log in
register

Is a well specced Domane worth the cash?

  • Creator
    Topic
  • March 1, 2017 at 10:20 pm #26839
    barongreenback

    So having had my bike fit, it looks like I’m looking at a geometry that gives me a high stack and a short reach. The Trek Domane looks very nice indeed and at a push I could probably stretch to around £3k if it really is as good as the reviews would suggest (not yet decided on discs vs. rim brakes) Anyone with any experience of this range?  I would like to get good value but the online brands don’t seem suited to what I need.   At this price point 105 seems a bit stingy on the disc version although from the only review I can find online, Trek have gone with a fancier wheelset. 

     

    I know a fancy bike won’t really make me any faster but this is is a one in a lifetime treat to myself for recovering from cancer and getting fit again so would like to finalise a shortlist and get out on a test ride.  Thanks in advance!

  • Creator
    Topic
Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 19 total)
1 2
  • Author
    Replies
  • March 3, 2017 at 6:15 pm #888141
    0
    barongreenback
    gonedownhill wrote:
    Was gonna suggest the Rose Xeon CDX – £2400 for ultegra with hydraulic discs and sportive geometry, but the same size trek is both shorter reach and bigger stack so I reckon go with the Trek. 

    https://www.rosebikes.com/bike/rose-xeon-cdx-3000-disc-820921/aid:820952

     

    I have 105 and Ultegra on different bikes and think I would struggle to tell the difference in a blind test. Unless I was ungloved and it was cold as the metal levers on 105 are a bit chilly in winter!

     

    I looked at Rose as I like the fact you can customise like Ribble but yes, not quite as good a match. Certainly on rim brakes I struggle to tell the difference too.  Not tried the hydraulic disc versions but the 105 level levers look dreadful. 

    March 3, 2017 at 5:58 pm #888139
    0
    barongreenback

    Thanks Cugel. Yes, I would

    Thanks Cugel. Yes, I would have preferred a compromise as also a knackered set of carbon wheels is a lot pricier to replace than aluminium.   

    My problem is tight hamstrings. Despite physiotherapy they are still ridiculously tight hence the need to be a bit more upright. Having got my full report today, the Domane in a 62cm is the only bike we have found so far that gets beyond the standard 1.54-1.57 stack to reach ratio of many other endurance bikes. 

     

    March 3, 2017 at 5:23 pm #888137
    0
    Cugel

    I have two Domane bikes: one

    I have two Domane bikes: one set up as a light summer “racer” with calliper brakes and light HED wheels; the other set up as a winter bike with discs, a triple chainset (low gears) and mudguards.

    Both are a joy to ride – stiif for power transfer and steering down bumpy bendy roads but very compliant when sailing over scab-road and other nasty surfaces.

    Both have 28mm tyres on, although the disc version will take 32mm albeit mudguards then get a bit tight to fit. I have them both with short high rise stems, so that this with their already tall head tube has me quite upright, as I’m an old scrote now and can no longer adopt the racing position without neck & shoulder ache.

    However, comfort can also be achieved in the racing position if your vulnerable part is a lower back rather than a stiff neck, since the racing position puts more weight through your hands and less through your spine. At 40 summick years old you should be supple enough to adopt a racing position. (I’m 68).

    But if you like to ride more in touring or audax style, the Domane will suit. Different stems will allow a significant range of positions anyway; but you’ll always have it’s great power transfer allied with a lot of comfort, especially at the back end.

    ***

    Trek was guilty of selling good frames with decent groupsets but poor wheels, to meet a price point. With the £3000 105 version inclusive of fancy wheels I think they’ve gone to the other extreme. A £1600 pair of wheels on what should be a £2000 bike is a mismatch. £2000 for the same bike with much better wheels than the usual bottom-of-the-range Bontragers should be possible.

    Just a month or three ago you could buy a Domane 400 CF framed bike with Sora and TRP HY/RB discs for £850 in the sales. It’s one of the Domanes I have and I was very happy to pay £1300 for it. An £850 price would be reasonable just for the frameset, especially if you flogged off the Sora, TRP brakes and Bontrager wheels but kept the good quality stem, seatpost and bars. You could get some very good groupset & wheels for £2150!

    I put Shimano full hydraulic brakes on mine and it’s the best winter bike I’ve ever had (and I’ve had a few).

    Cugel.

    March 3, 2017 at 12:28 pm #888135
    0
    gonedownhill

    Was gonna suggest the Rose

    Was gonna suggest the Rose Xeon CDX – £2400 for ultegra with hydraulic discs and sportive geometry, but the same size trek is both shorter reach and bigger stack so I reckon go with the Trek. 

    https://www.rosebikes.com/bike/rose-xeon-cdx-3000-disc-820921/aid:820952

     

    I have 105 and Ultegra on different bikes and think I would struggle to tell the difference in a blind test. Unless I was ungloved and it was cold as the metal levers on 105 are a bit chilly in winter!

    March 3, 2017 at 8:17 am #888133
    0
    barongreenback
    Gasman Jim wrote:
    If you already have a winter bike with discs and guards then I’d say get the lightest raciest bike this time round and keep it for spring / summer use.

