Sock game

One leg over, one leg under; make a statement, you know it's the way to go 

Under, always under.

I've always worn socks underneath my longs - but whatever works for you.

Its almost overshoe time anyway so it wont matter !

BAN THIS SICK FILTH!!!!!

I'm with you dottigirl

https://www.instagram.com/p/BL3YKSrj3xM

look fine to me and Im not getting the witchy vibe from them, stripey socks are cool  Id probably wear socks over too as Im not mad keen on stirrupy type tights for comfort or that they look odder with the socks under but thats just me., but actually Im more surprised the cycling fashion police havent frothed more about  navy tights

I hate stirrup type tights. Best to cut them off...or not have them in the first place. As for socks over or under...if you want people to see them - over...if not - under.
I'd hope people aren't actually judging a cyclist by how they display their socks.(but then, isn't the cycling fraternity/sorority one of the most snobbish judgemental cliques going....)

socks > stirrups

Anyway it's coming up to Halloween so don't worry about the witchiness!

Both ways work, depends how you pull it off. Always find white socks under tights look a tad goofy for example. Patterned socks over the top bit more hip, usually. Black and black, best under, nice and elegant/classic looking. 

Too witchy? Guess that depends on whether your skid lid is conical, and your frame is made from broom handles.

Seriously though, looks fine.

looks fine. If you wore them under you'd see the stirrup. If you have nice socks you may as well show them. Mine are mostly hidden under shoe covers......

I always wear mine under , but don't ask me why

the only time I wore socks over my trousers/ jeans was down to them catching in the chainset