Home
Hong Kong blog blows cover on something but is it really Dura-Ace?

A picture has appeared on the website flwrider showing what appears to be a Dura-Ace lever in a new design that appears to combine both electronic shifting buttons and a hydraulic brake pipe emerging from it.

As we posted back in October, Shimano are rumoured to be developing both an 11-speed Dura-Ace Di2 system and some version of disc brakes to go with it.

We say 'some version' because although part of the flying speculation agrees that hydraulic actuation would be an advantage over the convoluted routing of traditional Bowden cable through a modern carbon-fibre frame, others have poo-pooed the idea as an unnecessary step. To be fair, they're probably the people repelled by the very idea of disc brakes on a road bike, anyway. But they're going to have to get used to the idea because as our mystery Insider says in his recent post, they're coming whether we like it or not.

This spy shot seems to raise more questions than it answers. It surely does say 'Dura-Ace' on the lever itself but that may be because the maker has utilised an existing part from Shimano. The American site Bikerumor that specialises in this kind of stuff even appears to have uncovered a connection back to the British F1 company developing the Factor 001 we posted about back in 2009. The lever at the top here does look suspiciously like the one shown in factor 001 pictures on their site.

 

Update from The Insider

Our own Insider was on in a flash confirming that this is NOT the Dura-Ace Di2 lever or at least not the one we're expecting. As he points out viz a viz the Factor 001, "Giveaways are 1. it looks identical, two Factor 001 use Di2 and 3 it (the body) is carbon – Shimano's would be injection moulded and most probably rapid prototyped at this stage.

Or, in other words, what we're looking at is the existing Dura-Ace Di2 lever with its attendant shift switches to go with the Shimano Dura-Ace Di2 gear mechanisms, all mounted in Formula's own carbon-fibre body with hydraulics built in. Neat.


The latest version of the Factor 001 road bike from bf1systems in Norfolk has disc brakes.

Factor 001 control levers: a combination of Shimano's Di2 electric shift system and their own hydraulic braking body.  

 

36 comments

Avatar
othello [359 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

That hit every branch of the ugly tree on the way down.  31

Avatar
charliemac74 [183 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Be good in winter, like a fairing for your hands

Avatar
uksportives [25 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Hey I'm all for it, if it improves breaking, safety, and I suppose as they say the Futures Bright) Things are going to change whether we like it or not...

I know it's I suppose Prototype but how on earth are you meant to Be comfortable on those hoods, unless there is a cover to go over the so called tubing on the hoods....  31

Avatar
mikroos [257 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Wow, it could double as a jacket hanger!

Avatar
Animal [41 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Ugly. Expensive. Non maintainable. Over complicated. Why? Just why?

What about people who just want a decent, lightweight road bike which we can maintain ourselves, change or adjust derailleurs and brakes?

We don't all want to spend 5000 fekking quid on tricksy toys to impress our fat friends!

The equipment companies are just ripping everybody off. "up"grading things year after year after year.

Avatar
therevokid [911 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
othello wrote:

That hit every branch of the ugly tree on the way down.  31

Gods ... and a few more when it got to the bottom !!!

Avatar
Graham Howell [49 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Can someone explain to me what exactly was wrong with mechanical 10 speed? or 7, 8 and 9 speed for that matter?

Avatar
jezzzer [329 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

oh for heaven's sake. to save the comments section getting clogged up by these sorts of postings EVERY SINGLE TIME you do an article about Di2 / hydraulic brakes / colour television / these new-fangled pneumatic tyres etc etc, why not just have a little tick box where people can register their reactionary disapproval without the rest of us having to read it...?

Avatar
JohnS [198 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Reply to Graham Howell:

Easy-peasy - Shimano can't rip you off if it produces backward-compatible compnents.

If your lever or changer is worn out or damaged or if you want to rebuild your bike, there's no money in selling you last year's model, let alone five-years-ago's model.

My fave bike frame (light, fast, responsive, comfortable) is old. Seriously old, 1991. It can't take a cluster wider than nine-speed, and even then I can't use the smallest cog because the chain fouls the chainstays.

No, Mr Shimano (or Mr Campagnolo), I'm not going to abandon a bike that goes round corners as if it's on rails on Alpine descents and keeps me comfortable on a 200km Audax just so that you can market stuff at me.

Avatar
notfastenough [3661 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Well I can kinda go along with the idea that more speeds equals less jump between ratios, hence more fluid pedalling. That said, I also think that mechanical Dura-Ace (or even Ultegra) is way more capable than my abilities to exploit it, so opting for Di2 would appear to just put maintenance a little further out of my reach. Ditto disc brakes.

On the other hand, I haven't tried them, so maybe I would be an instant convert!

