Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Mike Hall's partner criticises "flawed investigation" by Australian police into his death

Anna Haslock says inquest, which ended today, leaves "many unanswered questions"...

Anna Haslock, the partner of ultracyclist Mike Hall who was killed when he was hit from behind by a motorist near Canberra in March last year, has strongly criticised the Australian Federal Police for its “flawed investigation” of his death.

She made her comments in a message posted to the website of Cycle, Australia’s national cycling campaign group, which has been providing detailed coverage of the inquest into Hall’s death, which closed today.

The 35-year-old had been competing in the inaugural Indian Pacific Wheel Race when he was killed at around 6.20am on 31 March last year.

Haslock, who raised money through crowdfunding to be able to attend the inquest in Canberra, wrote: "The three-day hearing of the inquest into the road traffic collision that killed Mike Hall has closed, and yet we are left with many questions remaining unanswered.”

She said she was “deeply disappointed” with the AFP for its “poor handling of the case and their flawed investigation, including:

“A police reconstruction that failed to test several important elements of Mike’s visibility system.

“The AFP failing to retain vital evidence such as Mike’s clothing.

“The AFP failing to seize the driver's phone at the time of the incident. By his own admission, the driver was distracted, and we have been unable to eliminate the phone as that distraction.”

“Mike had every right to be cycling on the road at the time,” she continued. “He was well lit and riding safely. He had every right to assume that the car approaching him from behind would pass him safely and according to the law.

“I attended the Court with a clear mandate from those who supported me via the Just Giving fund to bear witness and to ask questions where and when I was able to. I did this to the best of my ability with the support of local and national cycling organisations. I will now be considering my options and getting further legal advice.”

Shegu Bobb, the motorist who hit Hall from behind, was excused from giving evidence at the inquest after notes to police interviews described him as a “suggestible” witness, reports the Canberra Times.

Coroner Bernadette Boss acknowledged that "The quality of his evidence would be very poor."

Bobb, aged 19 at the time, had been driving at the speed limit of 100 kilometres an hour on the Monora Highway when he hit Hall, killing him instantly and leaving his bike impaled in the bonnet of his car.

Witnesses said that after the fatal collision, Bobb had his phone on his lap and had dialled the emergency number 000 but was unable to speak due to shock. He has faced no charges in connection with Hall’s death.

As with the previous two days of the hearing, there were conflicting reports from different witnesses as to how visible Hall and his bike were on the morning of his death.

A police reconstruction suggested that  his bike would have been difficult to see at night, although video footage played at the inquest of Hall riding showed otherwise.

The coroner’s findings are due to be published early next year,

“The Coroner paid her respects to Mike as an impressive individual who could have gone on to achieve many more great things,” Haslock added. “Her words were a comfort, but the unfortunate reality is that the community of Mike's loved ones, friends and peers are left with many unanswered questions."

Simon joined road.cc as news editor in 2009 and is now the site’s community editor, acting as a link between the team producing the content and our readers. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, he has reported on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, the latest developments in the bike industry and the sport’s biggest races. Now back in London full-time after 15 years living in Oxford and Cambridge, he loves cycling along the Thames but misses having his former riding buddy, Elodie the miniature schnauzer, in the basket in front of him.

Add new comment

13 comments

Avatar
Jimmy Ray Will | 5 years ago
0 likes

Echoing my sentiments from the other day... why are prosecutors so utterly incompetent? 

However, this was an inquest so not the same, but it should be obvious for all to see that there was an agenda being pushed from the police from day one...

I can see the argument though... "foreigner comes over here, does some stupid race, riding about in the middle of the night like some form of ninja... why should one of our own be punished by something that was totally avoidable if this foreigner wasn't being so weird?"

Blah blah blah.

Avatar
Sakurashinmachi replied to Jimmy Ray Will | 5 years ago
0 likes

Jimmy Ray Will wrote:

Echoing my sentiments from the other day... why are prosecutors so utterly incompetent? 

However, this was an inquest so not the same, but it should be obvious for all to see that there was an agenda being pushed from the police from day one...

As you say, it's a Coronial inquest - so no prosecution, no defence, no charges.  But charges may be recommended by the Coroner.

  

Avatar
BehindTheBikesheds replied to Sakurashinmachi | 5 years ago
0 likes

Sakurashinmachi wrote:

Jimmy Ray Will wrote:

Echoing my sentiments from the other day... why are prosecutors so utterly incompetent? 

