Driver who pleaded guilty to killing time-trialling cyclists walks free from court

CPS outlines reasons why motorist charged with causing death by careless, not dangerous, driving

by Simon_MacMichael   December 23, 2010  

Gavel

A driver who admitted killing a cyclist who had been taking part in a time trial on the A435 near Stratford-Upon-Avon has escaped a prison sentence after being convicted of causing death by careless driving.

Arron Bjorn Cook, from Lower Quinton, Warwickshire, was instead sentenced to a community sentence and banned from driving for a year by magistrates at Warwickshire Justice Centre when he appeared before them last month, reports CTC on its Stop SMIDSY website.

The cyclist, 52-year-old Cath Ward of Solihull Cycling Club, died when she was stuck by Cook’s car as she took part in a time trial on the A435 Oversley By-pass at Alcester on 4th August this year.

Another member of the club who reached the scene of the fatal accident shortly after it happened told CTC that Cook had admitted that he had not been looking at the road when the collision took place.

The case contrasts with one in Gloucestershire reported here on road.cc last week in which a driver was jailed for eight months following a hit-and-run incident in which a cyclist was left injured at the roadside.

In that case, 28-year-old Colin Buckingham pleaded guilty to charges of aggravated vehicle taking, failing to report an accident, driving while banned and having no insurance, but no charges were laid relating to the injuries suffered by the cyclist.

While the two cases are entirely separate, and the charges brought against the drivers very different, the variation in the sentences handed down suggests that at times, property rights and adhering to laws regarding licensing and insurance are treated more seriously by the authorities than the killing of a cyclist, at odds with the concept that justice should not only be done, but also be seen to be done.

Commenting on why Cook was charged with causing death by careless driving rather than the more serious offence of causing death by dangerous driving, a spokesperson for The West Midlands Crown Prosecution Service said: “Following a detailed investigation by the police, a file of evidence was submitted to the Crown Prosecution Service.

“A Crown Advocate reviewed all of the evidence and decided that although the driver was not driving far below the standard expected of a competent and careful driver, he should have been more careful while he was travelling along the dual carriageway which led to the accident.

“Due to this, we felt it was more appropriate to charge Mr Cook with an offence of careless driving rather than dangerous driving.”

CTC, the national cyclists’ organisation, commented: “Whilst obviously we don’t have all the evidence available to prosecutors in this case, it is hard to understand how driving into the back of a cyclist on a clear summer evening is anything other than ‘dangerous’, and therefore why the motorist was allowed to get off so lightly for a mere ‘careless’ driving offence.

“Surveys show that more people want to take up cycling and the Government is keen to encourage this, yet the fear of bad driving is a major factor preventing this from happening. We do not tolerate ‘carelessness’ on our railways, planes, workplaces or construction sites, so the Government really needs to tighten up on the legal system’s response to so-called ‘carelessness’ on our roads.”
 

5 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

I think this is a total joke! Someone has been killed by a direct action of someone else and they walk free??

Its about time cyclist had some proper protection from the law regarding idiot drivers!

xcstu's picture

posted by xcstu [100 posts]
23rd December 2010 - 13:48

1 Like

Speechless with shock. Can people not directly connected with a case complain to the DPP over sentences?

Really, though?

posted by workhard [388 posts]
23rd December 2010 - 15:08

6 Likes

This is a sad story to end the year.

At the end of the day due to direct negligence and dangerous behaviour one person lost their life. The law should be clear and justice should and must be seen to be done. The driver/killer should be brought to book for this, and a community sentence is surely insufficient.

Bring me sunshine, and dry roads

MalcolmBinns's picture

posted by MalcolmBinns [107 posts]
27th December 2010 - 21:18

3 Likes

THE Magistrate is having a laugh ? Had this been a member of the magistrate's family there would have been a custodial sentence !
Property damage counts for more than a life ? Did the magistrate forget that there was a bike destroyed and decide that as it was the cyclist's that it did not count ?
Time Theresa MAY told her Law Enforcement officers whether the Police or Judiciary to get on the "same page" and treat Death of Vunerable Road Users as custodial not community service offences >
More Weekend prison for Deaths will send the message that ALL have the right to live when they use the road .

Bikes being stolen is the subject of my recent blogs .

Skippy(advocate for "Disabled / Para Sport")@skippydetour. blogging as skippi-cyclist.blogspot & Parrabuddy.blogspot currently on the road with ProTour Grand Tour Events .

skippy's picture

posted by skippy [385 posts]
29th March 2011 - 21:13

4 Likes

Cath was a member of Warwickshire Police. We carried out a detailed collision investigation, as we always do. Ultimately the courts / judges pass the judgement not the police.
It is more common than people think for those causing the death of another on our roads to get just a fine and short driving ban.

colhum1's picture

posted by colhum1 [98 posts]
29th March 2011 - 23:56

4 Likes