Justice (Lonpicman, Wikimedia Commons)
Justice (Lonpicman, Wikimedia Commons) (Image Credit: Farrelly Atkinson)

Drunk driver who crashed into cyclist, breaking his neck, walks free from court

Judge imposes suspended sentence on the defendant, saying their decision to drive after drinking was a “moment of stupidity”
Mon, Dec 19, 2022 12:46
22
Justice (Lonpicman, Wikimedia Commons)
Justice (Lonpicman, Wikimedia Commons) (Image Credit: Farrelly Atkinson)
Google icon
Add as a preferred source on Google

A​ driver who knocked a cyclist from his bike, resulting in his neck being broken, has walked free from court after a judge who described them as having had a “moment of stupidity” handed her a suspended sentence.

The defendant* had pleaded guilty at Maidstone Crown Court to causing serious injury by dangerous driving – an offence which carries a maximum penalty of five years in jail – failure to stop following an accident and drink-driving, reports Kent Online.

The court heard that CCTV captured the moment when the defendant hit cyclist David Shirley, who was wearing a hi-viz vest, on Mill Hill in Edenbridge, Kent, on 8 August 2021.

The footage showed that despite the force of the impact causing the bumper of their vehicle to become detached, they failed to stop at the scene.

People living nearby who heard the crash alerted police after finding Mr Shirley lying injured in the road.

He was given first aid by an off-duty sergeant from Kent Special Constabulary, and two off-duty Metropolitan Police Officers assisted by closing the road so he could receive treatment.

Police officers used the CCTV pictures and ANPR cameras to identify their vehicle, which they found, damaged, when they visited their home three hours after the collision.

Recorder Laurence Harris, the judge in the case, described the defendant’s decision to drive while drunk as being a “moment of stupidity.”

He sentenced them to 16 months in jail, suspended for 18 months, and ordered them to pay the victim £500 in compensation.

“You did not stop,” he told them. “You made no attempt to call for an ambulance or help Mr Shirley.”

Referring to police visiting their home after the collision, he said: “You were asked if you knew why officers were there and said no.

“You were asked to take a breath test which showed you were over the legal alcohol limit and were arrested.

“On any basis, your dangerous driving has had a serious impact on Mr Shirley, both physical and mental.

“The spinal fracture which you caused meant that he was required to wear a neck brace for 12 weeks after the accident. He also suffered a cut left ear.

“Your moment of stupidity in driving under the influence of alcohol has led to a profound impact on Mr Shirley’s life and well-being. No sentence that I pass can undo that impact.

“There was also a significant impact on his vision, causing him headaches, loss of depth perception requiring him to use a walking stick and restricting his ability to go out socially,” the judge added.

“There are inevitably concerns about the longer-term impact of this serious injury.”

The defendant was also banned from driving for 30 months, and will have to wear a tag to monitor a 90-day abstinence from alcohol imposed by the judge, as well as a six-month, three days a week curfew.

* Due to persistent requests, the defendant’s name has been omitted from the article

Simon joined road.cc as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

22 Comments

22 thoughts on “Drunk driver who crashed into cyclist, breaking his neck, walks free from court”

  1. After every article like this
    After every article like this, I tell myself not to read the next one, and save myself the upset and impotent rage.
    And yet… I still find myself reading these articles, I still find myself becoming upset, and I still suffer from impotent rage.

    I’ve had to stop sharing this stuff on Facebook, or reading it to my wife as I cansee the time where she says “enough” and stops me going out (remember, she’s spent the last 4 years watching me suffer following the guy that drove in to me, and changing our lives forever).

    What does it take for this shit to stop; for judges to stop seeing the offender as the victim?

    • My wife is clear that she

      My wife is clear that she doesn’t want me to tell her because she would worry about my safety, but knows that no cycling would have other negative effects…

      It’s clear that personal responsibility isn’t going to work. To be honest other than getting another dangerous driver off the road more custodial sentencing isn’t going to work.

      What we do have is technology. It has been possible to deactivate the ignition of a vehicle until a breath sample is supplied for years. Cars increasingly have the ability to gauge the attentiveness of the driver. Regulations have mandated traction control, ABS, EABC, etc. on new cars over the years but all of these are trying to sort out a problem once the drivers’ incompetence/ inattention has caused it. Would it not be better to prevent a car from moving unless the driver proved they were in a fit state? While we are at it use GPS to set the speed limiter as well.

      • Prevention is obviously

        Prevention is obviously better than cure but consequence is also a factor.

         

        The consequences are so little to those behind the wheel that speeding, checking facebook, self-entitlement, inattention, not driving to conditions and victim blaming are now the norm; why would you even bother to drive well?

