Koga E-Nova RT electric bike  £2529.00

8/10

Very good quality e-bike; a solid alternative to a second car for round-town transportation

Weight 25100g   Contact  www.koga.com

by Dave Atkinson   March 19, 2014  

Koga's E-Nova RT is a great vehicle for getting around with consummate ease. It does a fantastic job of flattening out the topography to make any journey cycle-friendly. The Bosch drivetrain is easily the best I've used, and the whole bike oozes quality. It's expensive, and there are some esoteric component choices, but overall this e-bike is a joy to pilot about town and could be a genuine alternative to a second car depending on your circumstances.

Koga's e-bike range concentrates on the upper end of that particular market. Across the channel, where electric bikes are much better established and the average spend on an e-bike much higher, a lot of bikes in the £2-3k price bracket get sold. Talking to electric bike dealers at the recent Core Bike show it's clear that we Brits aren't prepared to fork out anywhere near as much on a regular basis.

That's probably because cycling is still very much pigeonholed as a leisure activity rather than a viable transport option over here. Two grand is a lot when you're thinking about popping out to the pub of a weekend, less so when you're considering how you'll get to work every day.

Anyway, that price tag gets you plenty of bike. The frame itself is 6061 aluminium alloy and it's very nicely made and finished, with smooth welds and a gun-metal paint job that's smart and tough. The fork is also alloy and the E-Nova uses Koga's feathershock system which is similar to Cannondale's Headshok in that the fork crown and blades are a single rigid structure but they're suspended by a mechanism within the head tube. It doesn't offer much in the way of travel but it's very neat.

Bolted to where you'd normally expect to find the bottom bracket is Bosch's latest generation motor. The bottom bracket unit contains the motor and three sensors monitor your pedal input and match it with a push from the motor. This happens up to 1,000 times a second apparently, although I'm not sure a city e-bike really requires that level of precision.

The motor can supply up to 50Nm of torque and it's powered by a 400Wh Lithium-ion battery that sits within the rear rack. Controlling the power, and checking your stats, is all done via the Bosch Intuvia display which is mounted centrally on the bars. There's a big speedo, an assistance indicator that shows you how much the motor is helping, a battery level indicator and a display that'll show you trip distance, range under power, time, odometer, average and maximum speeds '' the usual computer stuff.

The Intuvia display also shows what level of assistance you're on. You can turn the motor off completely, or choose from four assistance modes: Eco, Tour, Sport and Turbo. No prizes for guessing which one's most powerful. Like all non-licensed electric bikes the E-Nova is able to assist you with a maximum of 250W of power up to a maximum speed of 25kph; after that you're on your own. Changing the power level and the displayed info is a simple matter of pressing the buttons on the remote that sits next to your left hand; that also features a 'walk' button that'll power the bike along when you're walking with it to take your mind off the fact that it weighs 25kg and more.

Your position on the Koga is upright, thanks to a high front end and swept bars that culminate in some excellent ergonomic leather grips. The stem is adjustable through a fairly wide range of positions and the single-bolt design is very neat. A comfort saddle takes your behind and that's mounted on a suspension seatpost.

Gearing-wise the E-Nova sports a Nexus eight-speed hub with the chain running in a fully-enclosed chain case. It also has a coaster brake, which supplements the Magura HS-11 hydraulic rim brakes. Lighting is provided by a Trelock front and Spanninga rear, running from a Shimano dynohub. You even get a nurse's lock, mudguards and a stand.

All in all it's a good-looking city bike. The motor and battery are unobtrusive and Koga have gone to some lengths to tidy away all the cables; the result is a clean look that needs a double take to spot it's electric. I had the 57cm men's model which was fine for me (1.90m), if you're a true giant there's a 60cm frame too as well as a 54cm and women's bikes with a step through frame running from 47cm to 59cm.

