A council criticised for installing “discriminatory” barriers on a cycling and walking route in Bolton, apparently to prevent anti-social behaviour, has admitted no equality impact assessment was carried out pre-installation but believes it has still acted in accordance with design guidance.
The barriers appeared on Rothwell Street on a cycling and walking route, Bolton Council arguing their installation was a necessary reaction to criminality and people using the route to evade the police. However, cyclist and Bolton Active Travel Forum Technical Review Group member Dr Grahame Cooper, as well as many others, have called the council out for the inadvertent impact such barriers can have on people, particularly those with disabilities who may use an adapted cycle.
“Discriminatory” barriers (Image Credit: Dr Grahame Cooper/supplied)
“The real issue is that the barriers discriminate against people who use many types of cycle, including adapted cycles for users with disabilities, and the council’s failure to follow due process,” he told road.cc.
“The Public Sector Equality Duty, placed on public sector bodies by the Equality Act 2010, means that the council is required to assess the impact of the changes on protected groups such as disabled, elderly and pregnant people and record the reasons why the perceived need for the barrier outweighs that duty.
“They have admitted that they have not done that and there is no Equality Impact Assessment. This is particularly important if they are departing from national guidance. Before the barrier was installed, the 3.5-metre-wide path was perfectly adequate for shared cycling and walking use. Now that the barriers are in, there is conflict between the needs of people walking and cycling due to the bottleneck.”
The route has also become strewn with litter and broken glass since the barriers were installed, Dr Cooper suggesting it has created a “focal point for anti-social behaviour and littering”.
“Discriminatory” barriers (Image Credit: Dr Grahame Cooper/supplied)
However, of main concern is the inability for many cycle users to still be able to access the route. Explaining the decision to the Bolton News, Bolton Council said the barriers were introduced as a “temporary” measure to tackle “a prolonged period of anti-social behaviour and criminality”.
“People were using the route at the end of Rothwell Street to evade police officers,” a council spokesperson said.
“Working with Greater Manchester Police, the council installed the temporary barriers at the end of Rothwell Street to assist the police in tackling the anti-social behaviour which was blighting the local community.
“Installing the barriers is not an action taken lightly but there is still access for pedestrians and most cycles and it is expected that the barriers will only be a temporary measure.
“The design guidance for cycle infrastructure states that barriers should only be used if there is ‘a persistent and significant problem of antisocial moped or motorcycle access that cannot be controlled through periodic policing’ which is the case here.”
That final paragraph references the official Department for Transport guidance for local authorities regarding the design of “high-quality, safe cycle infrastructure”, but does not mention the fact that in the very next paragraph, the LTN1/20 guidance also states:
Access controls that require the cyclist to dismount or cannot accommodate the cycle design vehicle are not inclusive and should not be used
20 guidance (Image Credit: Farrelly Atkinson)
The council reportedly also confirmed that it had not carried out an equality impact assessment, a process meant to help authorities consider the potential effects of policies, and to make sure they do not discriminate or disadvantage people.
Dr Cooper also tells us he has seen the response to a Freedom of Information request, made to Greater Manchester Police, which asked the force to “provide a copy of advice or communication from 2023” with Bolton Council or relevant councillors relating to the barriers’ installation.
“Following receipt of your request searches were conducted within Greater Manchester Police (GMP) to locate the requested information and I can confirm the information requested is not held by GMP,” the reply reportedly came.
Dame Sarah Storey, Paralympian-turned-active travel commissioner for Greater Manchester, said she would be working “with the police and local authority to find a long-term solution”. Campaign group Walk Ride Greater Manchester warned there are more than 100 similar barriers across Bolton.
Similar cycle lane-blocking barriers have been seen in locations across the country, campaigners and local riders calling on local authorities to remove them to make routes more accessible for all.
In January 2022, York City Council removed the “shameful” barriers that blocked access to a cycle route, while Stockport Council in the same year decided to backtrack on barriers installed to, as in Bolton, combat anti-social behaviour.
Back in September a cyclist in Newcastle sent a legal letter to the council to challenge the lawfulness of barriers on a National Cycle Route which prevent him from accessing the path on his recumbent.
Cyclist challenges council over barriers on popular cycle route that “discriminate against disabled people” (Alastair Fulcher) (Image Credit: Farrelly Atkinson)
Most bizarrely was the case in Milton Keynes last year which saw ultracycling legend Steve Abraham criticise the local council’s move to install bollards on a cycleway as it meant the route was no longer accessible for those using cargo bikes.
The bizarre bit comes from the fact the cargo bikes in question, used by Abraham in his work as a courier, were themselves supplied by the council.
New bollards on Milton Keynes cycle routes (Steve Abraham) (Image Credit: Farrelly Atkinson)
Help us to bring you the best cycling content
If you’ve enjoyed this article, then please consider subscribing to road.cc from as little as £2.49. Our mission is to bring you all the news that’s relevant to you as a cyclist, independent reviews, impartial buying advice and more. Your subscription will help us to do more.
