asthma in pro cycling

  • This topic has 29 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 11 years ago by crikey.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #24216
    daddyELVIS

    So, LottoNL-Jumbo have withdrawn from MPCC, upset that George Bennett and Theo Bos have both been prevented from starting races for having low cortisol levels. In both instances they say this was not due to the use of corticosteroids but due to asthma medication.

    So 2 questions – how can asthma be so prevalent at the pinnacle of pro sport? My hunch is the condition is faked to facilitate a TUE for performance-enhancing asthma meds.

    – how much are non-MPCC teams hammering corticosteroids, which apparently helps with weight-loss whilst maintaining the power to train like stink!

Viewing 14 replies - 16 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #849697
    0
    crikey

    I suppose, although I might
    I suppose, although I might be being super cynical, that the best indication of it being a performance enhancer is the fact that so many athletes seem to use it…

    #849695
    0
    fukawitribe

    crikey wrote:I think, and I’m

    crikey wrote:
    I think, and I’m not being patronising, that you’re looking in the wrong places…

    Quite possibly, although the studies i’ve looked at have been in a range of general and sports medical journals – quite how ‘reliable’ some of the are, I don’t know, but the message was consistent.

    [quote=crikey]Read here;

    http://www.steroidology.com/forum/anabolic-steroid-forum/54341-anabolic-albuterol.html%5B/quote%5D

    Tah.

    #849693
    0
    crikey

    I think, and I’m not being
    I think, and I’m not being patronising, that you’re looking in the wrong places…

    Read here;

    http://www.steroidology.com/forum/anabolic-steroid-forum/54341-anabolic-albuterol.html

    #849691
    0
    fukawitribe

    Well that’s just it – the
    Well that’s just it – the only results i’ve seen so far have come back with a distinct lack of ergogenic effects but i’m open to links to other studies and i’ll keep looking. So, if it’s not a PED at low dosage and not a PED at high (inhaled) levels, when / how does it produce a significant benefit ? Serious question, i’m not adverse to being educated – just lacking in the relevant information.

    #849689
    0
    crikey

    All three studies are looking
    All three studies are looking at acute administration of the drug, and are not looking for its documented ergogenic effects…
    …which is why people use it.

    Search for albuterol as well; the advantage salbutamol offers is a shorter half life and therefore a shorter glow time.

    It’s a PED.

    #849687
    0
    fukawitribe

    crikey wrote:Salbutamol is

    crikey wrote:
    Salbutamol is well known as a performance enhancing drug, not just as a bronchodilator.

    Like this ?..

    http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02425500

    The effect of salbutamol (S) on cycling performance was examined in 15 highly trained non-asthmatic male cyclists. A double-blind, randomized cross-over design was used with S or placebo (P) administered using a metered-dose inhaler and a spacer device 20 min before each testing session. The S dose was 400 μg (four puffs), which is twice the normal therapeutic level. Subjects were habituated to all the laboratory procedures in the week prior to actual data collection. The subjects performed four tests under S and P conditions on separate days over 2 weeks. These included measurement of maximal O2 uptake(V˙O2max) (cycle ergometry) with assessment of pulmonary function before and after, a submaximal (90% of ventilatory threshold) square-wave work transition from a base of unloaded cycling, a 60-s modified Wingate test, and a simulated 20 km time trial. No significant differences were observed in any of the dependent variables related to aerobic endurance or cycling performance between the S and P conditions. These results support other findings that an acute dose (400 μg) of S has no performance-enhancing properties.

    or this ?

    http://thorax.bmj.com/content/56/9/675.full

    CONCLUSIONS Inhaled salbutamol, even in a high dose, did not have a significant effect on endurance performance in non-asthmatic athletes, although the bronchodilating effect of the drug at the beginning of exercise may have improved respiratory adaptation. Our results do not preclude an ergogenic effect of β2 agonists given by other routes or for a longer period.

    or this ?

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21327796

    β2-Adrenergic receptor agonists are believed to present with ergogenic properties. However, how combined respiratory, cardiovascular and muscular effects of these drugs might affect exercise capacity remain incompletely understood. The effects of salbutamol were investigated in 23 healthy subjects. The study was randomised, placebo-controlled in double-blind and followed a cross-over design. Salbutamol was given at the dose of 10 μg/min in 11 subjects and 20 μg/min iv in the other 12 subjects. Measurements included muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA), ventilatory responses to hyperoxic hypercapnia (7% CO(2) in O(2,) central chemoreflex), isocapnic hypoxia (10% O(2) in N(2), peripheral chemoreflex) and isometric muscle contraction followed by a local circulatory arrest (metaboreflex), cardiopulmonary exercise test (CPET) variables and isokinetic muscle strength. Salbutamol 10 μg/min increased heart rate and blood pressure, while MSNA burst frequency remained unchanged. Peripheral chemosensitivity increased, as evidenced by an increased ventilatory response to hypoxia, but ventilatory responses to hypercapnia or muscle ischaemia remained unchanged. The effects of salbutamol 20 μg/min were similar. Both doses of salbutamol did not affect CPET. Only the higher dose of salbutamol decreased the anaerobic threshold, but this was not associated with a change in VO(2) max. Salbutamol increased the slopes of ventilation as a function of VO(2) (P < 0.05) and VCO(2) (P < 0.001) during CPET. Maximal isokinetic muscle strength was not affected by salbutamol. In conclusion, the acute administration of either low or high dose salbutamol does not affect exercise capacity in normal subjects, in spite of an earlier anaerobic threshold and increased chemosensitivity.

