Castelli or Gore ?????????

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #20363
    Stumps

    There has been a couple of articles already about jackets – windproof and waterproof.

    What i need some advice on is whether to go for a Castelli or Gore jacket. I’m getting some money for Christmas and my birthday so i’m going to splash out on a new jacket and cant decide which one to go for. I’ll probably have about £160.00 to spend.

    I already have an Altura waterproof so do i stick with that for rainy days although its not very packable and just get a windproof one ?

Viewing 14 replies - 16 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #766155
    0
    pirnie

    Sportful Survival has got to
    Sportful Survival has got to be worth a mention in my opinion. Great Gore-Tex jacket, has kept me warm and dry in some atrocious weather recently. Within budget at the moment too.

    #766153
    0
    mrmo

    William Black wrote:Castelli

    William Black wrote:
    Castelli direct from china. Nothing ostracises you quite like rocking up to a club run wearing pretty much the same piece of kit as some mamil and letting them know it cost best part of a tenner.

    Castelli, china….. mine says made in Croatia.

    #766151
    0
    William Black

    Castelli direct from china.
    Castelli direct from china. Nothing ostracises you quite like rocking up to a club run wearing pretty much the same piece of kit as some mamil and letting them know it cost best part of a tenner.

    I got a gore windstopper at a race one year, to be honest it has stayed tightly squashed into a water bottle most of the year, but when the weather really does turn south and it has to come out it stands up to the rain admirably.

    Have to say though I find I cook to death wearing ‘jackets’ much prefer LS Roubaix(TM) type jerseys through winter

    #766149
    0
    edd23

    i’ve got a Xenon 2.0
    i’ve got a Xenon 2.0 Windstopper Soft Shell Jacket and it is a fantastic bit of kit, wear it in autumn & spring just with a base layer underneath and in winter on rides when the temperature is below freezing I just add another layer underneath.

    In my experience Gore stuff is better quality and better made than Castelli…

    #766147
    0
    Colin Peyresourde

    Castelli all day, everyday.
    Castelli all day, everyday. Nothing says ‘commuter’ and ‘I heart Evans’ like Gore.

    #766145
    0
    paulfg42

    Not tried Castelli but have
    Not tried Castelli but have had a Gore windstopper for 3 years now and it’s been great. Decent fit, rain resistant and with a long sleeved base layer is very effective in the windiest of weather.

    #766143
    0
    racingcondor

    If you’re looking for race
    If you’re looking for race fit then Castelli without a doubt. Gore make great kit but personally I’m less convinced by some of the tailoring.

    I’d try on both and see though, like I say quality wise Gore is very good stuff.

    Sportful are well worth a look if Castelli isn’t quite your shape. Love the look of their kit and I don’t doubt it’s good but I just didn’t fit into it as well.

    #766141
    0
    Scowel

    I’ve got the Gore Xenon 2.0
    I’ve got the Gore Xenon 2.0 winstopper and it’s brilliant. Has taken loads of abuse from about January this year and still going strong. Lots of ventilation options but warm when you need it, even when wet. The Castelli stuff is pretty though…

    #766139
    0
    Raleigh

    Castelli every time.
    The dhb

    Castelli every time.

    The dhb one is very good though.

    And I have one from CREW ROOM – which is actually a rowing brand. It’s like a drysuit.

    #766137
    0
    AWP

    I have both a Castelli
    I have both a Castelli Elemento 7x and a Gore Xenon 2.0 SO Softshell in hi-viz that I use for commuting. Both are excellent. With your budget I’d go for the Gore just make sure you get the right size; it needs to be snug. Neither are totally waterproof (the Castelli hardly at all) but I’ve never really needed an additional waterproof with the Gore. It’s quite similar to a Gabba in some respects. There’s a few online shops that do the Gore at sub £150.

    #766135
    0
    David Arthur @davearthur

    Depends what you want and
    Depends what you want and need from a jacket. If you’ve already got a waterproof jacket, then a good softshell jacket could be the best option. They’re toasty warm, keep the wind out and are pretty good in light rain too, and really versatile – it’s rarely cold enough that a softshell won’t cope. You can easily stuff a few more layers underneath or over the top to adapt

    My softshell jackets get a LOT more use than any other my hardshell or waterproof jackets. They’re perfect for UK riding. With your budget you’ve got quite a large choice as well. Worth checking out available online discounts, can often get some good deals

    #766133
    0
    Mr Jono

    Gore power active shell.
    Gore power active shell. Amazing jacket and well within budget

    #766131
    0
    oddbydefault

    Rapha Wind Jacket. It’s
    Rapha Wind Jacket. It’s really got to be thrown into the mix because it’s within budget – £170, and is one of the best performing jackets I’ve come across.

    Very lightweight, packs down very small, is wonderfully breathable and extremely comfortable – Can be used for three seasons. It’s water resistant, and dries super quick too.

    Either way, I would suggest getting windproof over waterproof – much more versatile.

    #766129
    0
    mooleur

    Can’t comment on mens stuff
    Can’t comment on mens stuff but from a bird’s perspective the castelli jackets are certainly among the best out there at the moment. Well tailored as well as being incredibly light. If I had a bit of cash to splash I’d go with one of them!

    Check out Sportful while you’re there as well by the way, they’re the more “sensible” version of Castelli, same company & same factory, you might get more bang for your buck whilst not sacrificing style.

Viewing 14 replies - 16 through 29 (of 29 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.