Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Petition launched to cancel Velo Birmingham

Organisers counter concerns by pointing out all road closures are approved by the emergency services

A petition has been launched asking Birmingham, Solihull and Coventry Councils to refuse permission for the 2020 edition of Vélo Birmingham and “do something better” instead.

The petition has been set up by 48-year-old Lewis Edwards, who lives in Meriden near Coventry city centre.

Explaining his reasoning to the Coventry Telegraph, he said: "The reason for the petition is that when the event happened last year, the roads near where I lived were completely blocked off.

"Living in Meriden, there is only one road that goes through the centre of the village. We are used to roads closing for an hour or so for genuine charity events like fun runs, remembrance services and the OVO, but the bike ride means that we are stuck in our own homes for majority of the day, with restrictions being put on people’s movement from 11pm. I live in a cul-de-sac so there is no way of getting out."

Velo Birmingham organisers CSM Active have often come under pressure from local residents regarding road closures.

The 2017 edition was re-routed following opposition in Worcestershire, while late changes to this year’s route were branded “unforgiveable” by one local councillor.

Edwards continued: "I am all for raising money for charity and I have nothing against cyclists, being a cyclist myself, but I really feel as though the residents have not been considered and that the issues raised should be taken seriously, with proper consultation and sensible consideration of the health and wellbeing of people who live on the route who have no exit or entrance to their own homes.

"With many elderly residents in the area, many home visits to drop off medication, food and hydration could not take place or were seriously delayed, with stewards blocking carers and visitors on the day."

Responding to Edwards’ petition, a spokesman for Vélo Birmingham was keen to talk up the positive impact of the event and pointed out that all road closures are approved in advance by the emergency services.

"Given the necessary road closures that are in place on the day – all of which are signed off at the Safety Advisory Group by all stakeholders and the Emergency Services – we accept that a small minority do not support Vélo Birmingham & Midlands.

"We invest a great deal of time and effort to minimise as much as possible the impact on local residents and businesses.  Along with our partners at Birmingham, Coventry, Sandwell, Warwickshire, Dudley and Solihull Councils, we strongly believe that the event delivers a significant net benefit to the region in terms of profile, economic impact, health and well-being, the environment and charity fundraising.

"The fact that the West Midlands plays host to the second biggest cycling event in the UK is something to be incredibly proud of and we will continue working hard to make Vélo Birmingham & Midlands an event that everyone can enjoy and benefit from.

"If anyone has any questions about the 2020 event, we encourage them to reach out to our dedicated route team by emailing route [at] velobirmingham.com ."

At the time of writing, the petition had attracted 680 signatures.

Alex has written for more cricket publications than the rest of the road.cc team combined. Despite the apparent evidence of this picture, he doesn't especially like cake.

Add new comment

25 comments

Avatar
Organon | 4 years ago
0 likes

Oh dear, and I was thinking about doing this as an altenative to Ride London for a change. Guess all the cycling is cancelled, for good this time, thanks Lewis.

Avatar
levermonkey | 4 years ago
2 likes

No problem whatsoever. Cancel it, that's fine.

I'll just get a petition up that bans anyone living within those councils from running in the London Marathon or taking part in any other closed road event in the country.

After all, whats good for the goose...

Avatar
quiff | 4 years ago
4 likes

Lewis mate, just to give you fair warning, the Commonwealth Games are going to be in your neck of the woods in 2022, and I've heard that none of the competitors are even raising money for charity! Better get petitioning so you can submit it in good time.

Avatar
Rapha Nadal | 4 years ago
7 likes

Is the old "I'm not against cyclists, I'm one myself" the new "I'm not racist as my best friend is black"?

Avatar
alansmurphy | 4 years ago
3 likes

Not all, but most certainly the vast majority and almost always the 'appointed' spokesperson. How many drugs are really administered on the weekends? How many people are actually affected in a medical capacity? 1, 2, 10,000? There is ways of contacting the organisers to address the issues rather than one NIMBY guessing at a problem and over-reacting just because he can't be arsed to drive the half mile to his local to get smashed and drive home!