However, this was an inquest so not the same, but it should be obvious for all to see that there was an agenda being pushed from the police from day one...

As you say, it's a Coronial inquest - so no prosecution, no defence, no charges.  But charges may be recommended by the Coroner.

  

Absolutely no chance of that happening, their language during the inquest pretty much already hints as to which camp they are in.

Avatar
burtthebike replied to Sakurashinmachi | 5 years ago
0 likes

Sakurashinmachi wrote:

As you say, it's a Coronial inquest - so no prosecution, no defence, no charges.  But charges may be recommended by the Coroner.

 

The coroner may or may not recommend charges, but they also have a duty to point out the failings of the police, a level of such staggering incomptence as to offend the chief of the Keystone cops.  I'm not sure if the coroner can recommend the investigation of the police actions, but they certainly should.

Avatar
Karbon Kev | 5 years ago
0 likes

Hope his partner gets some justice in this horrible accident, poor sod didn't stand a chance. All cyclists are at risk, don't matter where you ride.

Avatar
jestriding | 5 years ago
7 likes

The only reason Mark Beaumont wasn't run into from behind when he did his world record circumnavigation of the globe was because the driver crashed into one of his support vehicles which was driving behind him.  

It appears being a big, white campervan with flashing lights does not prevent being run into from behind by an Australian driver.

Avatar
davel replied to jestriding | 5 years ago
4 likes

jestriding wrote:

The only reason Mark Beaumont wasn't run into from behind when he did his world record circumnavigation of the globe was because the driver crashed into one of his support vehicles which was driving behind him.  

It appears being a big, white campervan with flashing lights does not prevent being run into from behind by an Australian driver.

The culture is truly fucked. Not just over there, but over here too. 

There is cynical blurring of the boundaries of personal responsibility by Mr Loophole and his ilk; there is a much wider, but equally harmful acceptance that 'shit happens' in a dangerous environment.

But the law in this area, and those who uphold and enforce it, needs to be as black and white as it can be. The officers in Mike's case have been disgraceful - incompetent, at best.

Avatar
Crampy | 5 years ago
2 likes

One more thing; it is claimed in several press releases that English is Sheggu Bobbs second language. He is from Sierra Leone. The official language in Sierra Leone is English. Of course there are a couple dozen tribal languages, but everyone speaks English. Ive been there. 

It really seems like his council is over egging the pudding to make this guy out to be some sort of Afro Australian Forrest Gump...

Avatar
Crampy | 5 years ago
9 likes

«Had his phone in his lap»?!?!? And the police didnt size it?

FFS! I ran into the back of another car a couple years back, as I was late for work and driving like a wanker. As it was me who did the crashing from behind I was automatically responsible (I admited as such at the scene) and got an (approx) six hundred quid fine. This was more than the Bobb eejit got and I didnt even injure anyone! 

It seems that cycling in itself is an offence in Aus. 

Fucking travesty.

Avatar
brooksby | 5 years ago
0 likes

Is "a suggestible witness" a euphemism?

Avatar
BehindTheBikesheds | 5 years ago
10 likes

So a 'suggestable' witness is to be excused from any investigation, you mean someone who might tell the truth under pressure can't be allowed to say anything in case it totally blows the lies and corrupt police apart.

Wankers the lot of them!

I for one would chip in if Anna were to take a legal case against the police to have the whole matter reinvestigated by uncorrupt people. Incompetent doesn't cover it, there is clear evidence of covering up here and as I said before, an agenda to protect motorists and victim blame cyclists, just as they've been doing for years under the NSW government!

Avatar
brooksby replied to BehindTheBikesheds | 5 years ago
4 likes

BehindTheBikesheds wrote:

So a 'suggestable' witness is to be excused from any investigation, you mean someone who might tell the truth under pressure can't be allowed to say anything in case it totally blows the lies and corrupt police apart.

This ^.

They would appear to mean that he lacks the intelligence or the self control to stick to the narrative that appears to have already been decided...  I feel so sorry for Mr Hall's partner, having to sit through all that.

Avatar
hughsain | 5 years ago
13 likes

Sounds a lot like the police had already decided the outcome of this case from the moment they turned up at the accident scene.

Latest Comments