Middleway, were turned off.
Most collisions with vulnerable road users happen at junctions. Yesterday I talked to local residents near Belgrave Middleway; many recounted near misses they’d experienced.
Here’s an example of instant karma from one of @WMPolice’s #OpTriton safer junction operations yesterday. https://t.co/ToqRg6yKVv
— Adam Tranter (@adamtranter) November 17, 2023
Ironically, it was the same simplified media debate that led to this massive own goal for road safety. It’s the kind of approach that gives all the airtime to an activity that isn’t inherently dangerous and rarely hurts people, with no real scrutiny of the real causes of harm.
> Police stop more than 70 motorists in crackdown following cyclist hit-and-run deaths
A driver ran a red light every three minutes and 24 seconds on Belgrave Middleway, according to research in 2023 by campaign group Better Streets for Birmingham.
The same dangerous behaviour from drivers of motor vehicles is still happening in 2026. A recent AI camera trial at just two sites in the West Midlands flagged almost 19,000 potential seatbelt and mobile phone offences in a fortnight, including 1,920 drivers apparently on their phones. Two cameras found nearly a year’s worth in two weeks. Again, there aren’t even the resources to send warning letters to the drivers caught by these cameras; let alone spending limited police time being seen to crack down on people cycling.
The ideal world
I’d like to live in an ideal world, at least on our roads. One where the cameras work, we invest in technology, there are no ghost plates, and roads are safe for everyone. But we don’t. And we won’t ever.
The current status quo is that most vulnerable road users who die on our roads are killed by motorists, and even then we don’t have the resources and effort to enforce against them, even though we have the technology. In 2025 alone, 364 pedestrians were killed and 5,960 seriously injured, almost all of them hit by drivers of motor vehicles. Working closely with West Midlands Police, I quickly realised that with limited resources they have to focus on the biggest causes of harm.

Good Morning Britain featured the horrific case of Kim Briggs, who was killed by a brakeless rider, Charlie Alliston. The case was horrible, and Alliston’s actions and attitude were despicable. But a cyclist killing a pedestrian is so rare that many people, myself included, can still recall Charlie Alliston’s name immediately, a decade on. How many drivers who killed pedestrians could you name? Even the most empathetic judge or road safety campaigner would lose count.
That’s the problem. When bad cycling gets all the column inches, it fools people into thinking cycling is one of the biggest dangers to us all. It isn’t. If broadcasters want to stand on Belgrave Middleway and talk about red light running, they could start by asking why the camera above them is switched off.
And by the way, Hussien Nur Teklise’s hit-and-run killer (who was driving a car with a number plate) has still not been brought to justice over three years later, as is the overwhelmed nature of the justice system. Perhaps someone should talk about that too.

16 thoughts on “This broken red light camera in Birmingham tells you everything about Britain’s road safety debate”
Not a pedestrian killing, but Helen Measures killed experienced cyclist Denisa Perinova. Got away with it too.
On a point of order, the idiot Alliston wasn’t “a brakeless rider”, he was just relying on a single brake, and although the police muddied the waters with some ludicrous tests which “proved” he could have stopped with an extra brake the outcome would probably have been no different if he had possessed one. He hit a pedestrian who had stepped into the road in front of him as he rode through a green light in his favour at a speed below that of the motor vehicle limit for the road. It’s interesting how the one case always cited by the anti-cyclist brigade, and the foundational motivator for Matthew Briggs’ ill-advised and frankly vindictive campaign against cyclists, is actually arguably a miscarriage of justice based on false evidence and incorrect application of the law.
@Rendel Harris Agree. Alliston was a complete a*****e, and bears some culpability for not having two brake mechanisms and having some recklessness. But the standards of evidence used was ridiculous.
Had the situation been reversed, and Alliston was driving a car with partially defective brakes at below speed limit, and Mrs Briggs stepped in front of him without looking, there is no way he would have been prosecuted.