    I think that’s the way I’m thinking.  I’ll try the di2 to see whether that’s worth doing (on the Domane, it’s also a nice colour frame lol)

     

    Thanks again for all the advice and good wishes.

    March 2, 2017 at 10:24 pm #888131
    0
    Griff500

    A big part of any sport is

    A big part of any sport is psychology, and if you feel good, you do good. So in addition to the very real benefit of having a light, comfortable bike which transmits power effectively, you also receive a psychological boost. I looked closely at the Treks last year, predominantly Emonda, but eventually went for a Scott Addict Ultegra, which I love to bits. Part of the appeal was it struck the balance of having the pedigree of a major brand, but at least in my local area, not that common. I get a real buzz seeing it parked outside the cake shop in a long line of Defy’s! (Prepare to be flamed!). In the price range you are looking at, it is hard to find a bad bike. Its a question of which one floats your own particular boat.

    March 2, 2017 at 9:51 pm #888129
    0
    dunnoh

    I just got a Orbea with

    I just got a Orbea with Ultegra Di2 with discs for £1800.  I concur that having a fancy bike is amazing!

    March 2, 2017 at 8:03 pm #888127
    0
    Daveyraveygravey

    Another factor in my decision
    Another factor in my decision was looking at the rides I had done in the previous year. About 250 were around 2 hours – I ride to work 2-3 times a week and that was most of them. About 30 were around 4 hours and under 10 were all day, so I didn’t feel comfort should be a major factor

    March 2, 2017 at 7:03 pm #888125
    0
    Gasman Jim

    If you already have a winter

    If you already have a winter bike with discs and guards then I’d say get the lightest raciest bike this time round and keep it for spring / summer use.

    March 2, 2017 at 6:44 pm #888123
    0
    Luv2ride

    The disc version takes 32mm

    The disc version takes 32mm tyres, if that’s important to you? The rim brake version has less frame clearance.  I’d go SR6 if it were me, discs with the Vision Metron disc wheels.  Trek have recently hiked their prices though….

    March 2, 2017 at 5:44 pm #888121
    0
    barongreenback

    Thanks for the replies

    Thanks for the replies everyone. The geometry of the Domane seems to suit me best based on the slightly artificial setting of a bike fit but I also have the Roubaix on my list and the Focus Paralane reviewed yesterday adds something different into the mix. I’ve been cycling for over 10 years (pushing 40 now) and I’m looking for a bit of comfort, something lighter and something just a bit more flash than my aluminium Synapse that will become my winter bike.   I must admit rim brakes have never left me wanting more but the cable discs on my Synapse seem to do the job. As it’s a ‘best bike’ then I guess I can save it for dry days. If we get any!

    Time to sort out those test rides….

    March 2, 2017 at 5:29 pm #888119
    0
    katywu

    I’m a Domane 5.2 owner and

    I’m a Domane 5.2 owner and very happy with the bike.

    I did ride quite a few bikes before selecting the Domane, to be honest there wasn’t a great deal between them but I liked the look of the Domane and it certain felt comfortable to ride so that’s what I went with and happy with my LBS. No complaints 3 years later, I’ve upgraded the wheels but other than that all going well.

    As above create a shortlist and try and ride them and see what’s best for you.

    March 2, 2017 at 4:36 pm #888117
    0
    Johnnyvee

    The Treks seem very highly
    The Treks seem very highly regarded by my LBS every time I’m in there and they have good finishing kit.
    Test ride is essential and Evans, if there’s one nearby stock them. It may be that something a bit more or if the norm rides better…
    Best of luck in trying out and have fun on whatever you decide to get.

    March 2, 2017 at 4:09 pm #888115
    0
    Mungecrundle

    If you are asking if the Trek

    If you are asking if the Trek in that spec is a good bike, then from the professional reviews it would appear so. As to how it will make you feel, that is not something that any amount of forum opinion can truly tell you up front except to give you expectations which may or may not be realised.

    Is going faster what makes cycling fun for you? Do you enjoy going up hills, down hills, high speed cornering, long gentle trips in the sunshine with some sarnies in your pocket and a beer stop, or are you a masochist for bad weather? Do you like to be alone or in company? If so what sort of cycling are your mates into? Is the bike one of a selection only to be used for best or is it your daily commute and weekend warrior? Are you in the ascendant prime of your life or on the downhill side of your peak? Is the badge important or do you really not give a crap what others think of your choice? What are the route options where you live? Off road trails away from the traffic or are you road only? Are you planning some big adventure?

    So basically, from my vast experience of buying 1 second hand bicycle, 1 mountain bike and 1 high end road bike in the last 25 years, no help at all except in wishing you well on your remission. Must have been a shit time and I hope you have a great many summers of cycling to look forward to.

    March 2, 2017 at 4:00 pm #888113
    0
    VeloUSA

    Narrow your search down to

    Narrow your search down to three bikes. The only way to know which bike best fits your needs is too test ride each bike. Buy the one you like the most.

  • Author
    Replies
Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 19 total)
1 2
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.