log in
register

Can mudguards be silent?

  • Creator
    Topic
  • September 27, 2017 at 10:14 am #27682
    sergius

    I’ve a new winter bike for this year, and finally gave in and bought one with mudguards 🙁

    I took it out for a spin in the rain on Monday, they worked wonderfully but my main take away from the experience was the rattling of the guards over poor road surfaces.

    The bike has 28mm tyres fitted so there isn’t a ton of clearance between guards and tyres (maybe 2-3mm on each side.  The guards are SKS raceblades I think (2017 Canyon Inflite with their recommended guards) so they are meant to be pretty reasonable ones.  

    From an engineering perspective, the materials involved and the method via which they are fixed to the frame would suggest to me that you are never going to be able to make guards that won’t flex a bit under vibration/bumps.  Am I right in assuming that some rattling is the price you pay for running mudguards and saving the rest of the bike from getting covered in crap?

  • Creator
    Topic
Viewing 8 replies - 16 through 23 (of 23 total)
1 2
  • Author
    Replies
  • September 27, 2017 at 1:58 pm #903137
    0
    kil0ran
    sergius wrote:
    The frame has all the fixings for the guards, no bodging required.  I guess there’s probably room to increase the vertical clearance by pushing the guards slightly further away from the wheels – but they are made of fairly flexible plastic and have plenty of give in them when moved by hand. I reckon its horizontal movement that makes the noise, there isn’t much clearance between the metal rods and the tyres.

    That’s likely it – guards are freer to move side to side. With my Tortecs though the stays feeding through the eyebolts effectively fix the guards vertically and horizontally as they’re always under tension. There’s very little side to side movement.

    September 27, 2017 at 1:52 pm #903135
    0
    kil0ran

    Mine (Tortec Reflectors) on

    Mine (Tortec Reflectors) on my Faran are absolutely silent at the moment.

    Frame has proper fixings in traditional places which may help with this – chainstay bridge, rear brake, fork crown plus eyelets at the bottom the forks.

    Every fixing is insulated with either a nylon or plastic washer and the threads are Loctite (blue stuff so semi-permanent hold)

    I run them pretty close to 32mm Gravelking SKs and the only noise they make even off road is lumps of gravel pinging off them. Completely silent on the road with very little flex (front has safety clips which offers a little movement).

    Early days but other than a spanner check after the first shakedown ride they’ve not needed adjustment.

    My old bike had M:Part Primoplastics and they rattled but the fixings were non-traditional – halfway up fork leg and at right angles, plus mudguard screwed into underside of fork crown. Guards themselves had metal stays feeding into plastic clips and a ton a flex in comparison. They’re weren’t super loud but were noticeable particularly over some concrete sections of my commute. Then again the whole bike (alu frame, carbon fork) was much noisier. I think a steel frame/fork makes a difference – its by far the quietest bike I’ve owned. Either that or its because I assembled it with TLC rather than being factory-built.

    September 27, 2017 at 1:27 pm #903133
    0
    sergius

    The frame has all the fixings

    The frame has all the fixings for the guards, no bodging required.  I guess there’s probably room to increase the vertical clearance by pushing the guards slightly further away from the wheels – but they are made of fairly flexible plastic and have plenty of give in them when moved by hand. I reckon its horizontal movement that makes the noise, there isn’t much clearance between the metal rods and the tyres.

    September 27, 2017 at 1:06 pm #903131
    0
    StraelGuy
    fenix wrote:
    Much more likely to get quieter guards on a proper winter frame. Bigger clearances. Less to hit. 

     

    Agreed, my steel winter bike has all the relevant fittings so the SKS guards are fully bolted on. Doesn’t rattle at all normally.

    September 27, 2017 at 1:02 pm #903129
    0
    fenix

    Much more likely to get

    Much more likely to get quieter guards on a proper winter frame. Bigger clearances. Less to hit. 

    September 27, 2017 at 12:58 pm #903127
    0
    John_S

    Also I meant to say I think

    Also I meant to say I think that it depends on both the type of mudguards and the bike as well as how they are fitted.

     

    For example if you have a pure road/race orientated bike which isn’t really intended for mudguards but you can get something that can be fitted on then they’re much more likely to be rattly because I don’t think that they’ll be a completely secure fitting.

     

    However if your bike is designed with mudguard use in mind and it has all the right braze ons allowing for mudguards to be securely fitted then that will help to reduce the chance of them being rattly.

     

    That being said I had some of the chromoplastic mudguards in the past and they were very rattly in comparison to my current Portland Design Works metal ones.

     

    Or maybe I’ve just been lukcy with the current guards on my bike.

     

     

     

    September 27, 2017 at 12:43 pm #903125
    0
    John_S

    I think that to some extent

    I think that to some extent it depends on how they’re fitted.  My bike was fitted with mudguards from the LBS that I bought it from but following a trip to a specific bike mechanic he took them off saying that they’d not been fitted correctly and he put them back on and they’re great.

     

    I’ve got the PDW Full Metal Fenders and I have to say that I don’t notice any rattle.

     

    https://ridepdw.com/collections/fenders/products/full-metal-fenders

     

    September 27, 2017 at 11:55 am #903123
    0
    Canyon48

    I think all mudguards have

    I think all mudguards have some rattle. I’ve been group riding with people who SKS raceblades, Crudguards and SKS Chromoplastics, I myself have MPart primoplastics. From previous experience, all these different have some sort of rattle or rub.

  • Author
    Replies
Viewing 8 replies - 16 through 23 (of 23 total)
1 2
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.