Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Disc Brakes and the Tour de France con.

Anyone else irritated by the continual shots of wheels with disc brakes during this year's Tour?

Bearing in mind fewer than 50% of bikes in the peleton are actually using them, we have to wonder why so much attention is being paid to them and why consequently the Tour organisers are happy for their event to be used to promote a lie.

Its important to know that virtually every shot we see during the Tour has a commercial imperitive, so it's almost certain that there is a commercial decision behind showing so many shots of disc brakes despite the reality.

For me one of the very few down sides of the rise in popularity of cycling is the parrallel growth of a voracious industry that in some ways has been as much cycling's enemy as it has its friend. The determination by the cycle industry to force disc brakes on cyclists is an example of this.

The industry and more specifically the industry's marketing people are no longer (if  they ever were) in the least bit interested in how different technologies will benefit people and cycling. The priority is always to promote innovations and technologies that will first benefit their profits. Any benefit to cyclists is entirely coincidental. This admittedly cynical view appears to be reaching its apotheosis with the now wholesale drive to disc brakes. And it's probably no coincidence that the bike industry itself, after many years of spectacular growth is starting to level out. The debate as to whether rim brakes or disc brakes are superior has become irrelevant to an industry that has become obsessed with the prospect of millions of road-bike-riding consumers buying a new frame and rescuing them for another few years at least.

A similar thing happened a decade ago with bottom bracket standards, but that was disorganised and messy (cyclists are still paying the price for that one - literally). If the TDF shots are anything to go by, this new con is simpler and far better organised. Probably because it is benefitting all the relevant manufacturers roughly equally as they stare at falling sales.

So here we are. Watching the 2019 Tour de France punctuated by endless shots of bicycle wheels adorned with disc brakes, despite less than 50% of Tour bikes actually using them. All to develop the idea in people's heads that they really do need to get rid of that dated road bike they've been riding for at least six months and get something a bit more up to date.

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

38 comments

Avatar
ktache | 5 years ago
10 likes

They have always liked lingering shots of rotating wheels, it's part of filling 5 hours of telly.

It's as much TdF as glorious chateaux, or is the secret cabal trying to make us buy those too.

Avatar
mike the bike | 5 years ago
3 likes

 

I don't think this is a spoof post; I think Mr Legs has a point although it's as old as the hills.  Imagine if you will the scene outside the 16th century blacksmith's forge.  The cart owner can't believe the price of new wheels, an increase of ten groats in just one year.  But the smith explains that the new ones have metal rims and are definitely superior to the old wooden type.  So, afraid of being left behind by technology, the man pays the extra and everybody's happy.  

The story about discs is no different and after this fuss has died down there will be another along very soon.  Anyone prepared to bet it will be about road bike suspension?

Avatar
Daddylonglegs replied to mike the bike | 5 years ago
1 like

mike the bike wrote:

 

I don't think this is a spoof post; I think Mr Legs has a point although it's as old as the hills.  Imagine if you will the scene outside the 16th century blacksmith's forge.  The cart owner can't believe the price of new wheels, an increase of ten groats in just one year.  But the smith explains that the new ones have metal rims and are definitely superior to the old wooden type.  So, afraid of being left behind by technology, the man pays the extra and everybody's happy.  

The story about discs is no different and after this fuss has died down there will be another along very soon.  Anyone prepared to bet it will be about road bike suspension?

I think it is different Mike. The metal rims were superior, there wasn't a debate about it. Just because cart owners didnt want to pay the extra money doesn't mean there was any genuine debate about it. More than half the pro peloton aren't convinced about discs and much of the public isn't either. And for good reason. On the subject of discs it's horses for courses. They are good for some people and some uses and bad for others. My point is it's looking like manufacturers are going to force a situation where there will be no choice. I doubt it is a coincidence that this will lead to a significant short term rise in profits for an industry now struggling relative to its recent performance.  This is not good for cycling.

Avatar
Hirsute | 5 years ago
2 likes

We shuold go back to toeclips and straps.

Avatar
BehindTheBikesheds replied to Hirsute | 5 years ago
0 likes

hirsute wrote:

We shuold go back to toeclips and straps.

Never stopped using them though I use cleated shoes for the most part. There are some definite advantages over TC&S, disc brakes do not have anything like the advantages over rim brakes. Rim braking could have been developed further but manufacturers simply wanted to exploit an avenue to generate sales/increase profit.

Avatar
Hirsute replied to BehindTheBikesheds | 5 years ago
0 likes
BehindTheBikesheds wrote:

hirsute wrote:

We shuold go back to toeclips and straps.

Never stopped using them though I use cleated shoes for the most part. There are some definite advantages over TC&S, disc brakes do not have anything like the advantages over rim brakes. Rim braking could have been developed further but manufacturers simply wanted to exploit an avenue to generate sales/increase profit.

I was thinking more of the marketing aspect of the OP, 2 sets of pedals , 3 or 4 pairs of shoes, replacing cleats etc.

Avatar
EddyBerckx | 5 years ago
17 likes

Christ I hope this is a spoof post

Avatar
Daddylonglegs replied to EddyBerckx | 5 years ago
0 likes

StoopidUserName wrote:

Christ I hope this is a spoof post

Pages

Latest Comments