Avatar
step-hent [718 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
Graham Howell wrote:

Can someone explain to me what exactly was wrong with mechanical 10 speed? or 7, 8 and 9 speed for that matter?

Nothing wrong with it, exactly. But going from 7 up to 10 speed gives a far wider range of gears, with smaller jumps in between - meaning you're more likely to have the gear you want for a given stretch of road. so it's an improvement - one that some people don't want or need, but others do.

Moving to electronic shifting is the same idea - improves the shift reliability and accuracy, and thus gives improved performance. Not saying it's necessary, but it's still an improvement.

I don't really understand why people are so against progress. You can still get 8 speed shimano components for your 8 speed set up, and so long as there is a demand they'll still be available. No-one is forcing anyone to buy the new stuff - if you don't want it, don't buy it. No need to get all luddite about the technical advances - just choose not to buy it, and stick with what you have. Simple really...

As for this particular piece, if you could get a covering for the top section, it could make a great extra hand hold for a flat-armed aero position (see Vroomen's comments on his blog about the best aero position being on the hoods).

Avatar
Gkam84 [9068 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
othello wrote:

That hit every branch of the ugly tree on the way down.  31

And landed in the pile of dog sh*t at the bottom  19

Avatar
crazy-legs [704 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Can just imagine if the Victorians had had the internet...

You want to put brakes on my velocipede? And a chain? Whatever next? What was wrong with the penny farthing?  3 You want to have 4 wheels, a seat and an engine, what's wrong with a horse and carriage?

It's called progression, get used to it. 10 years ago, everyone was asking what was the point in full suspension/disc brakes on MTBs, now it's very difficult to find anything other than the most basic MTB that doesn't come with discs.

No-one is *forcing* you to buy anything. I certainly won't be buying it, not for a good few years yet. But I'm interested in the technology, the applications for it.

Imagine if you tried inventing a bike now and said to an engineer: "yes, the braking mechanism works by slowly wearing away the wheel rim, one of the most important structural parts of the bicycle, what do you reckon?" In 10 years time, you'll look back and wonder what all the fuss was about.

Avatar
mrmo [2019 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

didn't mavic get into trouble with the UCI over the shape of their levers? those are looking similar to what was banned. Wouldn't be hard to design those levers for aero advantage.

Avatar
brodibike [17 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

That's a brute. I still have a set of Magura HS66 Road lever hydraulic brakes. Levers are same size as an old drop lever pre STI/Ergo. They never caught on, work well, stop on one finger, but the blocks mash alloy road rims  16

Avatar
Graham Howell [49 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Ok ok maybe I was a little bit quick to judge but from my perspective (student trying to make 1st cat) its tough to keep up with all the advantages big budget teams get when I can barely afford to keep up my 105 equiped race bike (a second hand 2006 spesh tarmac comp).

Im all for technological advancements but there needs to be alot more focus on the middle ground. It took 2 years for the new shape shimano to make it down from Dura Ace to 105, by that time D-Ace had gone electric with a huge mark up in price. Whens Di2 gonna make it into the 105 end of the range?

Avatar
Chuck [521 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
Animal wrote:

Ugly. Expensive. Non maintainable. Over complicated. Why? Just why?

What about people who just want a decent, lightweight road bike which we can maintain ourselves, change or adjust derailleurs and brakes?

They should probably buy one. They haven't disappeared.

Animal wrote:

We don't all want to spend 5000 fekking quid on tricksy toys to impress our fat friends!

Then don't.

Quote:

The equipment companies are just ripping everybody off. "up"grading things year after year after year.

How are you being ripped off here exactly?

I think my 105 equipped Scott has many more years and miles left in it, and I don't see parts disappearing from the shelves anytime soon. If Shimano and the rest were suddenly in a position to break my stuff and force me to buy Di2 then maybe I'd agree, but that's not reality is it?

I don't understand why you're getting so wound up with what's happening at the cutting edge- you'd think it was a personal insult. Unless you're riding something with solid tyres and rod brakes I don't see how you can be so against development.

Avatar
monty dog [446 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

As anyone whose crashed and repaired bikes know, it's the top of the STi shifter that often takes the brunt/ hit in a crash which results in a broken lever body and a big bill - so you're probably looking at £300/ lever for a big off. The addage "only race what you can afford to crash" wouldn't be more apt.

Avatar
gbzpto [93 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

i like them

 1

Avatar
nick_rearden [434 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

Our spy found the original picture the detail at the top came from...

Avatar
quango2008 [34 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
Animal wrote:

Ugly. Expensive. Non maintainable. Over complicated. Why? Just why?

What about people who just want a decent, lightweight road bike which we can maintain ourselves, change or adjust derailleurs and brakes?

