Derbyshire: action on close pass reports only in “exceptional circumstances”

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #1737729
    Velo-drone

    Op Snap landing page for Derbyshire Police now says “Close pass reports – Whilst all close pass reports from cyclists and horse riders will continue to be reviewed, to remain efficient, effective and comply with national guidance regarding the analysis of video evidence, reports of close passes will only result in a positive outcome, including warning letters, in exceptional circumstances.”

    Does anyone know what “exceptional circumstances” actually means? Because zero explanation of that.

    In short it pretty much sounds like they are saying “don’t bother sending reports because we pretty much guaranteed don’t care and won’t do anything”. Is that what this is?

    Is this walloper going to count as “exceptional” – maybe 20cm clearance and forcing oncoming traffic to stop to not collide with them? My feeling from the disclaimer is this will be seen as normal everyday life-threatening behaviour that they can just delete as if it doesn’t matter.

    https://snap.derbyshire.police.uk/

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #1741623
    0
    mattw

    A Derbyshire Cyclist has published an excellent video looking at this, brimming with evidence and erudite commentary, back in the summer.

    #1739295
    1
    Bungle_52

    I have reposted my comment from Oct 30th which is still awaiting moderation!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The links have been removed.

    Gloucestershire Constabulary is way ahead. They never took any action on close passes but in September 2024 they started sending out advisory letters to close passers. Note that in Gloucestershire an advisory letter merely asks the driver to refresh their knowledge of the highway code and is not a warning letter.

    search : close-pass-isnt-offence-says-police-officer on roadcc for the article

    I have had action taken for a close pass since. In one I am convinced that action was taken because an oncoming driver was inconvenienced.

    near-miss-day-of the day 946

    In the other I suspect someone on the team slipped up and the driver was sent an NIP. I was told afterwards that the driver was going to go to court to challenge the decision but changed their mind when shown the footage.

    near-miss-day-931

    The link also shows that a very similar close pass a year later was back to advisory letters and I have had many similar outcomes since.

    Some on here think advisory letters are a waste of time and I agree that for some drivers it will be as water off a ducks back, but I have noticed a distinct improvement in driving around me since the policy started. I think most drivers genuinely think they have done nothing wrong but a letter from the police is a real wake up call.

    In answer to your question then in Gloucestershire someone has to be inconvenienced for action to be taken. Inconveniencing an oncoming driver is one possibility but having to swerve or brake to avoid being hit is another. Obviously this rarely happens with a close pass, especially those at speed which are the most dangerous, you simply don’t have time to do anything. As far as I can make out being frightened out of your skin doesn’t count as inconvenience either.

    They seem to have stopped sending even advisory letters for close passes now as they are short staffed.

    #1739037
    0
    Bungle_52

    Does anyone know how long moderation takes on the forum?

    #1738575
    1
    mdavidford

    All of that shouldn’t really need AI – it should all be stuff you could do pretty programatically. I can’t really see what advantage AI would deliver.

    #1738561
    1
    Velo-drone

    Feels like this is begging for AI deployment to me. If they still review them all, then the issue must be the burden of actually processing the action – obtaining the registered keeper info from the DVLA, issuing the NIP, processing any following notification of the driver, effecting the offer of points/driver improvement course etc.

    All of that should be just be delegated straight to AI.

    #1738043
    0
    Bungle_52

    Gloucestershire Constabulary is way ahead. They never took any action on close passes but in September 2024 they started sending out advisory letters to close passers. Note that in Gloucestershire an advisory letter merely asks the driver to refresh their knowledge of the highway code and is not a warning letter.

    https://road.cc/content/news/close-pass-isnt-offence-says-police-officer-310433

    I have had action taken for a close pass since. In one I am convinced that action was taken because an oncoming driver was inconvenienced.

    Near Miss of the Day 946: £1,000 fine after impatient driver close passes cyclist

    In the other I suspect someone on the team slipped up and the driver was sent an NIP. I was told afterwards that the driver was going to go to court to challenge the decision but changed their mind when shown the footage.

    https://road.cc/content/news/near-miss-day-931-314751

    The link also shows that a very similar close pass a year later was back to advisory letters and I have had many similar outcomes since.

    Some on here think advisory letters are a waste of time and I agree that for some drivers it will be as water off a ducks back, but I have noticed a distinct improvement in driving around me since the policy started. I think most drivers genuinely think they have done nothing wrong but a letter from the police is a real wake up call.

    In answer to your question then in Gloucestershire someone has to be inconvenienced for action to be taken. Inconveniencing an oncoming driver is one possibility but having to swerve or brake to avoid being hit is another. Obviously this rarely happens with a close pass, especially those at speed which are the most dangerous, you simply don’t have time to do anything. As far as I can make out being frightened out of your skin doesn’t count as inconvenience either.

    #1737917
    1
    HoarseMann

    At least they’re being honest about the lack of enforcement.

    The solution to this is to remove responsibility for enforcement of these offences from the police and create a dedicated national agency to deal with it.

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.