Cracked frame

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #28156
    buttensa

    Hi everyone – first time post so please be gentle. I wanted to know whether anyone has experience with cracked carbon frames and the time taken to get a response from the manufacturer on warranty?  It is a two year old bike that has been treated very well, essentially it is cracked on the seat tube and I have never seen a bike experience a crack in this location but wondered if anyone else has? See photo links below. 

    In terms of submitting a warranty claim, I have taken it to a local bike shop who have submitted a warranty claim on my behalf which happened about a month ago, I’ve been following up with them weekly and they’ve told me that it is a waiting game and there is no known timeframe for the manufacturer to get back to me even with a response. Given it has now been exactly one month since the claim has been submitted, I decided to contact the manufacturer directly and all they indicated was they need time to understand the situation – a month to understand the photos that were supplied seems like its stretching the friendship? They have not asked for additional photos or further information, or even to ship them frame to them – just silence. 

    Now to put this in context, I am a big fan of the brand of my bike and the bike itself, however not receiving any feedback at all for a month is making me question my allegiance to the brand. Is this normal as it has never happened to me in the past? 

     

    https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Sharing/n-HTFq5T/i-58nfjQQ/0/b997860e/X2/i-58nfjQQ-X2.jpg
    https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Sharing/n-HTFq5T/i-QZWSx6s/0/dbe548a6/X2/i-QZWSx6s-X2.jpg
    https://photos.smugmug.com/Sharing/Sharing/n-HTFq5T/i-Tkx9SWc/0/b48ddc94/X2/i-Tkx9SWc-X2.jpg

     

     

Viewing 6 replies - 16 through 21 (of 21 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #912771
    0
    Drinfinity

    My first mountain bike (GT

    My first mountain bike (GT Tequestra) had a similar , but bigger, crack in the same place, caused from the bottom of the seat post trying to escape through the seat tube. That was helped by a crash though. 

    I had a reinforcing sleeve welded on, and I kept riding for years more. 

    Anyway, the point I was making is it looks like the bottom of the seat post, and I think a warranty claim would be bounced on that basis. 

    #912769
    0
    alansmurphy

    The photos look like there

    The photos look like there was at least 3″ in the hole (steady)…

    #912767
    0
    kil0ran

    alansmurphy wrote:

    alansmurphy wrote:

    Really?

     

    Wouldn’t that mean most riders with a lot of seatpost showing would be risking the same?

     

    They’ve all got minimum insertion markings, and if you need to run a lot of post there’s always the option to run a 450mm post

    #912765
    0
    alansmurphy

    Really?

    Really?

     

    Wouldn’t that mean most riders with a lot of seatpost showing would be risking the same?

     

    #912763
    0
    Artem

    Looks like the reason is a

    Looks like the reason is a too short seatpost you used. It’s a very common mistake.

    #912761
    0
    iandusud

    That is very frustrating. You

    That is very frustrating. You might try contacting someone higher up in the company concerned as they are more likely to be concerned about any bad publicity this could bring as well as any good publicity a positive response could engender. 

Viewing 6 replies - 16 through 21 (of 21 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.