National federations urge UCI and McQuaid to let CAS decide on nomination validity

USA Cycling joins federations of Canada, Algeria, Finland and Russia in making appeal

by Simon_MacMichael   September 2, 2013  

Pat McQuaid © Simon MacMichael.jpg

Five national cycling federations, led by USA Cycling, are urging the UCI and its president Pat McQuaid to remove uncertainty about the validity of his nominations to stand for a third term of office by letting the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) rule on his eligibility.

The issue the federations, which also comprise those of Algeria, Canada, Finland and Russia, want the CAS to make a judgment on relate to the controversial proposed change to the UCI constitution that would allow a candidate for the presidency to be nominated by any two national federations.

Most contentiously, it is proposed that the rule change be applied retroactively, which could if adopted give McQuaid a nomination he would not otherwise have secured.

In a letter seen by the website Inside The Games, USA Cycling president Steve Johnson told McQuaid and UCI director general Christophe Hubschmid:

"The cycling world has been watching the UCI Presidential race carefully and its reaction has varied from amusement to outrage, from bewilderment to astonishment," it reads.

"The loudest voices are frustrated by the uncertainty that will accompany this year's Congress in light of shifting nominations, retroactive laws and midstream changes to the election process.

"We understand that Congress has the power to address the propriety of amending the election process, and it will speak when these matters are addressed in Florence."

It goes on: "This uncertainty does not serve anyone's interests, especially those of the delegates who rely on this year's proceedings to allow the UCI to prove to the cycling world that the governance of their International Federation is ultimately grounded in the Constitution, and that the meaning of the Constitution is predictable and reliable.

"As a group, we believe strongly about the legal principles involved to ask a court to resolve this Constitutional dispute in due course.

"But we also care enough about our International Federation to try everything in our power to avoid a protracted battle that might cast the results of the election into doubt for many months to come."

There is also the threat of recourse to CAS should the appeal in the letter be rejected and McQuaid go on to secure a third term in office when the 42 delegates at the UCI Congress vote in Florence on 27 September.

The proposed change to the UCI constitution is due to be voted on earlier the same day.

Cookson and others have said that McQuaid is acting out of desperation and is seeking to alter the electoral process retrospectively for his own ends. McQuaid insists that the Cookson camp is in turn trying to engineer a situation whereby he accedes to the UCI presidency unopposed.

Commenting on news of the letters, Cookson said: "I can totally understand the desire by a number of National Federations to seek clarity on the UCI Constitution in relation to the nominating procedure and how this applies to the current Presidential election.

"Given the nature of the controversy it does make sense to have this matter adjudicated by CAS so that we can have a sound and fair election that is also genuinely robust.”

McQuaid, whose original nomination by Cycling Ireland was deemed invalid on a technicality, then vetoed when it was put to a vote at an Emergency General Meeting, last month had a separate nomination by Swiss Cycling withdrawn.

Those were the only two nominations made public following the expiry of the deadline on 29 June. Cookson has been nominated by British Cycling, of which he is president.

Almost a month later, it emerged that McQuaid has also been nominated by the Thai and Moroccan federations. He claims to be a member of both, and according to a legal opinion prepared on behalf of the UCI, such nominations were made in time and comply with the governing body’s constitution.

6 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

In a sadistic way I want to see McQuaid run and see if he wins, if he does it proves the whole of the UCI are as corrupt as he is, terrible thought eh !

posted by mikeprytherch [198 posts]
3rd September 2013 - 8:52

like this
Like (9)

Yes - Cookson should withdraw from the race now. This would force another round of nominations, McQuaid can go cap-in-hand trying to get one (from Kuala Lumpur or wherever), and if he does they can have a fair election.

That way, if - hopefully when - Cookson wins, he can say he won fair and square. If he wins by default, much as it pains me to say it, Pat might have a a bit of support from people who feel he's been hard done by.

(Though personally I think he's failed to get a nomination, so he's not in the race).

PJ McNally's picture

posted by PJ McNally [579 posts]
3rd September 2013 - 9:45

like this
Like (6)

I think you've been misinformed Simon. These Federations do not want a CAS judgement on the proposed constitutional change, they want a judgement on the Article 51.1 phrase "the Federation of the Candidate" and Pat's insistence that this means ANY of the Federations of the Candidate. If Pat's (and the UCI's) reading of the phrase is accepted, he currently has two valid nominatons, and no constitutional amendment is needed for him to stand.

posted by The Rumpo Kid [590 posts]
3rd September 2013 - 11:14

like this
Like (6)

Leaving aside the tribulations of the UCI presidential race for a moment, could you please find another file photo of McQuaid for future articles? Being greeted by a slightly bemused elderly man at every article is wearing thin at this stage.

posted by Ham-planet [82 posts]
3rd September 2013 - 19:33

like this
Like (6)

Ham-planet wrote:
Leaving aside the tribulations of the UCI presidential race for a moment, could you please find another file photo of McQuaid for future articles? Being greeted by a slightly bemused elderly man at every article is wearing thin at this stage.

Seconded!!! There must be more than 1 picture of him in the whole World

posted by jarredscycling [436 posts]
3rd September 2013 - 21:04

like this
Like (5)

International cycling continues to make a fool of itself. At Wits End

Bigcog's picture

posted by Bigcog [14 posts]
4th September 2013 - 16:51

like this
Like (7)