Five guilty of manslaughter over London cyclist's death

Cyclist killed yards from home unwittingly caught up in car chase between feuding drivers

by Simon_MacMichael   June 17, 2010  

Gavel

Five men have been convicted at the Old Bailey in London of manslaughter and causing the death by dangerous driving of a cyclist who unwittingly got caught up in a feud between them that resulted in a high-speed car chase through a London suburb.

Graham Thwaites, aged 51, who worked for a bank in the City of London, had been cycling home from Petts Wood train station when he was hit by a Mitsubishi Shogun driven by 35-year-old Andrew Carlisle on Leesons Hill, Orpington in September 2008.

Carlisle’s vehicle was being pursued at speeds of up to 60mph in the 30mph residential area by a Vauxhall Vectra containing containing William Dennard, 24, David Cook, 24, George Webb 27, and Shane Webb, 24.

During the trial, which opened last month, Mark Heywood QC, prosecuting, had told the court that the Shogun was “completely out of control” at the time of the fatal collision, and that it had twice been rammed by the chasing car.

He added that there was “great deal of animosity" between Carlisle and the four occupants of the Astra, apparently arising from a dispute over the cost of a rottweiler puppy.

The fatal crash happened just yards from the home where Mr Thwaites lived with his wife and two children.

Local newspaper the News Shopper quoted Detective Inspector Mark Cam, of the Metropolitan Police's road death investigation unit, as saying: "Mr Thwaites lost his life because Carlisle, Dennard, Cook and the Webbs were intent on airing their personal grievances out on a public road.

"They all drove dangerously, recklessly, above the speed limit and without any consideration for members of the public.

"This wasn't simply a case of bad driving, it was manslaughter and I am pleased with today's verdict. I hope it goes some small way to providing comfort to Mr Thwaites' family who have acted with great dignity throughout this investigation."
MrThwaite's widow, Hazel, added: "This senseless act of driving cost Graham his life,he is missed by all of his family and friends."

The men have been remanded in custody and will be sentenced on July 15.

 

4 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

Great that all five were convicted of manslaughter.

two wheels good; four wheels bad

posted by cat1commuter [1420 posts]
17th June 2010 - 10:34

1 Like

What's the maximum sentence for a manslaughter charge?

OldRidgeback

posted by OldRidgeback [2515 posts]
17th June 2010 - 15:01

0 Likes

You're not gonna like the answer!

"In England and Wales manslaughter has a "discretionary" life sentence, as opposed to the mandatory one for murder. This means the judge's discretion is used. He could impose any sentence at all, from an unconditional discharge, which means a conviction is recorded but no punishment given, right up to life imprisonment, or even a fine. Fines for manslaughter are normal where the defendant is a company rather than an individual (although it is usually easier to prosecute in such cases as a health and safety breach, as the punishment is the same and the conviction easier to obtain). An individual can expect a sentence of a few years."

Buddha said:

Believe nothing, No matter where you read it,
Or who has said it, Not even if I have said it,
Unless it agrees with your own reason
And your own common sense.

mad_scot_rider's picture

posted by mad_scot_rider [579 posts]
17th June 2010 - 16:11

1 Like

OldRidgeback,

All is not lost. It's true that although Life is the maximum sentence, very few people ever get this sentence. However, the Judge will ask for reports on each of the individuals and will take into account the circumstances and each of their involvement. I would personally guess that as they caused a death with a motor vehicle in a deliberate or reckless fashion, they are probably all looking at fairly lengthy sentences.

posted by Tom Amos [246 posts]
21st June 2010 - 18:11

0 Likes