A driver who avoided jail “by the narrowest of margins” after fracturing a cyclist’s skull and causing bleeding on the brain in a shocking road rage attack has claimed that the rider “was blocking my way, so I had to move him”.
Joseph Hedley, 39, was driving through Cowgate, Edinburgh on the evening of Friday 20th September 2024 when an altercation occurred with 34-year-old cyclist Ian Brown. Footage shared on social media shows Brown arguing with a woman from the car in the middle of the road, with Hedley’s car appearing to have exited from the T-junction behind.
Hedley then gets out of the car from the driver’s seat and grabs Brown round the neck before throwing him to the ground. The pair then return to their car, which has an learner driver sticker in the front windscreen, before driving off, leaving Brown lying in the ground.
Does anyone know this man? https://t.co/x1GH2pXj28
— TaraBull (@TaraBull) September 20, 2024
Brown lost consciousness in the aftermath of the incident and was taken to hospital where he was diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury, a fractured skull and an acute bleed on the brain. The BBC also reports that the medics who treated him deemed his injuries to be “very much to the potential of danger to Mr Brown’s life”.
> Police make arrest after sickening footage of cyclist slammed to ground by driver goes viral
After learning that the police had put out an appeal for information, Hedley turned himself into police two days later and was charged with assault. Earlier this month he pleaded guilty to assaulting the victim to his severe injury, permanent impairment and to the danger of his life when he appeared at Edinburgh Sheriff Court earlier this month.
But at a sentencing hearing yesterday, Hedley avoided a jail sentence “by the narrowest of margins” according to the Sheriff Fergus Thomson. He was instead given an electronic tag, and a home curfew requiring him to remain at his address between 7pm and 7am for the next 12 months. Hedley was also handed a two-year supervision order which assigns him a social worker.
Defending, Calum Turner told the court Hedley had “not intended” to seriously injure Brown and had not driven since the incident. He claimed the Brown had shouted at Hedley’s vehicle, shone his bike light into the car and that a passenger in the car had suffered a “seizure”, in the build up to Hedley leaving the vehicle to confront and assault Brown.
Faith Currie, Procurator Fiscal (public prosecutor) for Edinburgh, Lothian and Borders said: “This was a violent, sustained and unprovoked assault on an innocent member of the public who suffered serious injuries. The actions of Joseph Hedley were horrific and shocking and could easily have had more devastating consequences.
“But he has now been brought fully to account for his crimes. As prosecutors, we wholly condemn road rage incidents of this nature which put the public at unnecessary risk from violent offenders like Joseph Hedley. We will always prosecute such matters where there is a sufficiency of evidence to do so.”
As he left the court following the verdict, Hedley stopped briefly to answer reporters’ questions. He told STV News he wanted to tell Brown “I’m sorry for what I did. He was blocking my way, so I had to move him.”
Driver who left cyclist with brain injury says it ‘doesn’t matter’ https://t.co/WOTDf7V6IW https://t.co/cegS8ioEdg
— STV News (@STVNews) October 27, 2026
Disputing the reporter’s characterisation that Hedley “left him for dead”, he insisted Brown “was kicking off”, and that Brown’s broken skull “doesn’t matter”. He added he felt lucky to have avoided a prison sentence.

38 thoughts on ““He was blocking my way, so I had to move him”: Road rage driver who avoided jail after breaking cyclist’s skull claims rider was “kicking off” and his brain injury “doesn’t matter””
I hope a civil suit for damages will follow this conviction and that Hedley’s insurance premiums will sky rocket. It will be no recompense or consolation to the victim but may balance up the ludicrously light sentence given by the court.
@Didsbury would his car insurance be paying out on any compensation claim. He is out the car, as per any other individual on foot when he commits the assault, not sure that the fact his car is there would be relavent.
@EK Spinner You’re correct, as he is outside the car the insurers have no liability for the assault. Hopefully the victim will be compensated via the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority, although sadly that won’t involve any penalty for the thug.
I have a couple of observations. (and many more opinions !!)
1. After the assault the victim was still in front of the car yet idiot was able to drive away, so you didn’t “have to move him”.
2. With there being no custodial sentence imposed I am going to assume that he (and his lawyer) expressed all sorts of regrets, remorse and apologies in court prior to sentencing. With the level of remorse being demonstrated to reporters outside the court is the jusge permitted to review his sentencing.
Incredible. The first video showing the attack shows that Ian Brown was perfectly peaceable, threatening no-one, and Hedley grabs him by the neck and throws him to the ground, hitting his head and knocking him unconscious. Hedley leaves him motionless and clearly seriously injured, and drives off.
But doesn’t go to gaol.
Hedley avoided a jail sentence “by the narrowest of margins” according to the Sheriff Fergus Thomson. By the narrowest of margins i.e. if it had been anyone but a cyclist.