We don't all want to spend 5000 fekking quid on tricksy toys to impress our fat friends!

The equipment companies are just ripping everybody off. "up"grading things year after year after year.

Ugly = yes!
expensive = yes (but so is Dura ace..doesnt mean its junk)
over complicated...id say no, intact, probably more simple than producing a cable lever.
why = because everything progresses!

no, we all don't want to spend 5000 quid on toys, but some of us do, the people who can afford it, why not buy it? i have di2, I'm not fat, and i bought it for me...because i like it!

as for equipment companies ripping people off???? are you on glue? you are not obliged to buy it, no one is forcing you! of coarse they are going to upgrade what they have! how else are they going to make money?? and for your info...di2 dura ace has been around for 4 or more years now, the life cycle of most group sets are much longer than a year..do your research before your pointless rants  1

PS: im loaded...so don't give a toss how much it costs...if i like it, i'll buy it...fact.

Avatar
michophull [126 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
Animal wrote:

Ugly. Expensive. Non maintainable. Over complicated. Why? Just why?

What about people who just want a decent, lightweight road bike which we can maintain ourselves, change or adjust derailleurs and brakes?

We don't all want to spend 5000 fekking quid on tricksy toys to impress our fat friends!

The equipment companies are just ripping everybody off. "up"grading things year after year after year.

Well put Animal. Bicycle brakes work perfectly well using a cable and housing. It's cheap, suitable for purpose, and easy to repair and maintain.

Companies use the magic word "upgrade" in the same way that The Spanish Inquisition used the magic word "God".

What this effectively means is that because they've brought out something new, we're all supposed to whoop like halfwit Americans and proclaim it as "awesome". All that's happening is that we're expected to buy again something that we've already got.  14

Avatar
therevokid [911 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

interesting how they've put the front brake on the drive
side .... would have thought non-drive al la mtb's and
weight distribution would have made more sense ... still
it is a proto-type so who knows ...

Avatar
koko56 [330 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

All these rants are pathetic...

Those who are getting wound up of "being forced to upgrade" make me wound up because it's just pure stupidity. (yes, I see what I did there)

Avatar
Cooks [490 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

That is one seriously sexy bike, apart from the disc brakes. Not for me. Di2 is ace tho, tried it a couple of weeks back. Not too sure bout 11speed tho, it's all I can do to keep a 10 speed indexed properly.

Avatar
broomwagonblog [14 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

I can't wait for road bikes with disk brakes. Coming from a mountain biking background with immense stopping power from a single finger to cable actuated caliper brakes took some getting used to.

Cables dont inspire confidence, either. Riding down a fast hill the thought i always there that I can't pull up quickly should the need arise, or that the cable might snap, or that it might pull through the eyelet. At least with hydraulics these things can't happen.

It is a shame to see some fairly ludicrous statements on here too. Ah well.

Avatar
Arthur Scrimshaw [64 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes
Cooks wrote:

That is one seriously sexy bike, apart from the disc brakes. Not for me. Di2 is ace tho, tried it a couple of weeks back. Not too sure bout 11speed tho, it's all I can do to keep a 10 speed indexed properly.

I thought one of the big pluses of Di2 was that it was self adjusting?

Avatar
dave atkinson [6144 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

I know it's not everyone's cup of tea, but are you really being pressganged into buying it?

So far as I'm aware, there's no black van coming round to remove your current bike against your will, and last time I checked (just now) you could get a 7-speed cassette from from more than 30 stores online.

Things move forward. Sometimes (indexed gears, freehubs) it's a success. Sometimes (dual control MTB levers) it's not. Stuff that sucks generally doesn't catch on. If people don't want it, they don't buy it.

Avatar
russyparkin [570 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

evolution is brilliant, i dont have money to burn and i do look after my stuff. @graham the trickle down is a great thing for instance im running a combo of 5700 105 and 6700 ultegra. this can be had on £1000 bikes if you look around. i appreciate thats alot of money but relatively your getting essentially duraace from 2009/2010 for peanuts. and in terms of electric shifting / disc brakes bring it on.

there will always be a place for cable/rimbrakes etc and i personally am happy with cable/rimbrake set up. not to say if i look to replace my bike in 2-3 years if discs and by then im sure 105 electric are in place i would happily try it.

cyclists are a funny bunch,especially roadies for not liking change. i personally used to be a mountainbiker and remember the kick off about disc brakes. but now you cant buy a mtb without them and i guarantee no one would go back to v's.

just sit back wait a year or two all the options will be on the table.

Avatar
russyparkin [570 posts] 4 years ago
0 likes

on the plus side this website is like bikeradar for grown ups. bar a few 'burn the witch' posts most people seem to make productive and informative posts here

Pages