news

Family of cyclist killed in Tottenham considering appeal against 'lenient' sentence

Driver who pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving banned for 3 years and given suspended sentence

The family of a cyclist killed in Tottenham, North London in March last year is said to be considering asking for the sentence handed down to the driver convicted of causing his death by dangerous driving to be appealed on the grounds that it is too lenient, and specifically a three-year ban from driving the motorist was given.

Frank Mugisha from Enfield, aged 41 and a father of four, lost his life six days after being struck by a car driven by 63-year-old Jonathan Baird at the junction of Great Cambridge Road and White Hart Lane on 27 March 2012, reports the Haringey Independent.

Baird, from Waltham Forest, pleaded guilty to causing his death by dangerous driving at Wood Green Crown Court and was given a six-month prison sentence, suspended for two years, ordered to undertake 150 hours of unpaid work and to pay £500 costs.

He was also banned from driving for three years, and will need to take an extended test before his licence is returned.

Isaac Adams, a friend of Mr Mugisha, told the newspaper that the victim’s family were considering asking for an appeal against the sentence and that he would be speaking about the matter with the cyclist's widow, Jennifer.

Victims, their families and other members of the public who believe a sentence in a given case is unduly lenient can complain to their local Crown Prosecution Service office, which may then decide to refer the issue to the Attorney General to consider whether an appeal should be lodged.

There is a 28-day limit between the date of sentencing and the case being referred by the Attorney General to the Court of Appeal, with no possibility of extension.

“I really think it is an insufficient sentence. I mean, you can’t take a life and get a three-year driving ban,” he explained.

“When you look at what the accident has cost his kids, they have been left without a father for good. This person has taken away a life from us.

“It is absolutely unbelievable. Someone with that kind of past should be banned for life.

“Last year it was Frank, in three years it could be someone else – it is something that could be avoidable. What is £500? It is probably something he was making in a week.

“We were hoping for a sentence within reason for the tragedy that he caused. That’s what justice is about. I am really appalled.

“There is no justice that could bring back Frank’s life but this sentence is a slap on the wrist – it doesn’t fit the crime.”

Last year saw the launch of a campaign led by British Cycling to call for a review of sentencing in cases in which cyclists are the victims, and representatives of British Cycling, CTC and RoadPeace met with justice minister Helen Grant in December to urge action from the government.

If you feel strongly about the way incidents in which cyclists and other vulnerable road users are are dealt with by the police and courts national cyclists’ organisation CTC earlier this month launched its Prioritise This campaign urging people living in England (outside London) and Wales to write to their police and crime commissioners to tell them to make road safety a priority. You can find out more details about that campaign here.

 

Simon has been news editor at road.cc since 2009, reporting on 10 editions and counting of pro cycling’s biggest races such as the Tour de France, stories on issues including infrastructure and campaigning, and interviewing some of the biggest names in cycling. A law and languages graduate, published translator and former retail analyst, his background has proved invaluable in reporting on issues as diverse as cycling-related court cases, anti-doping investigations, and the bike industry. He splits his time between London and Cambridge, and loves taking his miniature schnauzer Elodie on adventures in the basket of her Elephant Bike.

Latest Comments

  • Mathemagician 0 sec ago

    Yes, we should all shy away from using an inherently better drive type.

  • HarrogateSpa 9 min 31 sec ago

    Meanwhile Ricky Ross has started a whole thread of prejudiced anti-cycling bingo....

  • kil0ran 14 min 35 sec ago

    Self-build is the way to go. My old Triban 3 (now a pub bike) has been through commuter build to fast road with Di2 to light tourer to pub bike....

  • quiff 15 min 33 sec ago

    Is that a thing? I thought generally the advice was that you need some steerer above the stem clamp. Ok, it doesn't look that neat having loads of...

  • mdavidford 12 min 57 sec ago

    Makes you wonder why you bother reading reviews in the first place, since they cannot possibly give you any information you would consider useful....

  • ktache 20 min 9 sec ago

    Thank you  for posting this.  I read it yesterday and was very saddened by it....

  • jollygoodvelo 22 min 27 sec ago

    I've bought and enjoyed the other three so will be buying this one.  Beautifully produced books, ideal for dipping in and out of, perhaps in the...

  • brooksby 24 min 39 sec ago

    No, no, no.  I'm not being an idiot in driving 100 miles to go to the beach.  It's the other people driving 100 miles to go to the beach: it's them...

  • kil0ran 24 min 54 sec ago

    Correct on both counts re the Ribble, which is an issue if you can't bring the bike in the house or don't have power to the garage. Echo your...

  • The Choking Angels 32 min 18 sec ago

    Why complain to ST or IPSO? Describing the construction of a booby trap targetted at a particular group of people should be a police matter - it...