New to Road Bike - Typical 'Which One' Dilemma

by dustyrunning   July 27, 2013  

I'm another road bike newbie, or at least trying to be having been with a MTB these past many years, and have narrowed down my choice to 3 new machines all available locally to me on the high street:

Specialized Secteur Elite 2013
Trek Domane 2.3C 2013
Giant Defy 1 Compact 2014

Have tested out all 3, they are about the same in £££ and each one is comfortable to me (I'm 1.83m and 83kg) in the appropriate frame size. I'm aiming to do the C2C later this year and expect to enjoy the experience and thus keep on riding. I don't expect to have a winter/summer bike choices in the future; upgrades aren't on the horizon yet.

There is obviously much expert knowledge out there in road.cc land that I hope will help in the final selection from my short-list; I know that there are loads of other bikes I haven't even heard of though but don't want to prevaricate forever! It's taken me 2 months to get this far

Is there something that makes one of the above 3 bikes stand out - good or bad - to help me decide? I know that this 'ask' is entirely subjective but member's thoughts on any aspect of my final 3 would be welcomed. I'm sure that my quest may seem fairly tedious to experienced road riders but I have to start somewhere.

Cheerzmadeerz
Thinking

6 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

Hello There and welcome to the forum.
My personal opining would be the trek domance 2.3. Ask for last year’s models bikes there has been some i have seen for 2k down to 1k and more bike for money.at the end of the day it comes down to you and what sutes you

posted by Ashleyhoaken [37 posts]
27th July 2013 - 12:50

like this
Like (4)

I don't think you'll go very far wrong with any of these, but just to add that Giant get very good write up's at the moment, and that the secteur is perhaps the less well received of the three in the cycling press.

You'll get happy owners of all the reporting back how much they love their bike!

posted by 700c [556 posts]
27th July 2013 - 16:56

like this
Like (6)

Many thanks indeed for your inputs and I had provisionally put the Specialized at 3rd choice on my informal list, not that on the face of it there is much between all of them.

I'll have another go on the Giant & Trek machines to see which which one just 'shades' it and then do the deal over the next couple of weeks. Availability doesn't seem to be a problem.

Will keep looking here though in case someone has a 'clincher' based on first hand knowledge etc.

Smile

New to the sport and keen to learn ....

posted by dustyrunning [3 posts]
28th July 2013 - 9:37

like this
Like (3)

dustyrunning wrote:
Will keep looking here though in case someone has a 'clincher' based on first hand knowledge etc.

They're all great bikes. You need to choose for yourself.

Simon E's picture

posted by Simon E [1946 posts]
28th July 2013 - 16:41

like this
Like (4)

Will do; have done; Trek it is.

New to the sport and keen to learn ....

posted by dustyrunning [3 posts]
29th July 2013 - 8:23

like this
Like (5)

dustyrunning wrote:
Will do; have done; Trek it is.

Excellent! Cool

Hope you enjoy it. Awaiting the 'first ride' report...

Simon E's picture

posted by Simon E [1946 posts]
29th July 2013 - 23:09

like this
Like (7)