I've ridden a few electric bikes at length, and I've ridden a lot of electric bikes round the test track at Eurobike, and I've yet to find a system that's as polished as the Bosch bottom bracket. It's really very good indeed. The application of power is never jumpy or choppy, just a constant and helpful assistance. Changing modes is simple and quick; that means sticking it in Turbo for a quick getaway from the lights is a job you can do without even looking.

The hub gears, which allow you to change gear when stationary, are also a real boon around town. No more getting stuck at the lights in the wrong gear. On top of that the full mudguards and full chain case mean that you can ride in your normal clothes, and you'd feel pretty odd aboard the E-Nova in anything else. Riding the bike makes for lordly progress. It sits you up and it's comfy and stable, with the contact points (especially the excellent grips) just right for shorter journeys.

Range-wise, when we rolled the E-Nova out of its box, fresh from the Netherlands, it suggested that we might get over 100km from one charge on Eco mode. Ha! Then we showed it Bloomfield Road a few times, and now it's a lot more circumspect about how far you might be able to go under power.

The system learns your usage and adjusts its forecasts accordingly, but if you spend a big percentage of your time going uphill, as I do, it's fairly pessimistic, which I guess is better than it being optimistic. Now when it's fully charged the bike states the range on Eco as 45km or so, less on higher power modes.

In practice I'm getting 35-40km out of a full charge, although I never let the charge run down to zero as there's no need. Three times down the big hill into work and back up the big hill (approx 20km in total) is enough to deplete the battery to a point where I'd be plugging it in again. You can charge the bike with the battery in situ, or it's simple to release it and bring the battery inside if the bike lives in the shed/garage.

I'm 100kg and it's a big hill, so 35-40km is basically a worst case scenario unless your commute is up the Tourmalet or something. If you live in Cambridge and you weigh half what I do, you'll probably get close to three figures out of one charge, assuming you use Eco mode most of the time. I found I didn't need the range, so defaulted to Sport mode because it's more fun. If you're heavy, or unfit and in need of higher levels of assistance, and you have a long and hilly commute, then it's possible that you could run out of charge before you got home. But you'd have to think of a fairly specific set of circumstances where you'd need to charge the Koga more than once a day.

To fully put to bed the notion that you'd be better off on a lighter bike than this heavy old thing with its battery and motor weighing you down, consider this: I'm able, aboard the Koga, to do my commute home (3km at an average 5% climb), in my jeans and jumper, three minutes quicker than I can on my road bike. And that's without even really breaking a sweat, just pootling up the hill under power, whereas on the road bike it's a pretty tough climb. Not that the Koga, or any electric bike, is really about going fast. The motor cuts out at 25kph and that's as fast as you'd really want to go anyway on this thing. On the flat I was no quicker than usual. In a lot of instances I was slower. But what you're able to do aboard this bike is make those journeys in normal clothes with minimal effort.

I popped my back last June, a prolapsed L5/S1 disc in my lower spine. Then I did it again in August, and then again, in January, at which point I spent a couple of weeks in bed and decided that I'd better take it a bit easier on the old recovery front. The nerve damage caused by the prolapse meant i didn't have full muscle function or extension in my left leg, so I couldn't really ride a normal bike. I could ride this one though. So I was able to continue cycling.

Now I'm more or less mended, I don't really need to ride an electric bike down the hill when I'm capable of getting back up it under my own steam. But I'll miss the Koga, because if I'm just going into the office rather than on a ride, and I'll just be coming straight home, it means I can forget about changing and sweating and all those things and just ride down, and ride home. I know plenty of people in Bath, which is pretty topographically challenged, that would love to ride to work, but can't because they don't want to walk home up one of the city's many long and challenging hills. This bike could be for them, or for anyone who's not physically capable of whatever commute they have, be it one with hills, or one that's just a bit long to make a bike an option for them.

Lots of people can benefit from riding an e-bike that simply wouldn't consider a non-powered one. There's plenty for whom a good electric bike might be a realistic alternative to a second car. Given that scenario, the asking price of £2,500 suddenly doesn't seem all that steep. Cars are expected to depreciate by at least £500 a year. you'll probably put £500 of fuel in it even if you're just doing a short commute. Then it's another, say, £400 to insure, and then there's your vehicle duty, another £100+, and the MOT, and the servicing, and the parking, and suddenly you've spent a couple of grand in a year and the bike, which costs about 5p to charge, starts to look like quite an appealing option for the long term.

