Saddle opinions

by andylul   July 19, 2012  

Budget of £70-90 (ish)

Selle Italia
Selle San Marco

Have a Selle C2 at the moment and it's great, but recently acquired a new bike and cannot keep swapping it over. The CSN saddle I got with the bike wrecked my gentleman's vegetables...


or Concor

Ready - set - GO!

11 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

ride test saddles, any shop, or for that matter saddle maker,worth their salt will have test saddles. I ride fi'zi:k but you have just asked the "how long is a piece of string" question Wink

posted by 37monkey [143 posts]
19th July 2012 - 23:41


Could agree with 37monkey more. I spent all of May testing saddles, personally I couldn't get on with the fi'zi:k, and preferred a sella italia (but not the one I initially liked the look of online).
The choice of saddle is a very personal decision and it depends on your backside, not clever marketing, sponsered cycling team or an online review.
I hope you find yourself something comfortable.

posted by darranjoseph [15 posts]
20th July 2012 - 7:48

1 Like

I know it's an emotive subject - always felt more comfortable on a saddle with a cut out, and the Selle Italia I have is more or less perfect (if a little tatty)

New best bike demands a new perch, though - I guess I'm going shopping for a Flite Smile

Thanks all

andylul's picture

posted by andylul [416 posts]
20th July 2012 - 8:37


I went for a Specialized Toupe, very light and comfy(ish). Some shops have a bum measuring pad to find the width of your sit bones, so if you can find one of those, give it a go.

posted by bashthebox [663 posts]
20th July 2012 - 8:41


I'm currently on an Arione but I've found it does make the plums go numb. I've just bought a Toupe (saddle that is, rather than unconvincing hairpiece) for the perineal cut-out so that should improve things. As bashthebox says, definitely have your sit-bones measured so you don't end up with something too narrow or too wide for you. Also, as darranjoseph says, what works for one person will not necessarily work for you so try as many as you can until you find something comfortable.

posted by Sadly Biggins [266 posts]
20th July 2012 - 9:18

1 Like

According to the bike fit session I had last week, it's all about bar/hood angle rather than specific saddle type. I was fitted to an Arione which I'm getting on great with now (though I didn't with a dodgy bar setup a while back). I used to like Specialized Toupe's but I kept breaking them (and I know others who find the same).

posted by MattT53 [131 posts]
20th July 2012 - 9:54


I looked at the romin on my tarmac and thought not sure I will get on with that but its been fine tbh.

posted by Super Domestique [1655 posts]
20th July 2012 - 12:05


Should've gone Arione

Sir Velo

Raleigh's picture

posted by Raleigh [1734 posts]
20th July 2012 - 20:38


My Selle San Marco Ponza serves well, but only ever tried it with my bibs and VERY comfortable Nalini chamois. I could have been duped.

Don't buy upgrades. Ride up grades. (Merckx)

obutterwick's picture

posted by obutterwick [537 posts]
22nd July 2012 - 21:03


What's wrong with buying another C2? If you know it fits you, and it's inside your budget? Or am I missing something?

posted by robdaykin [161 posts]
22nd July 2012 - 21:57


C2 did fine on my Blue Bike, but needed something a bit more bling for my new Stealth Smile

andylul's picture

posted by andylul [416 posts]
23rd July 2012 - 14:34