@the little onion indeed – but while this should not have bearing on guilt or innocence his utter lack of sympathy (and indeed victim-blaming) meant that he came over worse than … er … some motorists, who were found not guilty of causing death by careless/ dangerous … er, as you were!
(Can’t recall if Martin Porter coveted this or whether it was after this trial, but I’m thinking of the chap who killed some cyclists when he slid on black ice. His bald tyres were not held to be contributory IIRC. Not sure if his decision to drive in freezing conditions was interrogated, but that’s presumably “normal”.
OTOH a lorry driver who’d put stuff in his lorry cab which blocked his view *was* convicted…).
I’ve still not forgotten how the BBC ran a “and finally” story, presenting a woman and child nearly being killed by a driver rolling their car along a pavement in… er… the West Midlands… essentially as a “bit of a giggle”.
The basic “collective psyche” issue Richard Madley is concerned about is too many are ignorant of motoring harms (in the most literal way).
https://www.coventrytelegraph.net/news/tv/bbc-blasted-deeply-troubling-report-28329290
I’d still suggest rising bollards (or spikes) when the green light turns to amber would be the solution for curbing the riskier drivers at many of the most dangerous junctions, such as this one in Birmingham.
Wait, a camera to catch drivers at a known hot spot was turned off due to lack of funds?
Which would have been self generating from the numbers of red light jumping drivers they already knew about?
Who was in charge of this system/decision?
Dung Old Taco Trump?
@mitsky It’s probably something like the revenue from fines goes to central government, where as maintaining the camera is paid for by the local council.
@OnYerBike A driver ran a red light every three minutes and 24 seconds on Belgrave Middleway, according to research in 2023 by campaign group Better Streets for Birmingham
Even I don’t claim the offence is as frequent at the only permanent lights around here: the A6 at Garstang. But there are always some because of the exceedingly lax attitude to RLJs of Lancashire Constabulary, and the comedy unlamented Lancashire Police and Crime Commissioner who is essentially on paid holiday until next May. The police did nothing about any of these- they claimed to have taken action on the four at the bottom which occurred within an hour in 2020, but I now realise that was just part of standard police fobbing-off procedure and they did either nothing or issued the joke advice letter. They subsequently just binned all reports and refused to respond. This list is just for my reference within an appropriate topic- there are no new ones as I haven’t been down there for months- I’m waiting for the barmy Christmas traffic, which brings the offenders out of the woodwork.
ttps://upride.cc/incident/j33bmd_transittrailer_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/sc21zsx_niro_redlightpass/ 1 amber, 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/kn13aus_knausmotorhome_doubleredlightpass/ 2 amber, 2 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pn72ooe_dacia_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pg73hya_suzuki1300_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pe18ojj_insignia_redlightpass/ 1 amber, 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pl24vsx_sportage_redlightcross/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/ov74urx_polestar_redlightpass/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/lonsdalebus_route88_redlightpass/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/a15tjv_bmwm4_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/jo55chb_kiasportage_redlightpass/ 2 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/kl04ndo_vw_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/da21sww_leon_redlightpass/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pl68tev_polo_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/de56ztv_discovery_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/ma08opb_crv_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/fh16vfa_rrover_redlightcross/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/k7ddy_audia4_redlightpass/ 1 red 1 amber
ttps://upride.cc/incident/g16dht_hgvtrainer_redlightcross/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pj23vmc_honda125_redlightcross/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/ye10aju_mini_redlightcross/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/ds6972_porsche_redlightpass/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/fd67nej_bmw420_redlightcross/ 2 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/t90jdt_audiwithcaravan_rljatspeed/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pn68kpg_hiluxtrailer_redlightcross/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/vo12hxu_berlingo_redlightpass/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/dl66xgz_lcctraffic_redlightpass/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/mf09hyk_chevroletaveo_redlightcross/ 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/pe62gyb_agila_redlightcross/ 2 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/f2yny_rangerover_redlightcross/ 2 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/yd18knj_vwgolf_redlightcross/ 1 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/px68nhc_toyotatrailer_redlightcross/ 2 amber 1 red