I wouldn't say the Koga is perfect. I know that Magura's HS-11 hydraulic rim brakes have a big and loyal following over on the continent. But why would you spec them when hydraulic disc brakes are so cheap? A set of Shimano Deore hydraulics would offer better braking, and they wouldn't be wearing your rims out and depositing black brake block gunk on the chain case when the going gets a bit wet either. Koga do a similar bike to this, the E-lement, with discs and a derailleur transmission. But the hub makes sense in town and the derailleur drivetrain isn't fully enclosed.

In any case the HS-11s make a good enough job of stopping the bike that the coaster brake on the hub is almost entirely redundant. It would be completely redundant with discs, which would mean you could get your pedals into start position at the lights more easily, which would be a bonus.

The Nexus hub isn't my favourite; my main bugbear is that when you're applying power it has a tendency to stick in gear when you're attempting to change down. This is exacerbated by the motor which effectively smooths out your pedal stroke so you're constantly applying pressure. To get it to shift reliably, you really need to back off. Not a major issue, just something you need to adjust to. Eight gears is more than you need, too. I rarely went below 2 even on the steep stuff and never went above 6 on the flat as that's a comfy gear for 25kph.

Overall though the E-Nova performs very well and is the complete package for anyone wanting a good quality city e-bike. If you're looking at it as a long-term investment for commuting then the up-front cost is easier to swallow if you're comparing it to the cost of a car or a season ticket. The Bosch motor system is the best I've tried and the rest of the components should give you years of service.

Verdict

Very good quality e-bike that's a solid long-term investment if you're planning to transport yourself on two wheels.

road.cc test report

Make and model: Koga E-Nova RT Electric Bike

Size tested: Large

About the bike

State the frame and fork material and method of construction. List the components used to build up the bike.

Frame

Completely hand built super smooth-welded frame. Tubing crafted from double hardened and double butted 6061 aluminium. Featuring an internal Bosch motor, integrated cables, headset and a KOGA chain tension system.

Front fork

KOGA Feathershock

Battery

Bosch Li-Ion 400 Wh (36V*11Ah)

Motor

Bosch BracketEngine - 50Nm

Display

Bosch Intuvia

Handlebar

KOGA Touring alloy

Stem

KOGA Justera - Adjustable A-head

Grips

KOGA ergonomic

Saddle

Koga Komforza

Seat pillar

KOGA Alloy

Shifters

Shimano Nexus - Revo

Cassette

Shimano Nexus 19T

Chain

KMC X8-93

Crank set

Mirande 18T

Brake (rear)

Magura HS-11 Hydraulic

Rims

KOGA KM19-622 alloy

Tyres

Schwalbe Energizer 37 mm

Rear Hub

Shimano Nexus-8

Front Hub

Shimano DH3N31 6V/3,0W

Headlight

Trelock LS 863

Rear light

Spanninga Plateo - Standlight

Rear carrier

KOGA frame integrated - Alloy hollow tubing max 25 kg

Pedals

KOGA Sole-Mate - Concaved anti slip layer

Mudguard

SKS B-45

Chain guard

Hesling Cadena

Kickstand

Pletscher Comp

Ring lock

AXA Defender RL - ART aproved - Folding key

Tell us what the bike is for, and who it's aimed at. What do the manufacturers say about it? How does that compare to your own feelings about the bike?

Comfortable E-bike with the new Bosch Active Cruise central motor for powerful and reliable pedal assist. Unique frame with an extra low instep, provided with low maintenance 8 speed hub gears and hydraulic disc brakes.

Frame and fork

Overall rating for frame and fork
 
9/10

Tell us about the build quality and finish of the frame and fork?

Very nicely made with smoothed welds, finish is tough and classy.