Furthermore, all of these elderly people will have benefited in some way from the charities represented. Perhaps if all charity events that inconvenienced a single NIMBY were to be cancelled then there would be less elderly people affected as they'd already be dead!

Avatar
TheBillder | 4 years ago
4 likes

Also need to bear in mind that some care workers are not paid for travel time between patients (utterly evil but it happens). Closed roads for sportives are a lovely thing to have and in the aggregate seem quite a small imposition, but I can see that for some it comes with a higher cost. As an outgroup we probably ought not to assume that objectors are all red-faced nimbies who won't be able to get the Rover out to go for a Sunday roast at a Harvester, even if some may be.

Avatar
ktache | 4 years ago
2 likes

He could organise a street party in the cul de sac, games for the local children.

But then they might like the freedom from the tyranny of the motor vehicle a bit too much...

Avatar
AlsoSomniloquism | 4 years ago
1 like

Also where did he get the from 11pm road closures from?

This link, although 5 months early, was still pretty valid on times and his specific area was 07:15 to 14:45.

Avatar
Accessibility f... replied to AlsoSomniloquism | 4 years ago
1 like

AlsoSomniloquism wrote:

Also where did he get the from 11pm road closures from?

This link, although 5 months early, was still pretty valid on times and his specific area was 07:15 to 14:45.

 

That's probably when any cars have to be shifted off the route.

I liked this quote:

> "I live in a cul-de-sac so there is no way of getting out."

Other than using your legs and walking, you fucking stupid lazy bastard.

Avatar
yupiteru | 4 years ago
0 likes

Lewis Edwards is obviously scared that if he is stuck in all day he will be forced to embark upon binge masterbation.

  Nothing worse than friction burns on your column and I feel very sorry for him.

Avatar
ktache | 4 years ago
1 like

But vermonter, they are evil cyclists, scourge of our streets.

Avatar
The_Vermonter replied to ktache | 4 years ago
2 likes

ktache wrote:

But vermonter, they are evil cyclists, scourge of our streets.

 

You got me there. Cyclists are worse than the Mongols.  Both the Khans and the motorcycle gang.

Avatar
The_Vermonter | 4 years ago
3 likes

At the risk of sounding slightly elitist, I will never understand why people would not want a group of people who are willing to spend thousands of Pounds on a bicycle(s), riding through the area and spending money in their shops, hotels, restaurants, bars, etc. They have disposable income and have come to your part of the world! 

Avatar
AlsoSomniloquism replied to The_Vermonter | 4 years ago
1 like

The_Vermonter wrote:

At the risk of sounding slightly elitist, I will never understand why people would not want a group of people who are willing to spend thousands of Pounds on a bicycle(s), riding through the area and spending money in their shops, hotels, restaurants, bars, etc. They have disposable income and have come to your part of the world! 

 

TBF, only a fraction of the 17000 would have stopped when passing through Meriden (Home to the Cyclists War Memorial) on the day so not much extra spent apart from side supporters.

Avatar
HarryTrauts replied to AlsoSomniloquism | 4 years ago
3 likes

AlsoSomniloquism wrote:

The_Vermonter wrote:

At the risk of sounding slightly elitist, I will never understand why people would not want a group of people who are willing to spend thousands of Pounds on a bicycle(s), riding through the area and spending money in their shops, hotels, restaurants, bars, etc. They have disposable income and have come to your part of the world! 

 

TBF, only a fraction of the 17000 would have stopped when passing through Meriden (Home to the Cyclists War Memorial) on the day so not much extra spent apart from side supporters.

 

There were loads of people out cheering us on in Meriden.  Most seemed to be drinking and eating.  I imagine the Spar did quite a bit of extra trade that day.

Avatar
Awavey replied to AlsoSomniloquism | 4 years ago
1 like

AlsoSomniloquism wrote:

The_Vermonter wrote:

At the risk of sounding slightly elitist, I will never understand why people would not want a group of people who are willing to spend thousands of Pounds on a bicycle(s), riding through the area and spending money in their shops, hotels, restaurants, bars, etc. They have disposable income and have come to your part of the world! 