@eburtthebike So basically to get jail time he had to kill the cyclist.
@Surreyrider Probably still walk free from court the same day. Plenty of drivers do. It’s fucking ridiculous.
*Vigilantism is not the answer, vigilantism is not the answer, vigilantism is not the answer*
If I keep telling myself, then I might believe it, because I sure as hell don’t believe:
“he has now been brought fully to account for his crimes”
Not when in his ‘apology’ to Mr Brown after the sentencing, he continues to blame the victim for his own unprovoked violent actions
I wonder what would happen if some random pleb decided to suplex Sheriff Fergus Thomson randomly for no reason on his way home from work. I have a sneaking suspicion it wouldn’t involve them “avoiding jail by the narrowest of margins”, no matter how many crocodile tears they might shed in court.
One assumes apoplexy.
@mdavidford which passenger? There’s a woman standing by the left front wheel, so presumably it isn’t her? So unless there are people in the back seat, this is just a lie in an attempt to get away with it.
Hedley came at the cyclist from the side, possibly not even in his peripheral vision. “I had to move him”? By throwing him to the ground right in front of your 2 tonne wankpanzer?
His brain injury doesn’t matter?
@Daveyraveygravey It seems incredible the woman was so calm if someone in the back of the car really were having a medical emergency, and if they really were in that much of a rush, why slow things down by getting out of the car when simply reversing to go around their victim would have allowed them to get under way much more quickly?
I’m not for filling prisons with people who are unlikely to offend again, and a sort of semi-home arrest can be a reasonable punishment that saves the tax payer money. A night time curfew is probably fairly effective for the sort of person who gets into fights in pubs, but this was in broad daylight. No driving ban, presumably because on exiting the car it can no longer count as a driving offence, and yet this man was clearly experiencing road rage and the incident demonstrated, IMO, that he doesn’t have the temperament to be responsible for a one and a half tonne killing machine. I’m no legal expert, but if it’s not currently possible to ban someone from driving for actions that take place once they leave their vehicle, there should be a change. The assault happened on the public highway within a couple of seconds of the offender exiting the car. The offender didn’t pause to talk or argue with his victim. Getting out of the car and assaulting his victim was all one movement. He was clearly in an unfit state of mind for driving whilst still behind the wheel.
@FionaJJ I agree with most of what you say. However, I would argue that Hedley could well offend again and may have assaulted people on previous occasions. The involvement of a vehicle may be incidental.
These are not the actions of a well adjusted non-violent person.
@Mr Blackbird I agree, and thought that’s what I was saying.
My point was that the law as it stands MAY not have allowed the sentence to include a driving ban, and if not, that should change to include this type of incident.
The video makes it very clear he’s not well adjusted and I think we’d all be very surprised if he had no history of violence, even if it was never prosecuted. The woman’s body language suggests she was not at all surprised by his actions, and if anything she was acting like someone hoping to avoid further escalation of violence.
Sadly, I doubt even a custodial sentence would have any impact on someone like him. It would get him off the streets for a while, but he appears incapable of even pretending to have any remorse.
@Mr Blackbird I do not know and it’s not mentioned here … but I am suspicious that a look into this chap’s past history would show that this is not an isolated “loss of control”, even if he wasn’t eg. employed as an enforcer with a criminal concern.
@FionaJJ Sentencing Act 2020, driving bans are available where “a motor vehicle was used (by the offender or by anyone else) for the purpose of committing, or facilitating the commission of, the offence.”
h ttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2020/17/group/THIRD/part/8/chapter/1/enacted
Not 100% sure if it applies to Scotland or just England and Wales.
Under Section 163 a ban can be handed out for any offence at all. In practice it tends to be only used in cases that involve a vehicle in some way that doesn’t count as ‘using’ it. Seems like there’s a reasonable case to be made that that applies in this case, though.
Worth noting that his car is blocking the road. Either the cyclist was turning right and he pulled out to turn right towards Lothian Road and cut him up, or he was turning left towards the Pleasance and crossed into oncoming traffic. I don’t see a scenario where the cyclist was in the wrong, and “in the way” simply means not diving out of the way of a useless angry driver.
The nonsense about a “seizure” also needs to be called out. Unless she’s related to Lazarus. Likely she had a light in her face because her pet primate pulled out in front of a cyclist with a front light on his bike.
When I look at the angle of his wankpanzer I suspect he was coming out of High School Wynd (give way lines) and planned to cross straight over on to Blackfriars Wynd, I suspect his victim was going East on Cowgate (coming from the drivers left). The driver has failed to give way and a collision nearly happened, but both have stopped.