         

        Just as an example, how often do you think the average person that has the required 12 points for a speeding ban actually was speeding? And thousands of them still keep their license!

  2. There seems to be no end to

    There seems to be no end to these joke penalties for very serious motoring offences, and leaving the scene after inflicting devastating injuries on cyclists now seems to be accepted as ‘normal behaviour’. We know that she will break this ’90 day abstinence’ and we know that they’ll do nothing about it other than warn her ‘do this several more times and there will really be trouble’

  3. This is exactly the kind of

    This is exactly the kind of sociopathic driver that needs to be removed from the roads. That judge is clearly not fit for purpose and should be immediately removed from judging any further driving related cases.

    I don’t understand the ‘moment of stupidity’ line of thinking. Does it mean that only pre-meditated crimes should be treated seriously? Also, being drunk in control of a vehicle shows some clear pre-meditation in having the vehicle available to you whilst getting inebriated. Also, continuing to drive whilst inebriated would entail several more ‘moments of stupidity’ and after hitting someone, another ‘moment of stupidity’ in not stopping to render assistance.

    • Follow that logic – and the

      Follow that logic – and the only fully culpable decision was to take the first drink.  (After that, you’re increasingly drunk so “your judgement was impaired… in a moment of panic you left the scene… wrong but we can understand…”)

      …which is also the most normal and reasonable thing they did!

      TBH I’m having a bit of a moment at this one.  I thought drink-driving was the one part – of all the problematic aspects of driving – that society (and the law) mostly condemned.  And now this.

      Should we just be grateful that “but what about the children” wasn’t used as an escape from any driving ban?

    • They are still awaiting
      They are still awaiting confirmation but using those, it should have been a range of 1 to 3 years with a starting point of 2 years in custody and then account for 2 possibly 3 of the listed aggravating factors (drinking, failure to stop and possibly driving uninsured since technically drink driving invalidates most insurance cover) and 1 mitigating factor (family responsibilities) and then reduce the resulting sentence in recognition of a guilty plea. I would say the sentence was very lenient or even unduly lenient based on that.

  4. Ahh another sentence that

    Ahh another sentence that basically says “you don’t have to pay attention when you are driving a 2 tonne lump of death at speed”.

    Thats what all these sentences boil down to. How could anyone be expected to pay attention when driving. Its clearly just unreasonable. 

    I was in the passenger seat the other day as we drove for a few hours and the number of people driving erratically only for us to go past them and see that they were on their phone or not looking at the road was mind boggling. On a motorway. Going about 70.

    People don’t give a shit about it because the law says they don’t have to give a shit about it. No, harsher punishments won’t bring loved ones back or fix bad driving but if we made driving a priviledge rather than a right, that would be a good start. Start banning people. Properly. This woman should be banned for 5 years for this. If people started losing their jobs, their freedom and their cars when they put other peoples lives at risk they might take it a bit more seriously. 

  5. There does exist a mechanism

    There does exist a mechanism for questioning the objectivity of judges, but I’m jiggered if I can remember it.

    I recall the National Secular Society complained about Cherie Blair once when she made some comments in the Chair that they thought indicated a religious bias.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/secular-society-upset-by-judge-cherie-decision-1889792.html

    Found it.

    It’s called the Office for (or of) Judicial Complaints. (Ahem.)

    One needs to be creative in writing the complaint, just like planning objections:

    ——————————————————————-

    Judicial Conduct Investigations Office
     

    We are an independent office which supports the Lord Chancellor and Lord Chief Justice in considering complaints about the personal conduct of judicial office holders.

    We cannot accept complaints about a judge’s decision or the way a judge has managed a case.

    • mattw wrote:

      We cannot accept complaints about a judge’s decision or the way a judge has managed a case.

      — mattw

      What the fudge are grounds for complaint then? Presumably only unprofessional conduct?

      • Given that I once got stung

        Given that I once got stung for £30k for hospitalising a pedestrian, I hope the cyclist got considerably more.

        (I being my house insurance company – I didn’t want to settle  with the ambulance chasing f*ckwads. But I had no choice in the matter.)

    • My favourite there is

      My favourite there is definitely

      “You’ve hit a road sign”

      “No I haven’t”

      “Your car is on top of a road sign” 

Leave a Comment

 

 

Read more...

Read more...

Read more...

