'Only good cyclist is a dead one' magazine editor agrees to join bike ride around Richmond

Richard Nye forced to apologise for comments - now the Richmond Cycling Campaign want to show him the positive side of riding

by Sarah Barth   September 10, 2012  

Richmond_twitter_title_page

Richard Nye, the magazine editor forced to apologise last week after writing an editorial in The Richmond Magazine stating that "the only good cyclist is a dead one," has agreed to join a bike ride in the local area to see the issues faced by riders.

According to the Richmond Cycling Campaign, "Richard has been in touch and we have something in the offing..." following an open letter to the editor which said: "We’d be more than happy to take him out for a short ride around the borough to see some of the issues we face on the roads and hopefully highlight why the reaction was as strong as it was."

The news was welcomed by cyclists, who flocked to our forum to berate Mr Nye for his comments.

Some called for his resignation, but the Richmond Cycling Campaign took a more measured approach.

They said: "We feel Mr Nye’s original comments were extremely badly misjudged to say the least (and on a personal level, having lost a friend this year in a road incident, offensive) and the reaction by the magazine should have been much better handled.

"They reflect much of the aggression many cyclists experience on a daily basis on the roads. We don’t, however, believe at this stage there is anything to be gained from pursuing a personal vendetta against Mr Nye or the magazine."

Nye eventually apologised for his comments, saying: "Largely, the controversy has focused upon the phrase “the only good cyclist is a dead one”.

"It seems that this has been interpreted as, at best, flippancy about cycling fatalities, at worst, an actual desire to see harm befall cyclists on our roads. Let me make it absolutely clear that this was not my intention. Neither is it representative of Sheengate Publishing’s editorial policy on cycling, which we fully understand is a vital aspect of Surrey life.

"I should add that I am well aware of the vulnerability of cyclists on our roads and the importance of addressing this. In practice, I endeavour to always approach them with the same degree of courtesy and caution as I would any other road user."

Let's hope he enjoys his ride and adjusts his thinking.

6 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

Well done to the Richmond Cycling Campaign. The kind of positive engagement with him which they plan has to be the best outcome.

two wheels good; four wheels bad

posted by cat1commuter [1293 posts]
10th September 2012 - 11:01

like this
Like (1)

hope he gets lynched! ha ha

posted by Karbon Kev [637 posts]
10th September 2012 - 13:55

like this
Like (0)

As the New Testament says, "There is more joy in heaven for one sinner who repents than for ten righteous men".

If the conversion is real, then we should applaud it, and suggestions that he should be lynched are just as bad as the original remark.

On the other hand, it does make me wonder - did Mr Nye predict precisely what reaction he would get? An outrageous - and perhaps not sincerely held - view attracts opprobium, he retracts it after allowing it to ferment a while, and he generates a theme which he can use for copy (yet to be seen whether pro- or anti-) which will last a couple of issues or more.

posted by Paul M [290 posts]
10th September 2012 - 16:46

like this
Like (0)

I very much doubt Mr Nye has changed his opinion. He's most likely been told by his publisher to apologise because the magazine has lost advertising revenue.

OldRidgeback

posted by OldRidgeback [1879 posts]
11th September 2012 - 21:09

like this
Like (0)

Should we hope, for his sake, that he's not a "good cyclist"? Thinking

posted by TheBigMong [218 posts]
11th September 2012 - 21:43

like this
Like (0)

Or should we hope that perhaps he sees what cyclists have to face on their daily commute (pot holes, near misses as cars pass too close, people stepping into the road not looking where they are going cos they're on their phones, vehicles behind revving their engine in an attempt to intimidate) and actually report on this as an 'outsider' to show that cyclists are human too and just as vulnerable... or take the tack that cycling is actually a fantastic way to travel that saves money, gets you fitter and takes more cars off the road? I'm perhaps optimistic, but then on the roads of Bristol and the rest of the UK, you have to be as a cyclist!

posted by Myriadgreen [89 posts]
12th September 2012 - 20:54

like this
Like (0)