ttps://upride.cc/incident/lc11vep_kiavenga_redlightcross/ 1 amber 1 red
The photo shows that BMW M4 AJ15 TJV (registration doesn’t exist any more) was well back when the lights changed to red
@mitsky As it states in the article:
If i remember correctly that case of the ‘fixie” rider hitting and killing a woman crossing the road the judge summed it up by saying he was going too fast (19 in a 30) and had swarn at her (yelling get the fuck out of the way to get her attention when she stepped into the road without looking) and suggested that a fixed rear gear does not function like a break (not peddling stops the rear wheel exactly because it is a fixed gear, the laws of physics and the law of the land are not the same I know). The riders attitude was not great but from his testimony she was looking at her phone and stepped into the road, and from the prosecution and judges own logic, given the 50cm a bike takes up, if he actually had the stopping time with proper breaks then she must have remained in his path long enough to for him to stop else he would never have hit her so it sounds like she stepped off the curb and stopped because either she was looking at her phone as the rider suggested or perhaps there was motor traffic that she chose to avoid and therefore cycle traffic she chose to ignore. For the rider it’s like the trolly eithics problem, if you’re on bike and someone steps in front with no time to stop should you a) swerve into motor traffic for your own near certain death or b) risk hitting but usually not killing the absant minded pedestrian, what would you do? Shouldn’t minimising harm, even your own, be accepted behavoir? I don’t actually like victim blaming but I don’t like the presumtion that a rider or yes even a driver have to be prosecuted for the outcome of an incident, rather than their culpability. It sounds like the same thing that happend in regents park or wherever, where the poor old lady forgot to look and just stepped out, she survived long enough to have the grace to tell the police it was her fault as she didn’t look and the police had the audacity to say they didn’t charge him due to lack of evidence, when in fact they did have evidence… that he did nothing wrong! Again why did the drunk driver, who split open a riders skull between their RR bonnet and a barrier and when being pulled out of the car announced they ‘hate cyclists’, get, iirc, a suspended sentance rather than life for attempted murder but a guy who was not speeding who slammed on his breaks and yelled out to warn the pedestrian who just stepped on the road without looking properly get two years under a 200 year old law from the isle of man? I think this wierd half law, half emotion approach is part of the problem, there’s not a consitant message of what the right thing actually is, and you hear this from drivers when they say things like “there are no rules on the road, everyone knows that”. Would it really be that hard to make all licence holders do a yearly hazard awareness course to keep their licence and likewise sending bad cyclist on manditory cycling courses? To start handing out longer and permanent driving bans? To confiscate the emotorbikes kids are riding at speed along cycle and non cyclepaths and procecute the kids and the parents who bought the damn thing? To actually accept that a pedestrian can be culpable for risking their own and others lives by crossing without looking? Shouldn’t there be clear rules and clear consequnces: if you cause the accident it’s your fault and you can be held accountable even if you are the one who gets hurt but if you try but fail to avoid an accident you didn’t cause when otherwise using the road legally then its not your fault. I do think the fixie rider should have been fully protected for riding without a proper rear break fitted, but the cause of the accident was the pedestrian stepping into the road, his back break or lack thereof had no bearing on the pedestrians ability to perceive the bike and rider, no lights a night would be different. Surely “how will the daily mail spin this” should not be how we decide on whos at fault?
Paragraphs are your friend.
@mdavidford as are spell checkers and dictionaries!
@mdavidford Considering the way they’ve absolutely declared war on them, seems more like their sworn enemy.
Ever since the 1885 inventions of the Benz Patent-Motorwagen and the Starley Safety Bicycle the two modes of transport have been at odds with each other. As long as the world’s governments and corporations believe that cars are integral to their success bicycles will unfortunately continue to be deemed a pastime pleasure. Law enforcement continues to have the view that cars have the right to the road while bicycles have a privilege. Unless these mindsets are changed articles like this will be regularly published.
I’ll have you know that there’s no place in the present media landscape for well written, informed articles such as this…