Birmingham "vigilante" cyclist tells his story

Protest followed years of police indifference to injured cyclists at notorious junction

by John Stevenson   October 25, 2013  

Junction of Horton Square and Belgrave Middleway (source Google Street View)

One of the riders involved in last week’s confrontation between cyclists and a taxi driver in Birmingham has told the campaigners’ side of the story and denied ever blocking the legal route through the junction.

Campaigners blocked the junction of Belgrave Middleway and Horton Square in Birmingham so that only buses and cyclists could use the lanes designated for them. A taxi driver, Abid Hussain, attempted to drive down the bus-only lane and was blocked by campaigners. After the stand-off that developed, Mr Hussain claimed: “They [the cyclists] were a law unto themselves. I couldn’t move anywhere because of the sheer numbers.

“These people on two wheels, who don’t even pay road tax, were acting like vigilantes.”

Legal route left clear

Not so, says protest participant Stephen Perrin. In a guest blog on the Levenes Cycle Injury site he writes: “[Mr Hussain] claimed, according to Birmingham Mail, that the cyclists surrounded his cab and blocked his way. If that was true then the dozens of law-abiding motorists squeezing through to take the legal route would have been unable to do so. It was he who chose to obstruct the highway.

“The way was clear for him to turn left at any time and was free to leave if he felt in danger as claimed. That he didn't shows an abandonment of his duty of care to his passenger.”

Mr Perrin also explains the background to the protest included the refusal of Birmingham police to take seriously the complaints of cyclists who have been victims of illegal driving at this junction.

A friend of his had been the victim of a hit-and-run collision at the junction, but had refused to complain to the police because a friend more seriously injured in a collision at the junction had been “met with disbelief by West Midlands Police and effectively told off.

“This mirrored an incident I reported to police involving a dangerous overtake by a HGV on the A435. The officer refused to take a report and told me: ‘Roads in Birmingham are dangerous, we know that. Complain to the Council.’

“I've had tangles with taxis and minicabs, private cars, large commercial vans and HGVs, also witnessing another cyclist's near miss with a bus. I've reported a number of these incidents only to be told police would take no action. The police say responsibility lies with Council who in turn blame Plod... lawless!”

Police side with taxi driver

As documented by both the Birmingham Mail and Mr Perrin’s account, police eventually turned up. The official police account says only that the taxi was “moving away” at the time of the evening’s final incident, in which the taxi’s wing mirror was removed.

Stephen Perrin gives a more detailed account of the police’s action at the incident.

“A Community Support Officer showed up and attempted to resolve the matter.

“After some negotiation with the driver she chose to appease the motorist and, after assuring the demonstrators she would instruct the taxi to drive up to Haden Circus, waved it through the bus gate, confirmed by a bystander.

“The cabbie drove his vehicle on the wrong side of the road through a junction towards a group of people. A pedestrian demonstrator came into contact with the taxi resulting in damage to a wing mirror.”

“Police negligence placed a number of people at risk of injury. I understand a complaint of misconduct will be made against the PCSO.”

Notorious junction - Birmingham’s ‘Bow roundabout’

Both Mr Perrin and Birmingham cycle campaign group Push Bikes say this junction is a notorious problem area for cyclists.

In a statement after the protest (incorrectly attributed to Nazan Fennell by the Birmingham Mail), Push Bikes said: “This crossing is a vital link across the ring road for cyclists, with hundreds of cyclists using it every day, but those cyclists' lives are put at risk by other vehicles abusing this lane, and there is a history of serious accidents at this spot.

“Cyclists' lives are put at risk by a minority of drivers who have the attitude that they are the most important people on the road, and no-one else matters, an attitude exemplified by this taxi driver.

“Push Bikes is very disappointed that the first police officer to speak to this taxi driver was uncertain about the meaning of the clear signs at this crossing, and did not persuade the taxi driver to take the legal route out of the bus lane.

“The message from Monday night is clear - our streets are made dangerous by a minority of bad drivers, and it is vitally important for the police and local authorities to punish drivers who think they are above the rules of the road.”

Stephen Perrin points out that there are three schools, a large mosque and a shopping area close to the junction, and hundreds of cyclists pass through it every day on their way between the south of the city and the centre.

He writes: “In an area with such a high concentration of vulnerable road users, routine abuse by motorists of both the bus gate and parking restrictions is met with indifference by police and the local authority; it's only a matter of time before there is another serious incident or even death.”

Push Bikes chair Chris Lowe pointed out that the protest was not organised or sanctioned by the organisation, though it had publicised the flash ride that it developed from, as it does many other Birmingham events . He said: “Push Bikes is in no position to sanction or otherwise the actions of people who were on that demonstration, as it was not our demonstration.

“I will say that Push Bikes does not support damage to private property, and we do hope that the damage to the taxi was accidental rather than deliberate.”