Tell us about the geometry of the frame and fork?

54, 57 and 60cm men's and 47, 50, 53, 56 and 59cm women's sizes available.

How was the bike in terms of height and reach? How did it compare to other bikes of the same stated size?

It was fine, and there's lots of adjustability.

Riding the bike

Was the bike comfortable to ride? Tell us how you felt about the ride quality.

Very comfortable for shorter distances.

Did the bike feel stiff in the right places? Did any part of the bike feel too stiff or too flexible?

The bike feels fine for a city bike, stiffness not an issue.

How did the bike transfer power? Did it feel efficient?

Very well, especially since you get out more than you put in.

Was there any toe-clip overlap with the front wheel? If so, was it a problem?

No issues.

How would you describe the steering? Was it lively, neutral or unresponsive? Neutral to slow.

Tell us some more about the handling. How did the bike feel overall? Did it do particular things well or badly?

Handlebar position and geometry make the steering fairly slow and predictable, fine for around town.

Rate the bike for efficiency of power transfer:
 
10/10
Rate the bike for acceleration:
 
7/10
Rate the bike for sprinting:
 
1/10
Rate the bike for high speed stability:
 
8/10
Rate the bike for cruising speed stability:
 
10/10
Rate the bike for low speed stability:
 
9/10
Rate the bike for flat cornering:
 
8/10
Rate the bike for cornering on descents:
 
7/10
Rate the bike for climbing:
 
10/10

The drivetrain

Rate the drivetrain for performance:
 
8/10
Rate the drivetrain for durability:
 
8/10
Rate the drivetrain for weight:
 
7/10
Rate the drivetrain for value:
 
6/10

Wheels and tyres

Rate the wheels and tyres for performance:
 
7/10
Rate the wheels and tyres for durability:
 
10/10
Rate the wheels and tyres for weight:
 
5/10
Rate the wheels and tyres for comfort:
 
7/10
Rate the wheels and tyres for value:
 
7/10

Controls

Rate the controls for performance:
 
8/10
Rate the controls for durability:
 
8/10
Rate the controls for weight:
 
6/10
Rate the controls for comfort:
 
9/10
Rate the controls for value:
 
7/10

Your summary

Did you enjoy riding the bike? Yes.

Would you consider buying the bike? If it was a choice between this and running a second car, then yes.

Would you recommend the bike to a friend? For the right sort of usage, yes.

Rate the bike overall for performance:
 
8/10
Rate the bike overall for value:
 
6/10

Overall rating: 8/10

About the tester

Age: 40  Height: 190cm  Weight: 102kg

I usually ride: whatever I'm testing...  My best bike is: Genesis Equilibrium 853

I've been riding for: 10-20 years  I ride: Every day  I would class myself as: Experienced

I regularly do the following types of riding: commuting, club rides, sportives, general fitness riding, fixed/singlespeed, mtb, Mountain Bike Bog Snorkelling, track

 

7 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

When's it going back? Because we still need to have that race up Wellsway! Smile

posted by mb429 [76 posts]
19th March 2014 - 17:46

29 Likes

Can I get the government £5000 electric vehicle subsidy to help pay for this?

Oh, no, I can't. Because it only has 2 wheels, not 4. Maybe Koga could tie two together for me?

PJ McNally's picture

posted by PJ McNally [592 posts]
19th March 2014 - 17:52

32 Likes

Lots of fair points there about the use-cases of those less fit or less able etc, but having tried a load of these for an ailing relative, I can see the attraction myself. In a country (UK) where we're vulnerable road users, these bikes simply remove overtaking! Cars don't go past you. You can ride in primary the whole way (in the more urban bits of town, at least)!

Only thing stopping me getting one is lack of space, lack of cash and the need to keep trim by hammering around town on my various errands. Mainly it's the cash. God, it was great fun.

