N+1 Dilemma – update

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #26672
    tomsener

    Update – see comment below, option one is now out

    I’ve decided to take the plunge and go N+1, specifially getting a new winter bike. Buying a new best bike and relegating the current one (Pinarello FP Quattro Ultegra Di2) will be far too expensive so that option is out. That leaves me with 3 ways of getting the new steed, each with their own pros and cons.

    1) Buy a cheapish new bike such a BTwin 700AF for about £750, stick on some mud guards and I’m away.

    Pros – probably the cheapest option; quick to start riding

    Con – A bit boring; I would swap the wheels straight out for a spare set I have so seems like a waste of money on that component; don’t get to build anything

    2) Buy a cheap frame and build up a winter bike. Evans have a Cinelli Experience for £250, stick on a 105 set. I have old wheels, bars, stem, etc at home so that would cover most of the cost

    Pros – I really fancy having a go a building a bike; the frame looks lovely; makes use of bits I have hanging around

    Cons – It will take a while for me to build it; might mess it up, more expensive than opt 1

    3) Buy a different frame to opt 2. Take the 10sp Di2 off my current bike and put this on the new frame, add in the other components I already have and bingo, a lovely winter bike. I’d then buy 11sp Di2 for the best bike (wheels are compatable) and get the bonus of a nice upgrade on that one too.

    Pros – 11sp best bike; Di2 winter bike; get to do a build; makes the most of existing parts

    Cons – The most expensive option; Di2 winter bike (yes a pro and a con, not sure how it will last); not yet found a frame to do this on.

     

    Please tell me what to do, oh wise people of the internet.

Viewing 5 replies - 16 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #885329
    0
    barbarus

    That’s really good value. How
    That’s really good value. How stretched out do you find it? The other frame that’s interesting is the planet x galibier (really light), was on offer really cheap after Christmas but I bottled spending the cash…

    #885327
    0
    dottigirl

    Strange you should mention

    Strange you should mention Kinesis – I visit the outlet page ( http://outlet.upgradebikes.co.uk/Outlet/Kinesis-UK/Kinesis-UK-Range/Frames ) once a fortnight or so, to see if anything interesting crops up. The Aithein there appears to have gone though.

    I already have a T2 as my winter bike, which I love and ride to death, but I wanted something different so plumped for the CAAD8. Not ruling out a Crosslight as my hack/off-road bike, but, funds. 🙁

    (This is the CAAD8 btw. Proper bargain according to friends. Decent enough frameset to build up. https://www.rutlandcycling.com/323873/products/cannondale-caad8-claris-8-2016-road-bike-black.aspx )

    #885325
    0
    barbarus

    Can’t tell you what to do but

    Can’t tell you what to do but I’d be really curious as to what you decide.  I’ve got a heavy comfortable relaxed steel bike with guards and discs and I want a cheap agressive fast option for the summer.  I’ve also been looking at the cinelli and I’m sort of not bothered if it’s a bit harsh…  Also considering CAAD10, or maybe an aithein if I can afford it.  Something from kinesis might suit you? 

    #885323
    0
    dottigirl

    I was going to do 2), but

    I was going to do 2), but after a friend said the ride was likely to be harsh, I bought a CAAD8 instead and am building that up with Ultegra and EDCO wheels. 

    #885321
    0
    allanj

    2

    2

Viewing 5 replies - 16 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.