Split Commute: 2 bikes or a folding bike

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #24802
    stevenagesteve

    I’ve got a two mile trip to the station, then a six mile trip from Kings Cross to my office.

    Planing to start doing the non-train bits by bike now that I don’t have to drop the kids off at nursery on the way.

    Can’t work out if I’d be better using one folding bike for the whole journey or parking a dedicated bike at Kings Cross.

    Folding:

    – Quicker on to the train at each end
    – More secure
    – Can maintain at home
    – Have to handle on the train
    – Slower and less fun on the road

    Dedicated Bike at Kings Cross:

    – Significantly less secure (have secure parking at work but not so confident about Kings Cross)
    – Slower on to the train as need to lock up
    – Need to maintain at work most of the time
    – Quicker and more fun on the road

    Any got any experience of this or recommendations?

    Thanks in advance.

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Replies
  • #859751
    0
    drphiliplee

    I have a two mile Crouch End
    I have a two mile Crouch End to Finsbury Park, then Victoria to Chelsea option and have opted for two bikes, with aa steel single speed that’s cheap and fun to bomb around in at the town end. So far so good, I have a lot of hills / dirt path in the home end which Brompton might find challenging, and tbh I’ve had no problem with the single speed in town at all.

    Although this morning I did think someone has nicked it until I arrived at work to realise I was too lazy to ride it on Friday and left it there all long weekend :S

    #859749
    0
    swerider

    What about the Canadian
    What about the Canadian folders there are/were on Kickstarter?

    Could they be an option for you? They sure look promising, at least on the staged photos…

    #859747
    0
    Bikebikebike

    I ride a Brompton all the
    I ride a Brompton all the time, and it’s great. Small handlebars also are good in London traffic.

    Having a folder is handy in other situations too.

    #859745
    0
    Shades

    I got a folder in a ‘knee
    I got a folder in a ‘knee jerk’ moment but it’s proven very useful, not just with train travel. It’s a Mezzo D9 and I’ve just managed to squeeze a bigger cassette on it (9 sp Tiagra Short Cage) which has given me a lower gear for hills. I still like the Brompton though!

    #859743
    0
    PompeyVin

    Do you have to go all hte way
    Do you have to go all hte way in to KGX?
    I commute from St Neots to Finsbury Park every day, 1 stop before Kings Cross. I opted for a cheap folder to do both ends (slower but not a huge difference, about 5 mins on the 3-4 mile journeys), but did consider the very secure bike parking at Finsbury Park – may be worth checking it out as a potential overnight lock up.

    #859741
    0
    Matt eaton

    A word of warning: check with
    A word of warning: check with your train company on their folding bike policy. FGW only recognise folders with wheel sizes up to 18 inches which gives very limited choices other than Brompton. Folders with larger wheels are treated as normal bikes (under strict policy at least). In practice I suspect a 20″ will be OK but anything bigger might draw attention.

    #859739
    0
    Jem PT

    I have a 1.5 mile ride to the
    I have a 1.5 mile ride to the station followed by a 7.2 mile ride from Waterloo. Definitely a Brompton is the way to go. Yes, they’re not cheap but you get what you pay for and they hold their value really well if your plans change (check out what they go for on eBay). For me the purchase price was repaid by not paying for the tube in 1 year, so from then on I’m getting a free ride.

    Yes they’re a slightly more exhausting ride – but I look on that as extra ‘training’ per mile! I could ride from Victoria which would be a shorter ride to my office, but deliberately choose the longer route from Waterloo which says it all really!

    #859737
    0
    farrell

    stevenagesteve wrote:Thanks

    stevenagesteve wrote:
    Thanks for all the comments. I’ll have to road test some folding bikes – everyone raves about Brompton’s but they are pricey. Might also try out the Montague Urban (which appeals as I’m 6’4″) and one of the Tern’s.

    Is there a Brompton Dock anywhere along your route or near home? If so you could hire one for 24 hours for about a fiver and give it a good extended test ride and see if that sways you one way or the other.

    #859735
    0
    Matt eaton

    +1 for a folder.
    The idea of

    +1 for a folder.

    The idea of having to stay late at work to maintain/service/repair a bike that never comes home would be enough to persuade me.

    #859733
    0
    arfa

    Bromptons are expensive but
    Bromptons are expensive but they avoid the old adage of “buy badly, buy twice” (which I have done). The design is streets ahead of the competition for durability and ride.
    Have a shop around as a number of vendors are doing monthly instalments so you can set off tube fares saved/train station parking and the pay back comes rapidly.
    You will need one with the extended seat post due to your height.
    The Brompton website is doing a competition giving a bike away every week if you want to have a go ?

    #859731
    0
    stevenagesteve

    Thanks for all the comments.
    Thanks for all the comments. I’ll have to road test some folding bikes – everyone raves about Brompton’s but they are pricey. Might also try out the Montague Urban (which appeals as I’m 6’4″) and one of the Tern’s.

    #859729
    0
    davecochrane

    Definitely a Brompton – you
    Definitely a Brompton – you will never regret investing in one.

    #859727
    0
    arfa

    Without any shadow of doubt,
    Without any shadow of doubt, get a Brompton s type with 3 or 6 gears. Fast, the best folding design and you will have no problem keeping up with roadies in town. I once had a dahon and the folding hinge on the bike broke when I hit a pothole and i’do argue having the hinge in the middle of the bike is a serious design flaw.
    Bromptons are also surprisingly stable at speed as I have hit 40mph + downhill and there was no wobble at all.

    #859725
    0
    Colin Peyresourde

    Locking up a decent bike is
    Locking up a decent bike is London is asking for disappointment. Take the folder and you take it everywhere…..get one with drop handlebars for speed….

    A lock up bike won’t be any more fun if it is stolen or so crap no one will steal it.

    #859723
    0
    Mombee

    Go and take a Brompton for a
    Go and take a Brompton for a spin… or one of the other higher-end folders… when I’ve tried them at the cycle show, I’ve always been suprised by how well sorted they’ve felt… and not at all weird to cycle.

Viewing 15 replies - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.