Also, a revelation was - before getting on one, I thought, why not make same bike but with lightweight components, I mean, look at the price! But as the article says, you don't want to be bouncing around over potholes much above 25kmph. The powered cycling encourages a sort of sit-back cycling, great in traffic.

posted by vbvb [366 posts]
19th March 2014 - 22:11

26 Likes

I've only ridden my mum's up and down the street, but to her it's been a godsend. She now, rather weather dependent, rides into work quite often, about seven miles. She couldn't do this on a "normal" bike, not in any sensible time, due to a knackered knee. The motor lets her get there without breaking a sweat, but still getting a bit of exercise (you don't have to get sweaty for it to have a benefit), whilst at weekends she can try going further and faster whilst still being able to tackle inclines (whilst my dad huffs and puffs in her slipstream Laughing )

She's actually on her second- her first was wearing out, the battery wasn't holding charge, and cycle-to-work came round again.

posted by Al__S [774 posts]
19th March 2014 - 23:08

26 Likes

the "Walk" button is also for when you're going up or down a flight of stairs with the bike wheels in the little cycle ramp that the continentals usually have.

I have a folding eBike that is costing me £999 via the cyclescheme. Wish it had a "Walk" button to help me get it up the stairs to my flat... the twist-grip throttle is too snatchy and fierce... Sad

posted by Paul_C [284 posts]
20th March 2014 - 11:52

26 Likes

Very nice, well-equipped bike but the price seems a bit steep. You can pick up an equivalent Kalkhoff electric bike with the higher spec Bosch Performance system for £1895 http://goo.gl/TG3m95 - it's also a significantly lighter, even with suspension.

Or one with Kalkhoff's Impulse 2.0 electric bike system http://goo.gl/w66uwj that develops more torque and much greater battery capacity and lifetime (and therefore greater range and economy) for around £500 less.

e.g. Pro Connect i8 Alfine http://goo.gl/ng9Opb
Agattu i8 http://goo.gl/MkLJkO

Regarding your point on the gear change, the Impulse 2.0 system automatically interrupts motor power for 250 milliseconds so that the hub gear can shift without being under load, making for smoother changes and protecting the hub's mechanism.

One model has continuously variable automatic gears which work with a wireless chest belt and the motor to keep your heart rate constant throughout your ride http://goo.gl/wT3mMF

Road.cc - the Bosch system is good, some of our bikes are fitted with it, but the Impulse 2.0 system performs at least as well and is always less expensive, on bikes that are just as well equipped as the Koga. How about we send one in for a test?

Tim 50cycles's picture

posted by Tim 50cycles [8 posts]
22nd March 2014 - 9:57

15 Likes

Also, you can read this review http://usemyreviews.com/electric-bikes-reviews/, written by me.

posted by AlliK02 [5 posts]
13th August 2014 - 1:20

0 Likes

road.cc reviews

Latest reviews

8/10
£22.49
April 20, 2015
8/10
£109.99
April 20, 2015
8/10
£1800.00
April 19, 2015
7/10
£7.99
April 19, 2015
4/10
£11.99
April 18, 2015
6/10
£130.00
April 18, 2015
6/10
£33.99
April 17, 2015
7/10
£33.99
April 17, 2015
9/10
£249.99
April 16, 2015
6/10
£95.00
April 15, 2015
7/10
£2149.99
April 15, 2015
9/10
£34.99
April 13, 2015
7/10
£34.99
April 12, 2015
7/10
£2199.99
April 12, 2015
7/10
£42.99
April 11, 2015
8/10
£14.99
April 11, 2015
5/10
£16.99
April 10, 2015
8/10
£299.99
April 10, 2015
8/10
£40.00
April 10, 2015
7/10
£1.99
April 9, 2015
9/10
£14.99
April 9, 2015
9/10
£279.99
April 9, 2015
8/10
£19.99
April 8, 2015
9/10
£8.99
April 8, 2015
8/10
£1300.00
April 8, 2015
9/10
£8.99
April 7, 2015
7/10
£59.99
April 6, 2015
8/10
£41.99
April 6, 2015
7/10
£29.95
April 6, 2015
 
1