Planet X RT58-S or 2013 Giant Defy 0 ??

by buckolfc   March 24, 2013  

I have only been cycling for the past 12 months! I bought a Hybrid using my works Cycle sceme. I did not think I was going to enjoy it as much as I have and now I have finished paying for the hybrid, it is time to upgrade!!

I commute 20 miles a day (all road), and try to do a longer ride on a Friday, maybe 30 miles. I have committed to do a coast to coast (170 miles in 2 days), 96km ride, and a 100 mile ride, all in the next 4 months so going from never owned a bike to all this I am planning on being busy!!

So anyway down to business!!

I have narrowed it down to two!

Either 2013 Giant Defy 0 - Great looks, tried and tested brand, good components, a great safe pick!


Planet X RT58-S - Looks amazing imo, stylish, full carbon, good components but not much in the way of reviews ect..

My heat says Planet x and my head says Giant!

Thanks for reading and any comments, tips would be greatly appreciated!

5 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

Both are good bikes. I'm sure that either will reward you well.

Having said that, have you thought of buying a cheap road bike for the commute and buying a better bike for weekend use? The daily commute bike will inevitably take some abuse. I personally would be reluctant to commute on a carbon frame.

Also, have you looked in the Canyon Outlet?

posted by londonplayer [671 posts]
24th March 2013 - 16:17


I understand what your saying about commuting but the roads are basically the same roads I would use at the weekend, plus I use the commute as part of my training and keeping fit, so its less commute and more exercise.

Also I cant use my cyclescheme voucher to get a Canyon! Top bikes though!

posted by buckolfc [2 posts]
24th March 2013 - 17:32


I guess I'd go for the Planet X then. Go Carbon if it's available over aluminium.

posted by londonplayer [671 posts]
24th March 2013 - 18:38


Have you tried the sales. Lots of sites selling last years models atcut down prices, sizes maybe the issue, it all depends if your lucky or not.
Try this one

posted by Tha cabbage [1 posts]
24th March 2013 - 19:06


I've got a planet X RT-57 and it's an absolutely stonking machine. If the RT58 is anywhere near as good, it too will make most of the "big brand" bikes look massively over-priced.

Oh, and Planet X themselves were a pleasure to deal with - unlike some of their competitors......

posted by Kestevan [38 posts]
25th March 2013 - 15:32