[TheBillder]

I’m in the middle of rebuilding the light tourer I bought new in the summer of 1988. The frame is at the painter, the wheels are being built by my LBS, I’ve chosen new pedals and toe clips, etc. It’s not going to be original (10 speed cassette going in) but not totally modern (friction shifting for example).

I need to find a saddle that’s not a million miles off visually. The riding position is less upright than might be expected as the frame has always been in the large side for me, and I probably like a bit more squish for my flabby arse than a proper roadie. But it still needs to look like a fast bike.

Could go for a Spa Cycles leather one, as the bike was a bit tourer-ish but worried that I’ll never get through the soreness if breaking in. On the weighty side too.

Could also go for a brown Charge Spoon – I use a similar Madison Flux on another bike and it’s ok for comfort – but it still looks a bit too modern.

I had a vague pointer to a Selle San Marco Rolls but the customer reviews are quite varied.

So can anyone recommend a comfy retro looking saddle up to about £50?

Thanks.

Topic

[TheBillder]

A belated thank you to all
A belated thank you to all who contributed to this discussion. In the end Santa went for the Regal. The bike it’s going on has been at the painters for over a month so I’m yet to put them together.

Eventually I got so keen to try the saddle that it has gone onto my winter bike, displacing the Madison Flux (a Charge Spoon derivative). So far (3 rides) I’m still getting used to it – much more curved side to side than the Flux. Not yet super comfy but does look amazing, even though the bike is wrong for it.

At some point when the weather is milder I’ll be able to try it with various shorts instead of the Galibier Mistral bib tights that are essential at the moment, and then perhaps I’ll find the perfect combination. If not,. Flite will be on the birthday list.

Thanks again all.

[EM69]

San Marco Rolls. Love the

San Marco Rolls. Love the Regal too, beautiful saddle but I believe these were more early 90s than 80s.

[Sjl]

Another vote for Rolls which

Another vote for Rolls which are supremely comfortable and very much in period, Flite titanium is also very good but a bit later, 90’s. 

[Shades]

Good 2nd hand market for

Good 2nd hand market for Brooks saddles on eBay; could well find something within budget

[TheBillder]

Brooks leather saddles are
Brooks leather saddles are perhaps a little older than I want, and definitely over budget. I’d go for a Spa if I changed my mind on having that look as cheaper and my backside would just have to harden up…

I’ve lusted after a Cambium for a while for other bikes. I see now that some are on offer at £75 so only 50% over budget, obv nothing when it comes to bike spending. So I’ll think some more!

[andystow]

I was going to suggest a

I was going to suggest a Cambium, but he said £50.

[EddyBerckx]

Is Brooks too retro?

Is Brooks too retro?

[TheBillder]

Ah, the inevitability of just
Ah, the inevitability of just one wafer-thin extra on any short list. I’ve seen good things about Buckets but nowhere to actually buy one. I think like most of the good Charge stuff, it’s all over except for some e-bikes.

But thanks for contributing.

[ChasP]

I’ve got a Charge Bucket on a

I’ve got a Charge Bucket on a retro build, cheap, comfy and looks the part.

[TheBillder]

I’ve seen a few people saying
I’ve seen a few people saying that. I just hope the cheaper Al railed one is just heavier and not stiff. I might just go for it first as the deal I’ve seen won’t last forever. Even at full price the Planet X is less than I’ve saved on cake while my club rides have been off so I can afford that later if the Flite isn’t for me.

Decision made.

[Welsh boy]

For what it’s worth, I have

For what it’s worth, I have used dozens of saddles and found the Flyte titanium to be the most comfortable sadle I have used by far.

[TheBillder]

Thanks everyone – plenty

Thanks everyone – plenty there for a short list.

I’m going to take a while to make up my mind, and as ever, what fits my posterior may not be quite the same as everyone else’s so whatever I go with first might end up on ebay (with a bunch of other saddles I really need to shift).

So far I am taken with the Flite (I know it’s slightly later than the bike but exactly the sort of saddle that might have been fitted as an upgrade) but a little worried that it might be too narrow. Good price at Condor, aluminium rails bring it under £50. Perhaps a little plain.

The Planet X Gran Sport was a surprise – it’s really cheap and looks nice, so I might take a punt. And the Regal does indeed look the business, I just need to decide if it’s the right look.

Of the others, the Rolls is a bit over budget, and I did want to buy new and shiny.

Thanks again everyone, I really appreciate that you took the time.

[lesterama]

Rolls or Regal, very comfy

Rolls or Regal, very comfy for me. New or used. A Regal with copper rails and rivets looks the business.

Selle Italia Turbo, Concor Profil and Cinelli Volare SLX are also decent and available used. Which one is comfy for you will depend on personal preference.

The Flite is early ’90s and not period-correct. Plus, some people find it extremely uncomfortable.

[Welsh boy]

https://www.planetx.co.uk/i/q

https://www.planetx.co.uk/i/q/SAHOGS/holdsworth-gran-sport-saddle

https://www.planetx.co.uk/i/q/SASMVREG/san-marco-regal-saddle

[Secret_squirrel]

+ 1m for the Rolls one of the

+ 1m for the Rolls one of the comfiest & classiest saddles I have ever owned – regularly used it without padded shorts.

-1m for the Flite.  Like sitting on a razor blade for my butt.

[Author]

Replies