Scary spoke setup on a disc brake wheel?

  • This topic has 18 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 10 years ago by Welsh boy.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #25832
    davembk

    Call me a fusspot but wondered if anyone else has thought about this: Knowing that with disc brakes, it’s all down to the spokes, to carry the braking forces from the rotor/hub out to the rim, I took a look at my giant defy’s 20 spoke front disc brake wheel.  It’s radially spoked on the non rotor side and cross laced on the  rotor side. I feel sure that for disc braking, radial spokes are a just a little  bit better than a hairnet in a rainstorm, as all they’d do is have a vague and spongy effect. So on my wheel, of the 10 remaining, crossed laced spokes we’re down to just the 5 forward facing spokes that I can count on for braking. Ie with the bike in the garage, when I push the bike forwards against the brake, the forward spokes go up in pitch when played like a harp whereas the back facing spokes go down in pitch. So when I’m just about to brake on a nasty downhill, should I be scared, or am I just paranoid? For the record, the rear wheel has no radial spokes, and I’d argue, why for the sake of a few saved grams, weaken things with radials on the front, where to my mind the major braking forces are. All comments and reassurances highly appreciated!

Viewing 3 replies - 16 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #872805
    0
    CXR94Di2

    I would suggest you buy a

    I would suggest you buy a different wheel with more spokes or build one to your specifications to satisfy your worry.    There is no reason to have a concern when options are available

    #872803
    0
    crazy-legs

    In theory you can’t have a

    In theory you can’t have a radially-spoked drive side rear wheel because of the pedalling forces but I’ve seen it done plenty of times. You just need to use a specialh in that can transfer the stresses.

    It’ll be the same here, the wheel will work together as a unit rather than a couple of spokes.

    #872801
    0
    Mungecrundle

    Others may have heard

    Others may have heard different, but I am not aware of any reports of collapsing front wheels on disc brake equipped bikes. It’s not even on the standard list of make believe problems that the disc haters trot out every time there’s a discussion about them.

    Not to say that any wheel cannot fail under extreme circumstances or manufacturing defect, but basically you would be safe to assume that the physics is sound, that the design engineers understood what they were doing and that the manufacturer produced a safe wheel of good quality.

    Even if the wheel does collapse, you (or your next of kin) will be filthy rich from the product liability claim, so stop fretting.

Viewing 3 replies - 16 through 18 (of 18 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.