After that voices will have been raised, pride hurt, stubborness and Adrenalin kick in passenger gets out (this is when the video starts) and we all see what happens next
‘unprecedented cycle use in kirkcaldy causing delays for motorists; man misses curfew’
in less commercial times, community conscience might have had it’s own punitive effect. denial of local service and hospitality, etc. what could be an equivalent now?
maybe the local cycling clubs can arrange a regular exhibition tour past his domicile at 19:01 most evenings
Genuine questions:
Given convicted criminals can, and often do, file claims with the Court of Appeals, speciously claiming overly harsh sentencing to get away with watered-down punishments, does anyone know who has the prerogative to take a claim to the Court of Appeals that a sentence is overly lenient?
And specifically in this case, does Mr Hedley’s post-sentencing interview constitute evidence that he shows no remorse for his actions, therefore any clemency by Sheriff Thompson for Mr Hedley reportedly taking account for his actions, was entirely on false premise?
@ROOTminus1
“The prosecutor – who puts the case against the offender in a trial – can appeal against a sentence if they think it is unduly lenient. In some cases they can appeal against a ‘not guilty’ verdict, but this is only when a judge heard the case without a jury and the appeal is about a point of law.”
public sentiment and support can lend weight to such considerations. you would need to direct any such supporting statement fao Faith Currie, COPFS.
https://www.scottishsentencingcouncil.org.uk/sentencing-information/disposals-and-appeals
@the infamous grouse
that would be the same Faith Currie that said:
@momove well he has been held to account … just not punished accordingly.
It’s a bit scary to know the UK justice system let’s people off with a slap on the wrist for attempted manslaughter! I don’t think I’ll be riding a bike if I visit your fair country!
That was unbelievable!
@rgriffith7 Dont visit. The UK is a fucking dump.
@rgriffith7 I’m not sure the wisdom of basing your safety analysis on what happens *after* the bad thing has occurred. I’d be more interested in that not happening in the first place … but I guess it’s a fair proxy for general attitude to driver behaviour / cyclists.
Anyway – if you’re of an adventurous disposition and can avoid obvious invitations to an altercation (basically any time a motorist takes the time to insult you, or worse) stats show that on average you can enjoy several lifetimes of cycling in the UK without serious injury…
Lifelong UK transport cyclist here, still alive at time of posting…
@rgriffith7 I don’t know where you live, but having ridden quite a bit in both the US and the UK, I’d take the UK any day.
All the more of a reason to always wear a helmet, obviously the cyclist thought he was entitled and invincible. Now after the fracture he must wear a helmet just to walk down the road. The car driver pays vehicle tax so has the right to do whatever he wants and the law will back him right up to the hilt..
@rbrtribble
/S right? Right?
Otherwise; Ladies and Gentlemen, Nigel is back in our midst under another pseudonym. How long before this account is removed for racist hate speech?
@ROOTminus1 was going with “sarcasm” but they should have gone with “road tax” and some comment about “unlike cyclists who aren’t even making meaningful journeys” for full marks.
Perhaps with a side of “and the fact this went to court shows that motorists are scrutinised for the slightest technical fault (like speeding, driving where not allowed)! And they’re held to exacting standards, not even excused momentarily losing control under extreme provocation from these activists-on-2-wheels… (BTW that’s only possible because they have car number plates / licences etc unlike cyclists…)”
@rbrtribble as the driver was out of his vehicle, thereby not making it a driving offence, and the cyclists was stationary with their feet on the ground, there was no more need for a helmet than if the encounter had been between two drivers who had got out of their cars, or two blokes in a pub.
Maybe all of those people who fall down the stairs and hit their head should wear a helmet?
I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt, and accept that you were being sarcastic, but leave my comment for the benefit of those who think you were being serious.
@rbrtribble You’re a bit of a cunt arent you
Was the judge breathalysed?
No justice as usual.
At least we can take solace that the perp seems to have aged about 20 years in the 2 years this has taken to come to trial.
I cannot fathom how a judge could show leniency to a person who assaulted someone so severely for no good reason. If the court won’t jail someone , then perhaps a civil suit for damages would be the next best thing. Bankrupt the son of a …
@BrianP just wait until you read road.cc stories for a couple of weeks: you’ll start to fathom it alright…
… although it won’t make you happier, and indeed may even disincline you to cycle on the roads.
In fairness a quick general review of cases of assault might also be depressing in terms of outcomes / actual penalties for any identified perpetrators.
But on the roads I believe little changes until our current motornormative culture does. No matter what “top down” changes might be made. And indeed even those law changes / directions to police and courts won’t be a priority for the politicians until the electorate change their view…
Change – it’s possible (see NL) but very hard, until it happens.
Hedley avoided a jail sentence “by the narrowest of margins”. Still the same outcome, and even more infuriating…