Latest Comments

mattw 6 hours ago

@jaymack Why would the cost of owning and running a car be relevant to this comparison? It is a charge for a storage space. Do you want to include the cost of tyres too?

in: Cars now cheaper to park than bikes in some London boroughs as cycle hangar costs soar
pphaneuf 7 hours ago

Non-racing bib shorts/tights without pockets should be illegal in 2027.

in: Gobik Subzero Bib Tights review – ideal for freezing rides
andystow 7 hours ago

@kingleo you totally misunderstood my comment, but that's not surprising. The actual number is well under 1% per year. Because of this, the vast majority will have zero crashes with cars in decades. Some, like you, will feel superior because of it, because you don't understand statistics.

in: “Should Lime riders be forced to wear helmets?” asks folding helmet founder – but cyclists tell him to “leave us alone”; TV camera captures cyclist’s near miss on London’s most dangerous junction; Pro cycling reform group launches + more on the live blog
chrisonabike 7 hours ago

@andystow yup - the illusion of skill. Cycling safety is another Schroedinger's cyclist paradox - it is simultaneously more dangerous than it should be (and certainly can feel much more so) but equally most of us (in the UK at least) could cycle a lifetime or two without coming to serious harm. (Perhaps longer - if only most of us did...) FWIW the Dutch statistics show that considered at population level (with "mass cycling") and if cyclists are adequately protected from the worst effects of motor traffic ... ... the majority of crashes causing some kind of injury are essentially "falling off your bike" or running into static things. But of course that includes the minor injuries (and very old/young people who cycle in numbers there), and "if..."

in: “Should Lime riders be forced to wear helmets?” asks folding helmet founder – but cyclists tell him to “leave us alone”; TV camera captures cyclist’s near miss on London’s most dangerous junction; Pro cycling reform group launches + more on the live blog
Aluminium can 7 hours ago

Well, the downtube looks to have a kammtail shape, so there's obviously some aerodynamics going on.

in: Boasting space for 55mm tyres and its ‘lightest yet stiffest’ frame, the updated Tambora is set to be Polygon’s fastest gravel bike yet
Rendel Harris 8 hours ago

@kingleo I can assure you it takes much more than the likes of you to get me in a throth, in fact I can honestly say I've never been in a throth in my life. Thousands of cycle races and thousands of running races, eh? So that's a minimum two thousand of each, four thousand races over sixty years, more than one every single week for six decades. All whilst holding down a job in London to which you cycle commuted for forty-eight years and extensively touring Britain and Europe to boot! Well well. Unfortunately no level of experience, real or imaginary, can make your comments any less foolish or victim blaming.

in: “Should Lime riders be forced to wear helmets?” asks folding helmet founder – but cyclists tell him to “leave us alone”; TV camera captures cyclist’s near miss on London’s most dangerous junction; Pro cycling reform group launches + more on the live blog
chrisonabike 8 hours ago

@HoarseMann yup - in one of his articles ol' Ranty covers that, noting that while they are often demanded (if only as "reassurance") they take us back to the world of "cyclists as drivers of mini cars" and the faulty premises around that. (Where in fact unlike with motor vehicles both pedestrians and cyclists are more able to "negotiate".) It is nuanced though. The issues that IIRC he also touches on are that right now, the majority of people in the UK are habituated to those expectations (if they consider cyclists should be there at all...) That can make it difficult for planners and designers who may feel the weight of having to "square the circle" of what is ultimately a political decision *. They may know what "gold standard" is but if they're doing their jobs properly they'll understand they have to take the humans we have into account. There is also greater awareness of the "accessibility lobby" now. (Not least - those law makers and public-opinion-setters aren't getting any younger!) Albeit that doesn't mean they won't get ignored as usual after being co-opted for "selective concern" when we *really need* those extra parking spaces / that road widening... And they have been used to new developments always being a major challenge - and not uncommonly things being even less convenient after. * e.g. "the current level of motoring - and particularly likely increases in it if we continue as normal - is unsustainable. So we have decided to back measures that best deliver transport most fairly, in a more cost- and space- effective way".

in: Floating bus stops are “low risk” and rarely cause cyclists and pedestrians to “interact”, new Transport for London report finds
chrisonabike 8 hours ago

Next up: Sir David Attenborough distils his (seven?) decades of wildlife broadcasting knowledge for a new generation: "Find some animals to talk about, and make sure you record it in some way". ;-) Caution is advised when out there of course. Being less snarky they make cycling a part of the school curriculum as standard in The Netherlands I believe, and that's in a place where it is normal, so perhaps more adult training is advised as we hope to encourage more cycling? I'm glad that people continue to take up cycling (even if casually - but those are unlikely to be readers of road.cc of course). And to hear of those who keep doing so (particularly if not just "I'm alright Jack"). As they'll likely - on average - have at least a mildly better time. And may help make the place (even more slightly) better for everyone else.

in: “Should Lime riders be forced to wear helmets?” asks folding helmet founder – but cyclists tell him to “leave us alone”; TV camera captures cyclist’s near miss on London’s most dangerous junction; Pro cycling reform group launches + more on the live blog

Most Popular News