Dan was the road.cc news editor from 2022-2026. He joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan mainly wrote news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.
Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, you’ll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he’ll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he’s a bit strange like that.
13 Comments
13 thoughts on “Under-fire council admits “discriminatory” cycle route barriers were installed without equality impact assessment”
Im still for and agasnt them
Im still for and agasnt them
We get a lot of dick heads on mopeds using such pathways as a speedway, often two or tree at a time.
But they do get in the way for the rest of us
Unfortunately, there’s no design that will stop a moped, but won’t stop a bakfiets. Even something weight sensitive, there’s considerable overlap between the weight of a light moped and a loaded cargo bike with a heavy rider.
Unless the criminals escaping from the police were using some form of vehicle more than 1,5m wide, I don’t really see the point of these barriers, because that’s the only people they’re going to stop.
“Installing the barriers is not an action taken lightly but there is still access for pedestrians and most cycles and it is expected that the barriers will only be a temporary measure.”
It appears to be a decision taken very lightly, with no reference to guidance, no Equality Impact Assessment, and no consultation with local cyclists. Seems pretty permanent to me, and if it’s only temporary, what is the permanent solution and when is it going to happen?
Someone should have a proper Someone should have a proper look at the A barriers in place at the Ancholme Valley Way trail (similar to these https://www.cycling-embassy.org.uk/dictionary/access-barrier), I struggle passing through them, even when just running. And they are no stop whatsoever to the motocross lot, as they just go through the farm grass verge.
This is yet another example of an attempt to use a technological “solution” for a law enforcement issue. There’s always edge cases that the designers/implementers don’t anticipate and meanwhile, everyone is inconvenienced by the barriers. It snaps my cranks that people are putting time, effort and money into building hostile anti-infrastructure i.e. designs that try to prevent people doing what they want similar to the anti-homeless sleeping designs of benches and bus stops.
What’s needed is to have law enforcement deal with law enforcement issues and in this case, I’d say that a handful of plucky drone operators could easily keep an eye on the path or better yet, revert back to having a physical police presence which is a lot more expensive, but also sends a deterrent message and increases people’s perception of safety.
… What’s needed is to have law enforcement deal with law enforcement issues and in this case, I’d say that a handful of plucky drone operators could easily keep an eye on the path …
— hawkinspeter
Bloody drones taking over the airspace, think the skies are made for them, flying right past red lightsno fly zones…
Ironically, the fact that the Ironically, the fact that the barriers are now surrounded by litter and broken glass suggests that people are using them as somewhere to sit and drink.
Ironically, the fact that the barriers are now surrounded by litter and broken glass suggests that people are using them as somewhere to sit and drink.
Ironically, the fact that the barriers are now surrounded by litter and broken glass suggests that people are using them as somewhere to sit and drink.
— bensynnock
And this is why we can’t ban drink-driving, because of the unintended consequences of displacing people who can’t now (perfectly reasonably) sit and drink in their vehicles…
I can only suggest everyone interested have a look at The Ranty Highwayman's blog (he's a civil engineer who now specialises in "sustainable mobility") where he has - with increasing weariness - covered this subject many times. And has pointed out the fact that for many years we have had exactly the same but where there is a *road* between the bus stop and the footway, eliciting very little "won't you think of the blind..."
For those interested this topic has also been covered by Robert Weetman, Bicycle Dutch (who has articles on "Riding around the bus stop" and also "How hard is it to cross the cycle path?") etc.
Please can we have a similar study done for collisions involving drivers and disabled people, at all types of pedestrian crossings?
A few years ago I asked the RNIB and/or NFB for stats on collisions involving visually impaired people and drivers/cyclists etc.
To show that the major danger is likely to be from drivers, both in numbers of collisions and severity.
They could not provide the stats.
@jaymack indeed, but in may people's calculations that cost is effectively ignored because "it's already paid / a given" or "we obviously have to have a car anyway".
So once people have one we don't exactly forget that it costs money, but tend to look at the cost of e.g. a train ticket vs. the cost of fuel to drive somewhere and the latter very often looks a better prospect! (Even ignoring the other tradeoffs people may consider like "my own space" / "I can leave / return when I like" / "door to door" etc.)
@OnYerBike "Taking guesses as to what else might have caused that kind of damage…"
I'm constantly seeing both cycle infra and nearby things like paving slabs, heavy-duty railings, lamp posts, concrete bollards etc. that have been bent or broken by those bloody cyclists...
@kingleo Another reason for not being content to say "take care, y'all" is that most people know (well ... "feel") that this is normal in the UK so it is yet another factor contributing to most people not wanting to cycle.