13 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

i am sad, but not surprised in the slightest by the whole affair.

mrmo's picture

posted by mrmo [1023 posts]
25th October 2013 - 18:52

like this
Like (16)

Getting tired of saying it but, but I will anyway; Road Tax does not exist.

podgethepuffer's picture

posted by podgethepuffer [18 posts]
25th October 2013 - 19:33

like this
Like (21)

I have to say, from talking to many other riders (online and in person) a large number in many districts do not feel the Police are either at all helpful after an incident, or indeed care, or that they've been blamed for inciting an incident.

I wonder if this flash ride was filmed by anyone. In this day and age you need to film these things to make the facts clear.

downfader's picture

posted by downfader [191 posts]
25th October 2013 - 19:53

like this
Like (16)

Are we meant to be surprised or outraged by police inaction? Try reporting some drug dealing, criminal damage or theft. I have no confidence in the police and I'm not surprised if people start taking the law into their own hands.

kiwiglider's picture

posted by kiwiglider [22 posts]
25th October 2013 - 21:33

like this
Like (14)

Playing devils advocate, firstly the "police officer" is a community support officer and so has no training in the road traffic act. And should not be sent to any incidents which could result in conflict so have not had enough training to cope with this incident. Secondly Birmingham city council are currently in a phased roll out of bus lane enforcement cameras to fine these transgressions, if this is a problem area it could well be part of the roll out.

posted by swampy [2 posts]
25th October 2013 - 22:35

like this
Like (13)

ok this sounds like useless city poilice to me. I live in Surrey and was at a BBC debate te other day. The Asst Chief Constable on the panel (ex club and racing cyclist) was good and fair. Last year I was in a confrontation with a white van that ran me into the side of the road and the passenger then hosed me down with juice. I had the reg and called it in right there and then. Had a call from the cops later that evening and they arranged to have someone come over an take a statement the next day. They took an hour over the statement. I showed them the exact place on street view. I had a follow up call a few weeks later to tell me that they had tracked the van down and spoken with the driver and they were going to prosecute. They prosecuted for dangerous driving because they cited 40 years of club cycling experience including cyclo cross and track was the only reason that I managed to stay intact. In other words Surrey Police used my cycling experience to show that the driving was worse than it looked. The lead officer was a cyclist. The lady that interviewed me was a motorcyclist. I now find that the Asst Chief Constable was a club cyclist. These are some of the benefits of understanding that come from a cycling background and not just cops steeped in car culture. More proof if any were needed that critical mass is so very important. Result was 9 points that in fact meant a a fine and a ban.
I hope they go to town on the thoroughly useless cop they have in Birmingham. Use your smart phone. get numbers and names and video. Ask questions of the cops. put them on the spot. and put your hand in your pocket for the CTC and the Cyclist Defence Fund. Make the cops your friend if you can put pressure on them if you can't.

Cycling is like a church - many attend, but few understand.

posted by oozaveared [505 posts]
25th October 2013 - 22:55

like this
Like (20)

swampy wrote:
Playing devils advocate, firstly the "police officer" is a community support officer and so has no training in the road traffic act. And should not be sent to any incidents which could result in conflict so have not had enough training to cope with this incident.

Which rapidly leads to the question, what did the police expect to happen? So why did they send an untrained PCSO to the scene in the first place!

Although, i would have to ask how many police officers have any knowledge or give a damn about the road traffic act anyway!

mrmo's picture

posted by mrmo [1023 posts]
25th October 2013 - 22:55

like this
Like (14)

+1 swampy

posted by mrchrispy [281 posts]
26th October 2013 - 0:27

like this
Like (10)

I was knocked off a few weeks ago, it took 45 mins for the plod to turn up and just took both sides and sent me on my way to walk home pushing my crumpled bike. The plod told me they would call me later with more info, I didnt get a call but 3 weeks later just the usual letter stating no charges and the case was now closed (though I didnt want charges).

posted by Leodis [169 posts]
26th October 2013 - 9:04

like this
Like (11)

I agree with him entirely with his sentiment about West Midlands police not giving a damn about cyclists.
Reported countless dangerous drivers, and never heard anything more from them, it's no wonder people are taking action themselves.

glynr36's picture

posted by glynr36 [271 posts]
26th October 2013 - 10:48

like this
Like (13)

The most serious incident I have had in recent years was when a car pulled away from its parking place on the right hand side of the road & came straight across, forcing me onto the pavement.

I'm in Birmingham. It was a Police car.

Grizzerly

posted by Grizzerly [113 posts]
26th October 2013 - 13:54

like this
Like (16)

I thought it was an offense for a police officer to refuse to take a crime report.

posted by jacknorell [267 posts]
26th October 2013 - 17:06

like this
Like (9)

I've seen that a few times, by the police as well.
Shocking really.

glynr36's picture

posted by glynr36 [271 posts]
26th October 2013 - 17:54

like this
Like (9)