 

TBF, only a fraction of the 17000 would have stopped when passing through Meriden (Home to the Cyclists War Memorial) on the day so not much extra spent apart from side supporters.

stopped during the actual ride event maybe so, but some of those riders would have been in the area the day/night before & after, staying in places there, eating food there, visiting. Maybe some of them having ridden through the place would have thought I never knew there was a place like this so close to Birmingham/Coventry, its hard not to imagine the area is just urban industrial sprawl and the M6, maybe theyll choose to come back and visit Shakespeare county and have more rides on those roads.

Avatar
growingvegtables | 4 years ago
4 likes

Eeeeh - the things middle-aged men will say in their campaign to get elected to Meriden Parish Council.  Anything to hide the fact that their waistband measurement is somewhat larger than their IQ measure.

 

Ach - I'm getting cynical in my old age  3

Avatar
mrchrispy | 4 years ago
8 likes

apparently they come around the night before, strip the house of any food and leave the home owners trussed up in the living room for 24hours. its very barbaric. 

Avatar
hkrpk replied to mrchrispy | 4 years ago
3 likes

mrchrispy wrote:

apparently they come around the night before, strip the house of any food and leave the home owners trussed up in the living room for 24hours. its very barbaric. 

Wait until you get involved in the logistic challenge of caring for a relative utterly reliant on home visits.  There's a mass of vulnerable people dependent on care workers or relatives making the journey to their home each day to do essential tasks.   Don't underestimate the frustration a day's road closure can cause someone in this instance.   

Avatar
muhasib | 4 years ago
5 likes

"many home visits to drop off medication, food and hydration could not take place or were seriously delayed,"

I didn't realise the event meant that the mains water was stopped?

Avatar
srchar replied to muhasib | 4 years ago
8 likes

muhasib wrote:

"many home visits to drop off medication, food and hydration could not take place or were seriously delayed," I didn't realise the event meant that the mains water was stopped?

Indeed it is. Residents are also banned from possession of foodstuffs that don't perish within the day and it's forbidden for doctors to prescribe more than 24 hours supply of any medicine.

Avatar
hkrpk replied to muhasib | 4 years ago
0 likes

 At some stage you may have care responsibilities which cover ensuring the person you need to call on is adequately hydrated.  Nobody is dropping off water but there's plenty of carers each day travelling from home to home making sure the vulnerable remain, amongst other things, hydrated.

Avatar
AlsoSomniloquism | 4 years ago
3 likes

Road closed for a fun run for only an hour. Really how many competitors are doing it then? 10? 50? 100? How much is raised for charity by that small fun run being it is a real charity event and not like the Velo which apparently isn't. (Also the OVO raises how much for charity?)

I do actually have sympathy for people on the routes and when riding along with the crowds I thank them regularly along the route due to inconvenience. But the reasons for the long notice on these road closures is for residents to discuss needs and / or plan to be as least disrupted as possible. 

I'm pretty sure that affected residents are asked about special needs, visits etc and these are accommodated on the day. (Although someone mentioned about a home nurse being delayed recently but it did sound like she wanted to literally park outside the patients house rather then elsewhere and walk). 

Anyway, another 9 months of this to come again I'm sure. 

 

 

 

Avatar
Sevenfold | 4 years ago
5 likes

Of course "being a cyclist myself", why doesn't he get his bike out of starage & take part?

Avatar
Zebulebu | 4 years ago
13 likes

I'm a cyclist too! (staring at BSO stored lovingly in shed under bags of peat moss and gardening tools - last used prior to the invention of CDs)

I'm all for these charity events (provided they inconvenience other people and not me)

But they leave me as a prisoner in my own home (because I haven't used my legs to walk anywhere further than 100 yards away since I was in short trousers - what do you think I am, some car-less oik?)

That about cover it?

Latest Comments