    ..and so on. The oral doses show some benefit in some studies – but that doesn’t appear to be the issue here. There may have been a reason behind WADA removing it from the list of prohibited substances.

    #849685
    0
    crikey

    Salbutamol is well known as a
    Salbutamol is well known as a performance enhancing drug, not just as a bronchodilator. The relationship to Clenbuterol is interesting too.

    Asthma diagnosis = a lot more wiggle room when levels are tested…

    As Professor Jim Royle has been known to remark ‘Asthma? My Arse…’

    #849683
    0
    turboprannet

    I thought the levels of
    I thought the levels of salbutamol were more indicative of using the tablet version as a weight loss drug more than the inhaled application which is of little benefit for non-asthmatics?

    #849681
    0
    Must be Mad

    Quote:Do asthma inhalers give

    Do asthma inhalers give non-asthmatics any sort of boost?

    Depends. Very much depends on the medication.

    One should remember that there is a huge variation in asthma cases, both in terms of cause and symptoms. For some people, they just get an occasional mild wheeze – for others it can be a life threatening and very debilitating condition.

    It is also a condition which you can grow into and out of over time.

    Part of the reason why so many people seem to have it these days (both in sport and in general public) is that the disease is much better understood now – and since inhalers have come on the scene, we have an effective way of treating it too (believe me, treatments prior to inhalers were boderline useless).

    As to the ‘performance enhancement’ effect – there are basically two types of inhalers – the most common kind as the ‘preventers’, designed to gently easy the airways and prevent future attacks – these will not give a performance boost.
    The other kind, prescribed for the more serious cases are the ‘relivers’. These are steroid inhalers, used to give the big boost to the airways for when you are really fighting for breath. These can give a boost, although modern inhalers are getting much better at targeting the boot to the airways rather to the rest of the body. Also, the dosage prescribed has a big difference here.

    From a personal experience perspective, I have been on some pretty hefty ‘relivers’ in my time, but several years ago now. Then the performance boost was VERY noticeable, but lasted no more that 10 minutes or so.

    For professional athletes – I think the key to remember is that this is a condition which can come and go. One aspect I think is releivent is that asthma does teach you to be very economical with your breathing. If you can recover from the asthma, then that experience of managing your breathing and your exertion when short of oxygen may be a big help in a sport where max V02 is so important. Froome for example – his ‘elbows out and head to the side’ style is exactly the sort of coping mechanism I use when I am fighting an asthma attack – so I defiantly believe he has a history of asthma

    #849679
    0
    Chris James

    Maybe doing high level sport
    Maybe doing high level sport makes it obvious to the athletes that they have asthma, rather than some fatty sitting in front of the TV who isn’t bothered that they are wheezing a bit?

    I was diagnosed with asthma after restarting cycling.

    Normal steroid inhalers and blue inhalers aren’t performance enhancing, which is why they are not on the banned list art normal usage levels. Obviously prednisone and the like are a different kettle of fish.

    #849677
    0
    nellybuck@msn.com

    farrell wrote:Do asthma

    farrell wrote:
    Do asthma inhalers give non-asthmatics any sort of boost?

    They’ve never made a jot of difference to me when I’ve tried.

    Assuming you’re referring to the reliever type inhalers such as Salbutamol (the blue inhalers you normally see asthma sufferers using while exercising), then no they don’t make any difference to non-sufferers. As the name suggests, they relieve the symptoms of asthma, so if you don’t have any symptoms, they don’t do anything.

    #849675
    0
    farrell

    Do asthma inhalers give
    Do asthma inhalers give non-asthmatics any sort of boost?

    They’ve never made a jot of difference to me when I’ve tried.

    #849673
    0
    fukawitribe

    Another question – how can
    Another question – how can abrasion injuries be so prevalent at the pinnacle of pro sport? My hunch is the condition is faked to facilitate a TUE for performance-enhancing graze meds.

    Their BMI and resting heart rates are anomalously low too – probably more drugs..

    (in all seriousness, while there’s almost certainly an amount of, shall we say ‘over-exaggerated’, asthma conditions in the pro-peloton and elsewhere, beware of extending the comparison of the rate in the population in general too far)

    #849671
    0
    CXR94Di2

    I couldn’t comment on pro
    I couldn’t comment on pro stats, but the general population has around 8% of children and adults suffer from asthma

Viewing 14 replies - 16 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.