And it's not the same as the case of e.g. crossing the road, where your safety as a pedestrian is more fully in your own hands (barring the drivers mounting the pavement, which alas does happen...)
I assume you wouldn't echo the suggestion by the good public in some of the comments which seems to be that if cyclists want to remain uninjured they better stop (and possibly dismount) every time they reach a junction. Even if it's with a side street and it's their right of way.
Could their be an alternative? Yes, and it's both simple and proven (see e.g. "continuous footway / cycleway"). But that requires both re-engineering our urban spaces and some degree of behaviour change from people driving.
In this case it needs fewer people driving, probably via sending the through traffic somewhere else or otherwise reducing the demand for driving here. Having a busy A-road through a "place" like this is unlikely to lead to happy transport solutions. I guess sorting out (outer) London is very difficult though since it's a huge collection of urban centres which have organically grown together.
@kingleo Do try not to be ridiculous, I am not in the least wound up by your foolish comments, I'm just pointing out how stupid they are.
Your claimed figures are completely wrong, research in Scotland showed that 73% of cyclist/driver collisions were the fault of the driver, for the UK as a whole cyclists have been found to be solely responsible for crashes in just 20% of cases. Even if your "Half the accidents that happened to cyclists are the fault of the cyclists" was true that would leave the other half that wasn't the fault of the cyclist, which in itself would be enough to disprove your silly "all you have to do to avoid crashing is be like me, cover the brakes, ride at a suitable speed and expect people to pull out in front of you" statement.
@kingleo Thanks and it looks like the cyclists in the video did exactly that, which is why they weren't on the floor and are uninjured.
Unfortunately, that is no guarantee of being uninjured. Because if drivers are simply pulling out across a lane without looking or caring what's in it (the cycle lane is a lane) at some point a crash will occur.
If the driver did this and hit / was hit by another motor car it's still possible that someone would be injured but the odds are that outcomes would mostly be property damage. Not so in the cycling case.
13 thoughts on “Under-fire council admits “discriminatory” cycle route barriers were installed without equality impact assessment”
Im still for and agasnt them
Im still for and agasnt them
We get a lot of dick heads on mopeds using such pathways as a speedway, often two or tree at a time.
But they do get in the way for the rest of us
Dbloke wrote:
How will these barriers stop them?
Unfortunately, there’s no
Unfortunately, there’s no design that will stop a moped, but won’t stop a bakfiets. Even something weight sensitive, there’s considerable overlap between the weight of a light moped and a loaded cargo bike with a heavy rider.
Its ridiculous a knee jerk
Its ridiculous a knee jerk local council responses to “something must be done”
Unless the criminals escaping
Unless the criminals escaping from the police were using some form of vehicle more than 1,5m wide, I don’t really see the point of these barriers, because that’s the only people they’re going to stop.
“Installing the barriers is not an action taken lightly but there is still access for pedestrians and most cycles and it is expected that the barriers will only be a temporary measure.”
It appears to be a decision taken very lightly, with no reference to guidance, no Equality Impact Assessment, and no consultation with local cyclists. Seems pretty permanent to me, and if it’s only temporary, what is the permanent solution and when is it going to happen?
Plenty of criminal use roads
Plenty of criminal use roads to evade the police – maybe we should install barriers across those, too…?
I’ve seen people on mobility
I’ve seen people on mobility scooters taking a long time to navigate those barriers too
Someone should have a proper
Someone should have a proper look at the A barriers in place at the Ancholme Valley Way trail (similar to these https://www.cycling-embassy.org.uk/dictionary/access-barrier), I struggle passing through them, even when just running. And they are no stop whatsoever to the motocross lot, as they just go through the farm grass verge.
This is yet another example
This is yet another example of an attempt to use a technological “solution” for a law enforcement issue. There’s always edge cases that the designers/implementers don’t anticipate and meanwhile, everyone is inconvenienced by the barriers. It snaps my cranks that people are putting time, effort and money into building hostile anti-infrastructure i.e. designs that try to prevent people doing what they want similar to the anti-homeless sleeping designs of benches and bus stops.
What’s needed is to have law enforcement deal with law enforcement issues and in this case, I’d say that a handful of plucky drone operators could easily keep an eye on the path or better yet, revert back to having a physical police presence which is a lot more expensive, but also sends a deterrent message and increases people’s perception of safety.
hawkinspeter wrote:
Bloody drones taking over the airspace, think the skies are made for them, flying right past
red lightsno fly zones…They’re a menace to vulnerable sky users!
Ironically, the fact that the
Ironically, the fact that the barriers are now surrounded by litter and broken glass suggests that people are using them as somewhere to sit and drink.
bensynnock wrote:
Don’t worry: v2 will have spikes.
bensynnock wrote:
And this is why we can’t ban drink-driving, because of the unintended consequences of displacing people who can’t now (perfectly reasonably) sit and drink in their vehicles…